Does electric charge bend anything?

In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of bending space-time fabric and whether electric charge has a similar effect. It is explained that electromagnetism is not modeled the same way as gravity and is instead treated differently by quantum physics. The difficulty in visualizing the 4-dimensional nature of space-time is also mentioned. The concept of forces and resistance is also touched upon, with examples such as the strong nuclear force and magnetic force. It is clarified that force can only exist as a result of an interaction and that resistance is not a general physical definition.
  • #1
Prof Sabi
33
4
If mass is considered to bend space time fabric..
does electric charge bends anything?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
No. Electromagnetism is not modeled the same way that gravity is. Instead, EM is modeled by quantum physics, which treats the three non-gravitational fundamental forces very differently than General Relativity treats gravity.
 
  • #3
Prof Sabi said:
If mass is considered to bend space time fabric..

and there is no space-time fabric :smile:
 
  • #4
davenn said:
and there is no space-time fabric :smile:
well many people believe this but why not space ime fabric
 
  • #5
Prof Sabi said:
well many people believe this but why not space ime fabric

Davenn means that 'fabric' is a misleading word. A fabric is usually thought of as a 2-dimensional object (or very thin 3-dimensional). However spacetime is 4-dimensional, with 3 dimensions of space and 1 of time. The diagram of a sheet being bend downwards by a massive objects is a 2-dimensional analogue of what is really going on. Unfortunately it's just really, really hard to visualize the curvature of a 4-D manifold. :biggrin:
 
  • Like
Likes davenn
  • #6
Drakkith said:
Davenn means that 'fabric' is a misleading word. A fabric is usually thought of as a 2-dimensional object (or very thin 3-dimensional). However spacetime is 4-dimensional, with 3 dimensions of space and 1 of time. The diagram of a sheet being bend downwards by a massive objects is a 2-dimensional analogue of what is really going on. Unfortunately it's just really, really hard to visualize the curvature of a 4-D manifold. :biggrin:
thats the thing :smile:
 
  • #7
I can't think of any force , no matter it's origin or it's composition ; would not have any effect on matter in it's path or in it's surrounding.
 
  • #8
roger larouche said:
I can't think of any force , no matter it's origin or it's composition ; would not have any effect on matter in it's path or in it's surrounding.

The strong nuclear force does not interact with electrons, even if they pass through the nucleus of an atom.
 
  • #9
Drakkith said:
The strong nuclear force does not interact with electrons, even if they pass through the nucleus of an atom.

The definition of a force do not have any value without resistance in it's path or in it's surrounding ~~ and ''Energy has the same definition''
 
  • #10
roger larouche said:
The definition of a force do not have any value without resistance in it's path or in it's surrounding ~~ and ''Energy has the same definition''

I'm sorry, I have no idea what you're getting at.
 
  • #11
roger larouche said:
I can't think of any force, no matter its origin or its composition ; would not have any effect on matter in its path or in its surrounding.
Magnetic force, for instance, has no effect on plastic or glass.
 
  • #13
Charge does bend EM waves.
We use the variation in Refractive Index to bend light through lenses in optical systems. That is because the RI, represents the relative velocity of the propagation of EM waves. RI = c / v.

Refractive Index is wavelength dependent and is determined by the density distribution of charge, and the rigidity of the molecules or space that contains that charge.

Dispersion results in rainbows. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dispersion_(optics
See; https://www.pdx.edu/nanogroup/sites/www.pdx.edu.nanogroup/files/3_1___Microscopic_view_of_the_index_of_refraction_PRINT_2.pdf
 
  • #14
David Lewis said:
Magnetic force, for instance, has no effect on plastic or glass.

A force cannot be created nor calculated at it's value ; if it's ''opponent'' ( plastic ) do not offer any resistance
 
  • #15
roger larouche said:
A force cannot be created nor calculated at it's value ; if it's ''opponent'' ( plastic ) do not offer any resistance

Your preceding posts are very unclear. Are you talking about force in the context of an applied force, such as what would accelerate an object (without regard to the specific fundamental interaction responsible for the acceleration), or are you talking about force in the context of a fundamental interaction and its accompanying rules?
 
  • #16
roger larouche said:
Yes~Forces only exist as a result of an interaction. witch mean; +++ resistance more forces.
As force involves acceleration, something has to be accelerated, which does not want to. It's usually called Newton's first law, and not "resistance". La résistance was a Belgian and French movement against the German occupation during WWII.

Any other definition will have first to be given, e.g. friction, air resistance, rolling resistance, electric resistance and so forth. There is no general physical definition of resistance in its own right. It splits into what is specifically meant. Maybe you talk about inertia, which again brings us back to Newton's first law.
 

1. How does electric charge cause bending?

The movement of electric charges creates an electric field around the source of the charge. This electric field interacts with other charges, causing them to experience a force and potentially move. When the electric field is non-uniform, the charges will experience a net force in a particular direction, resulting in bending.

2. Can electric charge bend light?

Yes, electric charges can bend light through the phenomenon of refraction. When light passes through a medium with varying electric fields, such as a prism, the light will bend due to the interaction with the electric charges in the medium.

3. Is electric charge the only factor that can cause bending?

No, there are other factors that can cause bending, such as gravity or magnetic fields. However, in many cases, electric charge is the dominant factor in bending due to its strong interaction with other charges.

4. Can electric charge bend matter?

Yes, electric charge can bend matter through the electromagnetic force. When two charged particles are close to each other, they can experience a force that causes them to move and bend, depending on their charges and distances from each other.

5. Does the amount of electric charge determine the degree of bending?

Yes, the amount of electric charge can determine the degree of bending. The stronger the electric charge, the stronger the electric field and the greater the force experienced by other charges, resulting in more pronounced bending effects.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
553
Replies
22
Views
882
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
9
Views
559
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
3
Views
993
Replies
73
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
504
Replies
14
Views
1K
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
3
Views
804
Back
Top