Noob Integral Question, Indeterminate form of ?

In summary, the conversation discusses the use of IBP to find the integral of x*e^(-x) from 0 to ∞. The uv term is evaluated and it is determined that the limit is an indeterminate form. The use of L'Hopital is debated, with the conclusion that it should not be used unless the limit is already shown to be indeterminate. The zero term is also discussed, with the final consensus being that it evaluates to 0 without the use of L'Hopital.
  • #1
ken.
2
0
Hi

I need INTegral from 0 to ∞ of : x*e^(-x) dx

I use IBP: u = x, du = dx
dv = e^(-x) dx, v = -e^(-x)

uv - ∫v du = -x*e^(-x) - ∫ -e^(-x) dx

I am trying to evaluate the uv term : -x*e^(-x) from 0 to ∞
for the ∞ term of -x*e^(-x) =
-inf * 1/e^(inf) = -inf * 1/inf = 1
OR
-inf * 1/e^(inf) = -inf * 1/inf = -inf * 0 = 0
OR
it is indeterminate form, use l hospital...
which path is correct one ?

for the 0 term of -x*e^(-x) = 0

I am really sorry for the noob calculus question.
This is part of larger question regarding Gauss Quadrature. but..
Kindly pls remind me of the correct one.

Thank you for your help
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
ken. said:
Hi

I need INTegral from 0 to ∞ of : x*e^(-x) dx

I use IBP: u = x, du = dx
dv = e^(-x) dx, v = -e^(-x)

uv - ∫v du = -x*e^(-x) - ∫ -e^(-x) dx

I am trying to evaluate the uv term : -x*e^(-x) from 0 to ∞
for the ∞ term of -x*e^(-x) =
-inf * 1/e^(inf) = -inf * 1/inf = 1
OR
-inf * 1/e^(inf) = -inf * 1/inf = -inf * 0 = 0
Neither of those is correct. You cannot treat "infinity" as if it were a number.

OR
it is indeterminate form, use l hospital...
Yes, this if of the form "[itex]\infty/\infty[/itex]".

which path is correct one ?

for the 0 term of -x*e^(-x) = 0

I am really sorry for the noob calculus question.
This is part of larger question regarding Gauss Quadrature. but..
Kindly pls remind me of the correct one.

Thank you for your help
 
  • #3
Thanks. u re right. This really shows how indeterminate it can be..

But, what about the zero term
do I also need to apply the L'Hospital there ?
because without L'Hospital, the term evaluates to 0
and with L'Hospital, the term evaluates to -1

I think it is 0. Because the L'hospital applies to individual limits and not to the whole term before evaluated 0 to inf
But.. just making sure.

Thank you.
 
  • #4
An important point about L'Hopital is that it only works for indeterminate forms. If the limit is defined, not only do you not need L'Hopital, but you should not use it. So
[itex]\lim_{x\rightarrow0} xe^{-x}=0\cdot1=0[/itex]
is already defined.
Only use L'Hopital if you have already shown that the limit is an indeterminate limit.
 

1. What is a Noob Integral Question?

A Noob Integral Question refers to a basic calculus problem that involves finding the area under a curve. It is typically given to students who are just learning about integrals and is considered a fundamental concept in calculus.

2. What is an Indeterminate form?

An Indeterminate form is a mathematical expression that does not have a definite value. It usually arises when trying to evaluate a limit that results in a division by zero or an infinity.

3. How do I solve an Indeterminate form of a Noob Integral Question?

To solve an Indeterminate form of a Noob Integral Question, you can use various techniques such as L'Hôpital's rule or algebraic manipulation. It is important to understand the concept of limits and have a good understanding of basic calculus principles.

4. What are some common examples of Indeterminate forms?

Some common examples of Indeterminate forms are 0/0, ∞/∞, 0*∞, and ∞-∞. These types of expressions often arise when evaluating limits or solving certain calculus problems.

5. Why is it important to understand Indeterminate forms in calculus?

Understanding Indeterminate forms is crucial in calculus because they represent situations where a limit does not have a definite value. In real-world applications, these situations can arise frequently, and being able to evaluate them correctly is essential for solving problems accurately.

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
943
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
189
Replies
3
Views
342
Replies
19
Views
3K
  • Calculus
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Calculus
Replies
1
Views
781
Replies
2
Views
301
Replies
1
Views
945
Back
Top