How does quantum superposition really work?

In summary, superposition is the concept of expressing any state as a linear combination of other states in a chosen basis. This is similar to how we can write numbers in different ways, but still end up with the same value. In practice, we choose a basis that makes our calculations easier, such as when analyzing the polarization of a photon. This helps us understand quantum mechanics and quantum computers, but it is not the only factor at play.
  • #1
Curious Cat
9
0
TL;DR Summary
I understand how to put a quantum particle into a superposition, by
passing it thru 2 slits or a beam splitter, which U can say actually
splits the wave, function, but
How does putting it potentially inbetween 2 basis states, which U
will measure only later, on, do it!? That seems like magic, to me. And
yet I accept that it does. Somehow.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Have you ever studied vectors? E.g. although gravity is a vertical force, we can decompose it into components in any basis. E.g. when analysing motion along an inclined plane we decompose it into components normal to and tangential to the plane.

That's superposition. Not magic!
 
  • #3
PeroK said:
Have you ever studied vectors? E.g. although gravity is a vertical force, we can decompose it into components in any basis. E.g. when analysing motion along an inclined plane we decompose it into components normal to and tangential to the plane.

That's superposition. Not magic!
Thank you, for your reply:
Well, yes, of course.
Are you saying that that's all QSP is!?
Then how does that explain the quantum computers?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #4
Curious Cat said:
Thank you for your reply:
. Well, yes, of course.
. Are you saying that that's all QSP is!?
Then how does that explain the quantum computers?
That's all superposition is: quantum States are (abstract) vectors and may be expressed in any basis - which means an infinite choice of superposition for any state.

It takes more than the concept of superposition to explain QM and quantum computers.
 
  • Like
Likes mattt
  • #5
Curious Cat said:
How does putting it potentially inbetween 2 basis states, which U
will measure only later, on, do it!?
As @PeroK says above, states add like vectors so any state can be written as the sum (more precisely, a linear combination) of other states. Typically when we start in on a problem we choose a set of vectors that we call the basis, and then we write everything else as a superposition of these basis vectors; but we could choose a different basis and then some of the states that were written as superpositions before might no longer be.

For example: Let's call the photon state that we informally describe as "polarized at a 45-degree angle clockwise" ##|45\rangle##; there's a state that is orthogonal to that one, we'll call it ##|-45\rangle##. If we choose to use these two vectors as our basis then we would write the state of a vertically polarized photon as the superposition ##\frac{\sqrt{2}}{2}(|45\rangle+|-45\rangle)##. However, we could also choose to use the states "polarized vertically" and "polarized horizontally" as our basis (let's call them ##|V\rangle## and ##|H\rangle##); now the state of a vertically polarized photon would be written as simply ##|V\rangle## - no superposition. But it's the same state either way, and there's no more magic involved than in noting that we can write "5" or "3+2" and it's the same number either way.

In practice we generally try to choose a basis that make the problem at hand easy. If we're planning to send a photon through a vertical polarizer at some stage of our experiment we'll probably want to use the ##|H\rangle##,##|V\rangle## basis just because we can read the probability amplitude for passing through the filter directly from the state. In this basis the state will look like ##\alpha|V\rangle+\beta|H\rangle## and the probability amplitude will be ##\alpha##. If instead we chose to use the ##|45\rangle##,##|-45\rangle## basis we'd have to do some extra algebra to get the same result.
 
  • Like
Likes mattt

1. What is quantum superposition?

Quantum superposition is a fundamental principle in quantum mechanics where a particle can exist in multiple states or positions simultaneously. This means that until it is observed or measured, the particle exists in a combination of all possible states at the same time.

2. How does quantum superposition work?

Quantum superposition works by utilizing the wave-like behavior of particles at the quantum level. Instead of being confined to a single state, particles can exist in a superposition of states, with each state having a certain probability of being observed when measured.

3. What is the difference between classical and quantum superposition?

In classical physics, objects can only exist in one state at a time, while in quantum mechanics, particles can exist in multiple states simultaneously. This is due to the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics and the wave-particle duality of particles at the quantum level.

4. How is quantum superposition observed or measured?

Quantum superposition is observed or measured through a process called wave function collapse. This occurs when the particle is observed or interacts with its environment, causing it to collapse into a single state. The specific state it collapses into can be determined by measuring the probability amplitudes of each possible state.

5. What are the applications of quantum superposition?

Quantum superposition has many practical applications, such as in quantum computing, where the ability to exist in multiple states simultaneously allows for more efficient and powerful calculations. It also plays a crucial role in technologies such as MRI machines and atomic clocks.

Similar threads

  • Quantum Physics
Replies
2
Views
924
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
4
Replies
124
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
602
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
5
Replies
143
Views
6K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
22
Views
1K
Replies
10
Views
953
Replies
3
Views
645
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
12
Views
675
Back
Top