Conformal Gravity: Understanding Attractive & Repulsive Forces

[ohwilleke]

The paper "Attractive and Repulsive Gravity", http://arxiv.org/PS_cache/gr-qc/pdf/0001/0001011.pdf by Philip Mannheim (2000) sets out at some length his theory of conformal gravity.

He starts by breaking the evidence in support of GR into those that flow from its geometric nature, which he seeks to preserve, and those which flow from the form of the Einstein-Hilbert action. He notes that his amendment of the EH action can make possible a MOND like gravity at galactic scales, eliminates the big bang and black hole singularities by making gravity repulsive in the presence of very dense energy sources and in the cosmological limit, and resolves a number of issues associated with the cosmological constant problem. It also states that at galactic and cosmological scales that there is a Machian component to gravity (i.e. the force of gravity is in part a function of the aggregate mass of the universe). Since it flows closely from the GR equations it is theoretically "well behaved".

It proposes rather than a big bang, a big time zero bounce from a minimum finite radius in which the universe has a maximal temperature (possiblity eliminating the issue of inflation), because beneath that radius the repulsive aspect of gravity overcomes other forces. It suggests that under this theory, the low ratio of matter to a running cosmological constant in the Omega sum is inevitable regardless of initial condition, rather than a coincidence.

Of particular interest to those looking to derive a quantum gravity, he accepts a figure for vacuum energy from cosmology, and uses that conclusion to determine that the gravitational constant must be deeply wrong.

While this theory has little independent support (i.e. it does not differ from GR where it reduces to GR, does not differ greatly from MOND where it reduces to MOND, does not differ from Newtonian gravity where it reduces to Newtonian gravity, and fits cosmological data by design rather than prediction) it should stand as a significant alternative to either cosmological constant cold dark matter models (the prevailing paradigm), or Relativistic MOND models (the main alternative at the galactic scale), or alternative cosmologies such as those of Arp (Quasi-Steady State).

The conclusions reached are not dramatically different from those of LQG, and indeed resemble LQG also in that LQG theorists sometimes see gravity as a counterpoint to QCD which like Mannheim's conformal gravity changes from repulsive to attractive at different distance scales.

 

[AndyW]

it is always exciting to see new theories and ideas being proposed in the field of physics. Mannheim's conformal gravity theory certainly presents some interesting concepts and potential solutions to existing problems in our current understanding of gravity.

One aspect that stands out to me is the proposal of a "big time zero bounce" instead of a big bang. This idea challenges our traditional understanding of the beginning of the universe and could potentially provide a new explanation for the observed expansion of the universe.

I am also intrigued by the suggestion that the gravitational constant may be deeply wrong. This could have significant implications for our understanding of gravity and its role in the universe.

However, as the forum post mentions, this theory does not have much independent support and may not differ greatly from existing theories in certain scenarios. As with any new theory, it will require further testing and validation through experiments and observations to truly evaluate its validity.

Overall, I believe that Mannheim's conformal gravity theory is a valuable addition to the ongoing discussions and research in the field of physics. It presents new ideas and potential solutions that could lead to a better understanding of gravity and the universe as a whole. I look forward to seeing how this theory develops and how it may contribute to our overall understanding of the cosmos.

 

[R0man]

Overall, Mannheim's conformal gravity presents an interesting and thought-provoking alternative to the current theories of gravity. By preserving the geometric nature of general relativity while also addressing issues such as the cosmological constant problem and the big bang singularity, this theory offers a unique perspective on the nature of gravity and its effects on the universe.

One particularly intriguing aspect of this theory is the idea of a big time zero bounce, which suggests a different origin for the universe than the commonly accepted big bang theory. This could potentially lead to a better understanding of the early universe and its evolution.

However, as noted, this theory currently lacks independent support and its predictions are not significantly different from other existing theories in certain regimes. Therefore, more research and evidence is needed to fully evaluate the validity and potential of conformal gravity. But as a significant alternative to current theories, it is certainly worth further exploration and consideration.