Maintaining the same flow rate while subdivding a tube

In summary, the conversation discusses dividing a 5/8" tube into smaller tubes to maintain the same flow and pressure. It is suggested to use Poiseuille's equation to calculate the necessary number of smaller tubes, taking into account the effect of friction on flow rate. However, due to the fourth power relationship between flow rate and radial dimension, a significant amount of smaller tubes (possibly up to 6,000) may be needed to maintain the same flow and pressure as the single 5/8" tube.
  • #1
Pyper
4
0
I have a 5/8" tube that air is blown through. I want to subdivide the center section using .1" tubes so that the same volume of air can be blown through it. It will start as 5/8", but immediately be divided into the separate .1" tubes, then end as a single 5/8" tube. How many .1" tubes would I need to maintain the flow of the single 5/8" tube?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Ignoring friction with the pipe walls for the moment... mass conservation ensures that the same air that goes through the 5/8" section has to also pass through the tiny follow-on tubes, right?
Is the question instead that you want to maintain the same flow at the same pressure even though you are splitting the tube? If so, don't you want to maintain the same total pipe cross-section, ignoring friction?
 
  • #3
olivermsun said:
maintain the same flow at the same pressure
What does it mean to maintain the same flow at the same pressure? The same pressure gradient? Then Poiseuille's equation should help.
 
  • #4
Is the question instead that you want to maintain the same flow at the same pressure even though you are splitting the tube?

yes!
If so, don't you want to maintain the same total pipe cross-section, ignoring friction?

yes!

Basically I want to blow through the tube and it be just as easy to blow through when diverting to smaller tubes as it is with a straight 5/8" tube.

I did these simple calculations just based on area of a circle:

5/8" = 15.875mm = Area of 791.73
.1" = 2.54mm = Area of 20.268
791.73/20.268=39.063
So I would need 40 small .1" tubes to have the same flow rate and pressure of the single larger 5/8" tube.
Does that sound about right?
That seems like a lot!
5/8" is only .625, it seems like 7 smaller tubes would be enough..
My thinking may be flawed here...
 
Last edited:
  • #5
Pyper said:
Basically I want to blow through the tube and it be just as easy to blow through when diverting to smaller tubes as it is with a straight 5/8" tube.
So the total length is unchanged, but we want a bunch of 1mm capillaries to replace a single 5/8 inch tube and still present the same pressure drop at the same total volumetric flow rate.
I did these simple calculations just based on area of a circle:

5/8" = 15.875mm = Area of 791.73
.1" = 2.54mm = Area of 20.268
791.73/20.268=39.063
So I would need 40 small .1" tubes to have the same flow rate and pressure of the single larger 5/8" tube.
Does that sound about right?
It is far far worse than that. The flow rate through a tube goes as the fourth power of the radial dimension. The ratio of your radial dimensions here is 8.75 to 1. Raise that to the fourth power and you will need a bit under six thousand small tubes to get the same flow rate as that 5/8 inch tube at the same pressure drop.

Edit: corrected my figures to use 0.1 inch small tube rather than 1 mm small tube and added...

There is a reason for this seemingly extreme behavior. In a tube with laminar flow, friction means that the fluid near the tube walls is moving slowly while fluid near the center is moving more rapidly. The closer the walls are to the center, the slower the fluid at the center will move -- for a fixed pressure gradient.

Here is another link to the resulting flow equation: https://www.fxsolver.com/browse/formulas/Hagen-Poiseuille+Equation

The situation is worse yet if the flow is not laminar.
 
Last edited:
  • #6
jbriggs444 said:
What does it mean to maintain the same flow at the same pressure? The same pressure gradient?]
Yes.
jbriggs444 said:
Then Poiseuille's equation should help.
Yes, I agree that's what the OP should use if this is a practical problem where the pressure gradient is held more or less constant.
 
  • #7
This is blowing my mind, 6K tubes?
When bundled together they would be MANY times larger than the single 5/8" tube.
All this because of friction, even for air?
 
  • #8
Pyper said:
This is blowing my mind, 6K tubes?
When bundled together they would be MANY times larger than the single 5/8" tube.
All this because of friction, even for air?
Yes.

[Back of the envelope, since your scale ratio is 8.75 to one you'd need something 8.75 times fatter. A bundle of tubes about six inches in diameter and maybe a bit more by the time you account for wall thickness and the hexagonal packing arrangement]

If you want to change the scenario so that instead of tubes we are talking about a thin plate with holes then friction stops being as relevant. We'd need a real fluid dynamics person to talk about the ins and outs of choked flow in that case.
 
Last edited:
  • #9
Wow.
No, it is definitely tubes, I can't get around that..
Thank you for the info..
Lots of trial-and-error ahead.
 

Related to Maintaining the same flow rate while subdivding a tube

What is the purpose of maintaining the same flow rate while subdividing a tube?

Maintaining the same flow rate while subdividing a tube ensures that the amount of fluid passing through each section of the tube remains constant. This is important in experiments and industrial processes where precise measurements and consistency are crucial.

How can the flow rate be maintained while subdividing a tube?

The flow rate can be maintained by using a pump or other devices to create a steady flow of fluid through the tube. Additionally, the diameter and length of each section of the tube should be carefully calculated to ensure an equal distribution of the fluid.

What factors can affect the flow rate in a subdivided tube?

The flow rate in a subdivided tube can be affected by several factors, such as the viscosity of the fluid, the diameter and length of each section of the tube, and the pressure applied by the pump. Any changes in these factors can cause fluctuations in the flow rate.

What are the consequences of not maintaining the same flow rate in a subdivided tube?

If the flow rate is not maintained, it can lead to inaccurate results in experiments or inconsistent production in industrial processes. It can also cause issues with the equipment and potentially damage the tube or other components.

Are there any techniques to monitor and adjust the flow rate in a subdivided tube?

Yes, there are various techniques to monitor and adjust the flow rate in a subdivided tube. These include using flow meters or sensors to measure the flow rate, adjusting the pump speed, and manually adjusting the valve or pressure in the system.

Similar threads

Determining Reverse Mass Flow Rate Formula for Multiple Diameter Tubes
    • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
1K
B Beam of air: Extending the range of a fan
    • Other Physics Topics
Replies
17
Views
2K
I Amount of energy in wind blowing through a tube
    • Other Physics Topics
Replies
11
Views
2K
Fully developed flow, Reynolds number
    • Other Physics Topics
Replies
12
Views
3K
Flow of air through an open tube with a balloon
    • Mechanics
Replies
9
Views
2K
Gas conductance through tube at low pressure
    • General Engineering
Replies
3
Views
2K
Dialysate flow rate when pulling through a jug
    • Biology and Medical
Replies
2
Views
2K
Flow/pressure and venturi question
    • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
26
Views
2K
What is the Cooling Time for Steel Tubes with Ambient Nitrogen Gas Flow?
    • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
7
Views
2K
Understanding Standing Waves in Open Tubes
    • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
907

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top