Has a change in the cosmic rays hitting Earth been causing Global Warming?

In summary, there is a controversial website claiming that galactic cosmic rays have a significant influence on Earth's climate. However, there is limited evidence to support this claim and it is not widely accepted in the scientific community. The website is hosted in a politically charged area, adding to the skepticism surrounding the information presented. The thread discussing this topic has been closed due to a lack of evidence and violating community guidelines.
Earth sciences news on Phys.org
  • #2
Where is the evidence that there has been any change in the cosmic ray flux?
 
  • #3
Here's some of the text:
When galactic cosmic rays increased during the Earth's last geomagnetic reversal transition 780,000 years ago, the umbrella effect of low-cloud cover led to high atmospheric pressure in Siberia, causing the East Asian winter monsoon to become stronger. This is evidence that galactic cosmic rays influence changes in the Earth's climate. The findings were made by a research team led by Professor Masayuki Hyodo (Research Center for Inland Seas, Kobe University) and published on June 28 in the online edition of Scientific Reports.
The Svensmark Effect is a hypothesis that galactic cosmic rays induce low cloud formation and influence the Earth's climate. Tests based on recent meteorological observation data only show minute changes in the amounts of galactic cosmic rays and cloud cover, making it hard to prove this theory. However, during the last geomagnetic reversal transition, when the amount of galactic cosmic rays increased dramatically, there was also a large increase in cloud cover, so it should be possible to detect the impact of cosmic rays on climate at a higher sensitivity.
In the Chinese Loess Plateau, just south of the Gobi Desert near the border of Mongolia, dust has been transported for 2.6 million years to form loess layers — sediment created by the accumulation of wind-blown silt — that can reach up to 200 meters in thickness. If the wind gets stronger, the coarse particles are carried further, and larger amounts are transported. Focusing on this phenomenon, the research team proposed that winter monsoons became stronger under the umbrella effect of increased cloud cover during the geomagnetic reversal. They investigated changes in particle size and accumulation speed of loess layer dust in two Loess Plateau locations.
In both locations, for about 5000 years during the geomagnetic reversal 780,000 years ago, they discovered evidence of stronger winter monsoons: particles became coarser, and accumulation speeds were up to > 3 times faster. These strong winter monsoons coincide with the period during the geomagnetic reversal when the Earth's magnetic strength fell to less than ¼, and galactic cosmic rays increased by over 50%. This suggests that the increase in cosmic rays was accompanied by an increase in low-cloud cover, the umbrella effect of the clouds cooled the continent, and Siberian high atmospheric pressure became stronger.
Added to other phenomena during the geomagnetic reversal — evidence of an annual average temperature drop of 2-3 degrees Celsius, and an increase in annual temperature ranges from the sediment in Osaka Bay — this new discovery about winter monsoons provides further proof that the climate changes are caused by the cloud umbrella effect.
"The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has discussed the impact of cloud cover on climate in their evaluations, but this phenomenon has never been considered in climate predictions due to the insufficient physical understanding of it," comments Professor Hyodo. (emphasis added)
"This study provides an opportunity to rethink the impact of clouds on climate. When galactic cosmic rays increase, so do low clouds, and when cosmic rays decrease clouds do as well, so climate warming may be caused by an opposite-umbrella effect. The umbrella effect caused by galactic cosmic rays is important when thinking about current global warming as well as the warm period of the medieval era."
 
  • #4
Where is the evidence that there has been any change in the cosmic ray flux in historic times?
 
  • #6
PF science forums are not here to debunk invalid claims. Moved to General Discussion.
 
  • #7
jim mcnamara said:
PF science forums are not here to debunk invalid claims. Moved to General Discussion.

Is that GD's function? In the past it was not.

I think the whole thread is off to a poor start, since it assumes facts not in evidence: that the cosmic ray flux is changing on timescales relevant to climate change. The OP should have done his due diligence before starting this thread.
 
  • #8
swampwiz said:
The website is hosted at the Northern Marianna Islands, making me even more suspicious

Why?
 
  • #9
This thread doesn't meet the CC guidelines and is closed.
 

1. What are cosmic rays and how do they affect Earth's climate?

Cosmic rays are high-energy particles that originate from outer space. They are constantly bombarding Earth's atmosphere and can have an impact on the planet's climate by influencing cloud formation.

2. Is there evidence to suggest that a change in cosmic rays is causing global warming?

While some studies have suggested a possible link between cosmic rays and climate change, the majority of scientific research does not support this claim. Other factors, such as greenhouse gas emissions, are considered to be the primary drivers of global warming.

3. How do scientists study the effects of cosmic rays on Earth's climate?

Scientists use a variety of methods to study the impact of cosmic rays on Earth's climate, including satellite observations, laboratory experiments, and computer simulations. They also analyze historical data and compare it to current trends to understand any potential correlations.

4. Can changes in cosmic rays be responsible for the recent increase in global temperatures?

No, the current increase in global temperatures is primarily attributed to human activities, such as burning fossil fuels and deforestation. While cosmic rays may play a role in climate change, their impact is considered to be minimal compared to other factors.

5. Are there any potential benefits to a decrease in cosmic rays?

Some studies have suggested that a decrease in cosmic rays could lead to a decrease in cloud cover and therefore, warmer temperatures. However, this is not considered a desirable outcome as it could have negative impacts on agriculture, water resources, and other aspects of the environment.

Similar threads

Replies
27
Views
11K
  • Earth Sciences
6
Replies
184
Views
44K
  • Earth Sciences
4
Replies
106
Views
35K
  • Earth Sciences
2
Replies
35
Views
21K
Replies
2
Views
17K
Replies
15
Views
4K
Replies
16
Views
8K
Replies
17
Views
6K
Replies
7
Views
7K
Back
Top