How much electricity is required to create a magnetic field as large & strong as the Earth's?

  • #1
Mikael17
40
3
TL;DR Summary
Earth's magnetic field
How much power (Megawatts) would it require if we were to create a magnetic field as large and strong as the Earth's magnetic field?. I haven't learned how to calculate this, but just curious.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
These aren't even the right units. A watt is a unit of power. That's like asking how many megawatts it takes to get from New York to Las Vegas.
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71
  • #3
That's the wrong question to ask. It takes zero power to maintain a magnetic field, although if you are using an electromagnet and aren't using superconductors it takes power to maintain the current. So the answer to the power requirement is between zero and absolutely enormous, depending on how you build your solenoid.

The question you probably want to ask is about energy. How much energy is stored in the Earth's magnetic field? Unfortunately, I don't know the answer. The energy density of a magnetic field of strength ##B## in a volume with magnetic permeability ##\mu\mu_0## is ##B^2/2\mu\mu_0##, but to get the total energy you need to integrate that over the whole volume of the field, and I don't know how ##B## varies. It's about 50 micro Tesla at Earth's surface and the magnetosphere extends to about 100,000km on the day side. It's much longer on the night side, but much weaker too. And I've no idea how it varies inside the Earth.

Finger in the wind, try a sphere of radius 100,000km and a B field of 50 micro Tesla with ##\mu=1##. ##\mu_0\approx 10^{-6}\mathrm{H/m}##. That'll come out on the order ##10^{21}\mathrm{J}##.

There are so many approximations there that I wouldn't really trust the number. However, note that the total power generation capacity of the world is on the order of a terrawatt. You'd need all of that for a few centuries to generate ##10^{21}\mathrm{J}##. So even if my estimate is off by a few orders of magnitude, it's more energy than is readily available. And we haven't even discussed the infrastructure needed to generate a field like that - the cooling capacity for superconductors the size of the Earth would increase the energy budget many, many times.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes vanhees71

1. How much electricity is required to create a magnetic field as large & strong as the Earth's?

Creating a magnetic field as large and strong as the Earth's would require an enormous amount of electricity. The Earth's magnetic field is generated by the movement of molten iron in its outer core, a process that is not easily replicated on a smaller scale. The exact amount of electricity needed would depend on the size of the artificial magnetic field and the method used to generate it.

2. Is it even possible to generate a magnetic field as large & strong as the Earth's with electricity?

While it is theoretically possible to generate a magnetic field as large and strong as the Earth's with electricity, the practical challenges are significant. The Earth's magnetic field is the result of complex processes deep within the planet, and replicating these conditions artificially would be extremely difficult. Additionally, the amount of electricity required would likely be prohibitively high.

3. How does the amount of electricity needed to create a magnetic field compare to other energy sources?

The amount of electricity needed to create a magnetic field as large and strong as the Earth's would likely far exceed the amount of energy produced by most other sources. Generating such a powerful magnetic field would require a massive input of energy, making it much more energy-intensive than most other processes. This is one of the reasons why creating an artificial magnetic field on Earth is currently not feasible.

4. Are there any potential applications for creating a magnetic field as large & strong as the Earth's?

While the practical challenges of creating a magnetic field as large and strong as the Earth's are significant, there could be potential applications for such a technology. For example, a powerful artificial magnetic field could be used for space exploration or to shield against solar radiation. However, the energy requirements and technical difficulties involved would need to be overcome before such applications could be realized.

5. What are the implications of attempting to create a magnetic field as large & strong as the Earth's?

Attempting to create a magnetic field as large and strong as the Earth's would have significant implications for energy consumption, technology development, and environmental impact. The amount of electricity needed would likely be enormous, raising concerns about sustainability and resource usage. Additionally, the technical challenges involved in generating such a powerful magnetic field would require significant advancements in engineering and physics.

Similar threads

Replies
11
Views
689
Replies
22
Views
903
  • Classical Physics
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
463
  • Classical Physics
Replies
16
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
693
  • Classical Physics
Replies
7
Views
857
Replies
15
Views
1K
Replies
26
Views
1K
  • Classical Physics
Replies
16
Views
186
Back
Top