More rotating toilet bowl insanity

  • Thread starter Thread starter DaveC426913
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Rotating
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the misconceptions surrounding the Coriolis effect and its influence on water drainage direction in toilets and bathtubs. Participants critique a viral video that inaccurately claims water drains in different directions just 10 meters from the equator, emphasizing that such a small distance is negligible in terms of the Coriolis force. They highlight the importance of controlled experiments, referencing a historical study that demonstrated a statistical tendency for water to drain counterclockwise in the northern hemisphere and clockwise in the southern hemisphere. However, anecdotal observations from individual users are deemed insufficient for drawing scientific conclusions. The conversation underscores the complexity of fluid dynamics and the need for rigorous testing to validate claims about the Coriolis effect.
  • #51
sophiecentaur said:
I sympathise with you but what could you tell them about Quantum Physics or Relativity that would fit that requirement? I think "Correct but probably too small to measure accurately in your bathroom" should do.
To which the inevitable retort is: "So you admit it is true!"
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #52
Which one of us is the devil and which one is the advocate here?
There is nothing to admit. The sums correctly predict that it works (mostly) in the case of weather systems but, even then, only when the conditions are right. If it were always true, everyone would be in a permanent cyclone / depression and that is not topologically possible. In fact, the situation in the atmosphere never produces the sort of conditions for a true bathtub effect because they are always triggered by linear motion of air masses and rising / falling air. It is also possible to get air moving the wrong way. I foundhttp://www.kdlt.com/2015/04/09/do-all-tornadoes-rotate-the-same-way/and several others, which tells us that clockwise tornados can sometimes form in the northern hemisphere, going against the coriolis effect even at that scale.
I'm sorry Dave (to coin a phrase) but I think it's all just too hard to present to your dumkopf lay friends in a cut and dried assertion. You and I, of course, are fine with it all.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top