High pass filter and low pass filter question?

AI Thread Summary
In a series circuit with a 1150 ohm resistor and a 144 nF capacitor configured as a low pass filter, the gain formula is incorrectly applied, leading to confusion in calculating the frequency for a gain of 0.25. The correct approach involves deriving the transfer function and understanding the relationship between angular frequency (ω) and frequency (f), where f = ω/2π. A participant recalculated ω to be approximately 1.5592 x 10^3, resulting in an incorrect frequency of 248.15 Hz. The discussion emphasizes the importance of sketching the circuit and deriving formulas rather than relying on potentially incorrect information. Ultimately, the correct frequency for the given parameters is suggested to be around 3724 Hz.
Grendelle
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
You have a series circuit consisting of a ac power supply, a 1150.0 ohm resistor and a 144.0 nF capacitor. If the circuit is configured as a low pass filter, what frequency will cause the gain to be 0.25?
Formula
Gain = Vout / Vin = R / [R^2 + (1/ωC)^2]^1/2Solution
Plugging in R=1150 ohms
C=144*10^-9 F

to find a value for ω

And then using ω=2 π f
I got f= 0.05223Hz which is wrong.

Also what will be the formula for high pass filter?
Please help!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Show your calculations for finding ##\omega##.
 
Grendelle;3785438[b said:
Formula[/b]
Gain = Vout / Vin = R / [R^2 + (1/ωC)^2]^1/2
Also what will be the formula for high pass filter?
Please help!

1. Formula for gain is wrong.

2. Gain expression for high-pass would be ωRC/√(1 + ω2R2C2)
 
Calculations for ω

ω=2∏f

The formula by prof has given me is Gain = Vout / Vin = R / [R^2 + (1/ωC)^2]^1/2 for a low pass filter.

0.25 = 1150 / [1150^2 + (1/ω*144*10^-9)^2]^1/2

My bad. I had a calculation mistake previously. I did it again and this time I solved it to get ω=1.5592*10^3
Using ω=2∏f, f=248.15 Hz.

Which is still wrong... :(I'm confused as to what frequency they are asking me for. Is the this frequency just plain ω? Am I making a mistake by calculating f=ω/2∏?
 
Grendelle said:
The formula by prof has given me is Gain = Vout / Vin = R / [R^2 + (1/ωC)^2]^1/2 for a low pass filter.
That is not a low pass filter. You seem to have dived into this problem without even sketching the circuit you are dealing with. Can you draw the circuit diagram for the low pass filter using the 2 specified components? Can you derive the transfer function Vout / Vin for it, rather than placing your faith in something without knowing whether it's the right formula or not?

I'm confused as to what frequency they are asking me for. Is the this frequency just plain ω? Am I making a mistake by calculating f=ω/2∏?
They are one and the same. But if in doubt, you can always write both.
 
Grendelle said:
Also what will be the formula for high pass filter?
You are asking the wrong question. What you should be asking of yourself at this point is, "What is the circuit for my high pass filter?"[/color]

Then determine for yourself its transfer function, and sketch it. That way, you can't go wrong.
 
Grendelle said:
Calculations for ω

ω=2∏f

The formula by prof has given me is Gain = Vout / Vin = R / [R^2 + (1/ωC)^2]^1/2 for a low pass filter.

0.25 = 1150 / [1150^2 + (1/ω*144*10^-9)^2]^1/2

My bad. I had a calculation mistake previously. I did it again and this time I solved it to get ω=1.5592*10^3
Using ω=2∏f, f=248.15 Hz.

Which is still wrong... :(


I'm confused as to what frequency they are asking me for. Is the this frequency just plain ω? Am I making a mistake by calculating f=ω/2∏?

No, you're right, f in Hz = ω/2π.

But the formula your prof gave you, if he really did, is still wrong.

Sketch the diagram for the low-pass circuit, write a summation of currents into the node at the capacitor. Then you can determine the right formula yourself. Don't just accept a formula from someone else, derive it for yourself, or you really won't learn what you need to.

BTW my answer is about 3724 Hz, is that what your prof got?
 

Similar threads

Back
Top