Eliminating the coincidence counter

In summary, the conversation discusses the effect of leaving out the coincidence counter in DCQE on the results at D0 and whether measuring the particle in an experiment affects the interference pattern. The question also arises about the role of human observation and whether destroying information about the experiment can still affect the results.
  • #1
Fiziqs
134
0
In DCQE, if you leave out the coincidence counter, does it effect the results at D0? Or is it impossible to know?

What I want to know is...do you collapse the wave when you measure the particle...or does that information need to be accessible to a human observer.

Or even simpler...in the double slit experiment, if you measure which slit the particle went through, and then destroy any information about the result, without ever knowing what it was, does the interference pattern disappear?

Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Fiziqs said:
Or even simpler...in the double slit experiment, if you measure which slit the particle went through, and then destroy any information about the result, without ever knowing what it was, does the interference pattern disappear?
Thanks

If which slit information was written by a robot arm onto paper and then the paper burnt, so no observer could read it ever again? hmmmm...
 
  • #3
for your question. Eliminating the coincidence counter in DCQE may or may not affect the results at D0, depending on the specific experiment being conducted. The coincidence counter is used to detect and record simultaneous events, and its absence could potentially lead to missed data or inaccurate measurements. However, it is impossible to know for sure without conducting the experiment and analyzing the results.

As for the concept of wave collapse and the role of human observation in quantum mechanics, it is a highly debated and complex topic. According to the Copenhagen interpretation, the act of measurement by a human observer is what causes the wave function to collapse and determines the state of the particle. However, there are other interpretations that propose different explanations for wave collapse and the role of observation.

In regards to the double slit experiment, if you measure which slit the particle went through and then destroy the information without ever knowing the result, it is likely that the interference pattern would still disappear. This is because the act of measurement itself disrupts the quantum system and alters the outcome. However, the exact outcome would depend on the specific experimental setup and conditions.
 

1. What is a coincidence counter?

A coincidence counter is a device used in scientific research to detect and count simultaneous events, such as the detection of two or more particles at the same time.

2. Why would someone want to eliminate a coincidence counter?

Eliminating a coincidence counter can reduce background noise and increase the accuracy of measurements, making it easier to detect and study rare events.

3. How does eliminating the coincidence counter affect data collection?

Without a coincidence counter, data collection may take longer as researchers must wait for individual events to occur instead of detecting multiple events simultaneously. However, the data collected may be more precise and reliable.

4. Are there any downsides to eliminating the coincidence counter?

Depending on the research being conducted, eliminating the coincidence counter may limit the types of events that can be studied. It may also require more specialized equipment or techniques for data collection.

5. How do scientists determine if eliminating the coincidence counter is necessary for their research?

Scientists must carefully consider the goals and methods of their research to determine if eliminating the coincidence counter will benefit their study. This decision may also depend on the availability of alternative methods for detecting and studying events of interest.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
2
Views
946
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
23
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
1
Views
786
Replies
5
Views
782
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
2
Views
286
  • Quantum Physics
2
Replies
36
Views
1K
Back
Top