- #1
johnykhan
- 8
- 0
Does it matter where I am doing my PhD from?
who got his PhD from Cambridge.Vanadium 50 said:Pakistan's treatment of its only Nobel prize winner was shameful,
Vanadium 50 said:Employers care about the quality of the institution. That is correlated with the country it is in. I'm afraid the very best schools in Pakistan do not compare with even a poor research university in North America or Europe.
Pakistan's treatment of its only Nobel prize winner was shameful, so this does not come as a great surprise.
Vanadium 50 said:It sounds like you had an answer in mind and are unhappy you're not getting it.
Locrian said:I'll add it also (maybe ultimately) matters who you are doing it with.
johnykhan said:Please elaborate I couldn't get you on "it also (maybe ultimately) matters who you are doing it with."
johnykhan said:The first part of your reply was perfectly fine in which you said: "Employers care about the quality of the institution. That is correlated with the country it is in." But in your claim "I'm afraid the very best schools in Pakistan do not compare with even a poor research university in North America or Europe. Pakistan's treatment of its only Nobel prize winner was shameful, so this does not come as a great surprise"; you didn't give a proper reason rather made a criticism. That's why I needed to correct you on that. Otherwise I am cool and hope you didn't mind as well. Cheers
Mike H said:What matters more than the name of the university is your graduate advisor and the work you do with them. Just because one speaks of a "brand-name university," it does not mean that they have the very best people in each and every subfield of every discipline. In fact, you may find that they don't have *anyone* in your areas of interest.
Locrian said:And there are some examples of colleges that are "only" good having great programs in specific areas. It's not just what you know, but who your advisor knows.
iRaid said:I think vandium is right though, I have never heard of any very good schools in Pakistan..
johnykhan said:"I'm afraid the very best schools in Pakistan do not compare with even a poor research university in North America or Europe." I differ with you on this because I have seen graduates of European schools struggling in front of Pakistani graduates; I am sorry I won't buy it.
In reply to your comment "Pakistan's treatment of its only Nobel prize winner was shameful, so this does not come as a great surprise." is out of context to the question. And on the ground that the treatment of employers outside Pakistan towards Pakistani graduates is not based on the reciprocity of treatment given to foreign graduates and laureates by Pakistani employers.
Yes, the reputation of the university where you obtain your PhD can have a significant impact on your future career prospects. Employers and academic institutions often consider the prestige and ranking of the university when making hiring decisions. A degree from a highly reputable university may open up more opportunities for you in your field.
The answer to this question depends on your personal goals and career aspirations. A PhD from a well-known university abroad may provide you with a global perspective and networking opportunities, but it may also come with a higher cost and longer duration. On the other hand, a PhD from a local university may be more affordable and allow you to maintain your current personal and professional commitments.
While the reputation of the university is important, it is not the only factor that determines the value of a PhD. The quality of your research, publications, and contributions to your field of study are also highly regarded. A PhD from a less prestigious university can still hold value if you have produced high-quality research and have a strong track record of academic achievements.
The location of the university can play a role in your PhD studies, but it is not the most crucial factor. It may affect factors such as cost of living, access to research facilities, and job opportunities. However, with the advancements in technology, many universities offer online programs, making the location less relevant for your studies.
Generally, a PhD degree from a recognized university will be recognized internationally. However, it is important to do your research and ensure that the university you choose is accredited and has a good reputation in your field of study. This will help ensure that your degree is recognized and valued by employers and academic institutions globally.