- #1
klimatos
- 411
- 36
In his famous thought experiment of 1867, James Clerk Maxwell postulated a creature (later called a “demon” by Lord Kelvin) who could discern the speeds of gaseous molecules and who could pass selected molecules through a partition or deny them passage on the basis of those speeds. The essence of that “demon” was its ability to bar or pass molecules based on their speed.
May I suggest that the demon exists and is hard at work at every phase interface (water-vapor, water-ice, ice-vapor, etc.). The role of “demon” is played by the collective forces of molecular attraction. Water molecules moving toward the water surface from below will become vapor molecules only if their speed equals or exceeds the “escape velocity”. They will remain water molecules if their speed is less that that velocity. This is a selection based on speed.
The removal of faster (hotter) molecules from the water or ice phase reduces the temperature of that phase. The kinetic energy lost in overcoming the cohesive forces goes on the books as potential energy; i.e., the enthalpy of vaporization or the enthalpy of fusion.
Thus we see that Maxwell’s Demon does exist. He goes by many names: force of intermolecular attraction, surface tension, surface energy and so on. But he does exist and is hard at work doing exactly what Maxwell envisaged him doing.
May I suggest that the demon exists and is hard at work at every phase interface (water-vapor, water-ice, ice-vapor, etc.). The role of “demon” is played by the collective forces of molecular attraction. Water molecules moving toward the water surface from below will become vapor molecules only if their speed equals or exceeds the “escape velocity”. They will remain water molecules if their speed is less that that velocity. This is a selection based on speed.
The removal of faster (hotter) molecules from the water or ice phase reduces the temperature of that phase. The kinetic energy lost in overcoming the cohesive forces goes on the books as potential energy; i.e., the enthalpy of vaporization or the enthalpy of fusion.
Thus we see that Maxwell’s Demon does exist. He goes by many names: force of intermolecular attraction, surface tension, surface energy and so on. But he does exist and is hard at work doing exactly what Maxwell envisaged him doing.