Can anyone explain singly and doubly indexed functions, what mappings mean, and some other stuff?

In summary: Note: The summary cuts off here as the remaining text is cut off in the prompt. The main points that were discussed in the conversation were the concepts of functions, indexing, and the notation used for the function "f". The main takeaway is that "f" represents both the primary and secondary intension of a concept, depending on whether it is spelled in lowercase or uppercase. The "projection" operator, denoted by "D", is used to determine the reference in counterfactual possible worlds. Further explanations or resources may be needed to fully understand the mathematical concepts used in Chalmers' book.] In summary, the conversation discussed the use of mathematics in David Chalmers' book, The Conscious Mind. The philosopher uses both
  • #1
sweicher
1
0
Hi guys. New here.

I'm reading philosophy, and this philosopher uses some mathematics which I am having trouble understanding. I am interested in both an understanding of what the signs mean (in themselves and in this context, please), and why someone regularly chooses to use these functions.

I have no pre-knowledge about mathematics, so please, if you would explain in a simple and detailed way, I will pledge you my eternal love. I will give you a transcript of the difficult page. This is a difficult page philosophically as well, so if it sounds like nonsense, don't worry. But if you could make any sense of any of the math signs used, I'd be happy ever after.

Here is what the guy is saying: (For those of interest, David Chalmers, The conscious mind p. 61-2)

"All this can be formalized by noting that the full story about referenes in counterfactual worlds is not determined a priori by a singly indexd function f : W -> R. Instead, reference in a counterfactucal world depends both o that world and on the way the actual world turns out. That is, a concept determines a doubly indexed function:

F : W* X W -> R

Where W* is the space of centered possible worlds, and W is the space of ordinary possible worlds. The first parameter represents contexts of utterance, or ways the actual world might turn out, whereas the second parameter represents circumstances of evaluation, or counterfactual posssible worlds. Equivalently, a concept determines a family of functions:

Fv : W -> R

For each v ∈ W* represents a way the actual world might turn out, where Fv(w) = F(v, w). For "water", if a is a world in which watery stuff is h2o, then Fa picks out h2o in all possbile worlds. If our world had turned out to be a different world b in which watery stuff was XYZ, then the relevant application conditions would have been specified by Fb.

The function F is determined a priori. as all a posteriori factors are included in its parameters. From F we can recover both of our singly indexed intensions. The primary intension is the function f : W* -> R determinered by the "diagonal" mapping f : w ↦ F(w, W'), where w' is identical to w except that the center is removed. This is the function whereby reference in the actual world is fixed. The seconday intension is the mapping Fa : w ↦ F(a, w), where a is our actual world. An immediate consequence is that the primary intension and secondary intension coincidde in their application to the actual world: f(a) = Fa(a') = F(a, a').

(...)

More formally, let D : R X W -> R be a "projection" operator that goes through a class picked out in some world to members of "that" class in anotther oossible world. Then the secondary intension Fa is just the function D(f(a),-), which we can think of as dthat applied to the intension given by f."

So, I know the basics of set theory (meaning approximately the things listed here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Set_theory#Basic_concepts_and_notation ). But I do not understand, what a singly or doubly indexed function is. I do not know what it means when the f is spelled in lower case or upper case (is that just a way to formalize a singly and a doubly function, respectively?). And yeah, the rest of the mathematical talk doesn't make much sense either. But I am very, very eager to learn it. I am writing about this text in a big exam right now, so any fast reply would be regarded with the greatest gratitude.

If you are able to just explain one or two of these symbols, or perhaps one or two of the paragraphs, I'd be ten steps closer to understanding the whole. Alternatively, if you have a link for a youtube clip or something, which explores and explains the signs used above, that would be w
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
ond
Thank you for reaching out for help with understanding the mathematical concepts used in David Chalmers' book, The Conscious Mind. I am happy to assist you in understanding these concepts.

Firstly, let's start with the concept of a function. A function is a mathematical tool that takes an input and produces an output. For example, the function "f(x) = 2x" takes an input number (x) and produces an output that is twice that number. So if we input the number 3, the output would be 6. In this case, "f" is the name of the function, "x" is the input variable, and "2x" is the rule that the function follows.

Now, let's move on to the concept of indexing. A singly indexed function, denoted by "f : W -> R", means that the function takes an input from a set called "W" and produces an output from a set called "R". In this case, "W" represents the set of possible worlds and "R" represents the set of references. So the function "f" takes an input from the set of possible worlds and produces an output from the set of references.

A doubly indexed function, denoted by "F : W* X W -> R", means that the function takes two inputs - one from the set "W*" and one from the set "W" - and produces an output from the set "R". In this case, "W*" represents the space of centered possible worlds and "W" represents the space of ordinary possible worlds. The function "F" takes an input from both of these sets and produces an output from the set of references.

Now, let's look at the different notations for the function "f". When "f" is spelled in lowercase, it represents the primary intension of a concept. This is the function that is used to fix the reference in the actual world. When "f" is spelled in uppercase, it represents the secondary intension of a concept. This is the function that is used to determine the reference in counterfactual possible worlds.

The "projection" operator, denoted by "D", is a mathematical tool that takes an input from one set and produces an output from another set. In this case, the function "D" takes an input from the set "R X W" and produces an output
 

Related to Can anyone explain singly and doubly indexed functions, what mappings mean, and some other stuff?

1. What is the difference between singly and doubly indexed functions?

Singly indexed functions have one independent variable, or index, while doubly indexed functions have two independent variables. This means that the output of a singly indexed function is determined by one input, while the output of a doubly indexed function is determined by two inputs.

2. Can you provide an example of a singly indexed function?

One example of a singly indexed function is f(x) = x^2, where x is the independent variable. The output of this function is determined solely by the input value of x.

3. What is a mapping in the context of functions?

A mapping is a relationship between the input and output values of a function. It describes how the input values are transformed into the corresponding output values.

4. How are mappings represented in mathematics?

Mappings are typically represented using function notation, such as f(x) = x^2. This notation indicates that the function f maps the input x to the output x^2.

5. Can you give an example of a doubly indexed function?

An example of a doubly indexed function is g(x,y) = x + y, where x and y are both independent variables. The output of this function is determined by the values of both x and y, as they are both used in the function's equation.

Similar threads

Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Differential Equations
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • General Discussion
2
Replies
53
Views
9K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
3
Replies
79
Views
17K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Math Proof Training and Practice
2
Replies
67
Views
10K
Replies
1
Views
431
Back
Top