Nonlinear material problem in ANSYS Workbench

In summary, the mix of linear and nonlinear properties, incorrect Mohr-Coulomb parameters, and improper meshing may be causing issues with solving the model. It is recommended to review and adjust these settings in order to successfully simulate the stresses on the sump.
  • #1
Anders Johnsen
5
0
I'm currently conduction a nonlinear analysis of a partially buried, cylindrically shaped sump-system. I've decided to best simulate the stresses on the sump by modelling a shallow cylinder with gravel-properties around it and a cube with soil-properties surrounding both sump and gravel.

As I'm writing my bachelor's thesis in mechanical engineering, soil mechanics is not my field of study. As a result, I've approximated some values from an external program, CivilFEM.

However, I don't seem to be able to solve the model after adding the nonlinear Mohr-Coloumb properties to engineering data.

The data from CivilFEM is as follows;
Name: "Sand - well graded"

Type: Soil

E: 8e+07 Pa

ν: 0.3

ρ: 2038.74 kg/m³

G: 3.07692e+07 Pa

α: 1e-05 1/ΔK

Act. time: 0 day

Deact. time: 36500 day

Plastic behavior: Mohr-Coulomb

Densities
ρ type: Apparent

γ dry: 20000 N/m³

γ solid: 20000 N/m³

γ apparent: 20000 N/m³

γ submerged: 10190 N/m³

γ saturated: 20000 N/m³

γ water: 9810 N/m³

ρ dry: 2038.74 kg/m³

ρ solid: 2038.74 kg/m³

ρ apparent: 2038.74 kg/m³

ρ submerged: 1038.74 kg/m³

ρ saturated: 2038.74 kg/m³

ρ water: 1000 kg/m³

Porosity: 0

Void ratio: 0

Water content ratio: 0

Saturation grade: 0

Mohr-Coulomb
Eff. Cohesion: 0 Pa

Φ: 30 °

Hyperbolicity: 0 Pa

Autocalculate hyperbolicity parameter: Marked

Non-associative flow rule: Unmarked

Damping
Automatic: Marked

α: 0 1/s

β: 0 s

Damping: 0 %

ω min.: 0.1 1/s

ω max.: 100 1/s

The data was input to ANSYS Workbench as shown on the picture.

Why won't the model solve? Is this due to the mix between linear properties and nonlinear properties?

Any help would be appreciated
 

Attachments

  • Sand - well graded - engineering data.png
    Sand - well graded - engineering data.png
    17.9 KB · Views: 752
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
! It is possible that the mix of linear and nonlinear properties is causing issues with the model. The Mohr-Coulomb parameters you inputted may not be compatible with the soil properties you have chosen, or the Mohr-Coulomb parameters may not be properly configured. It is also possible that the damping parameters are not set up correctly. If these settings are incorrect, the model may not be able to accurately simulate the stresses on the sump. You may need to adjust the settings or choose different soil properties in order for the model to solve. Additionally, you may need to make sure the model is properly meshed, as an improper mesh can lead to problems with solving the model.
 

1. What is a nonlinear material problem in ANSYS Workbench?

A nonlinear material problem in ANSYS Workbench refers to a situation where the material properties of a component or structure change in a nonlinear way under applied loads or strain. This means that the behavior of the material cannot be accurately predicted using linear material models, and requires more complex analysis techniques.

2. How does ANSYS Workbench handle nonlinear material problems?

ANSYS Workbench has several built-in nonlinear material models that can accurately simulate the behavior of materials under nonlinear conditions. These models include plasticity, hyperelasticity, viscoplasticity, and creep, among others. Users can also define their own custom material models using the ANSYS Material Designer tool.

3. What are some common examples of nonlinear material problems?

Some common examples of nonlinear material problems include plastic deformation of metals, large deformations of rubber or other elastomers, and the behavior of materials under high strain rates or variable loading conditions. Nonlinear material problems can also arise in structures with complex geometries or multiple contact points.

4. How does ANSYS Workbench account for material nonlinearity in structural analysis?

In structural analysis, ANSYS Workbench uses the finite element method to discretize the geometry, and then applies the appropriate nonlinear material model to each element. This allows for accurate prediction of the material behavior and its effect on the overall structural response. ANSYS Workbench also has advanced contact algorithms to handle nonlinear contact between different parts of a structure.

5. What are some challenges in solving nonlinear material problems in ANSYS Workbench?

One of the main challenges in solving nonlinear material problems is the computational cost. Nonlinear analyses require more iterations and time steps compared to linear analyses, which can significantly increase the solve time. Another challenge is accurately defining the material properties and selecting the appropriate material model for the specific problem, as this can greatly affect the accuracy of the results.

Similar threads

  • Materials and Chemical Engineering
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
23
Views
36K
Replies
1
Views
594
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
3
Replies
75
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
21
Views
8K
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
14
Views
3K
  • Materials and Chemical Engineering
Replies
2
Views
6K
  • Programming and Computer Science
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top