Prof. Mattuck's Lecture 20: A Divine Power of Speech & Laplace's Elegance

Thread starter Hall
Start date Dec 4, 2022
Tags

Differential equations Lecture Lectures Power

In summary, Lecture 20 by Prof. Mattuck was praised as being excellent and effective in communication. The speaker also mentions the importance of speech as an expression, drawing a connection to Aristotle's beliefs. They also mention Laplace's ability to independently discover the use of integrals in solving differential equations, which was considered elegant.

Dec 4, 2022

Hall

Lecture 20 by Prof. Mattuck is simply great. I don’t think there can be any better communication than that, it seemed as if what was in his mind simply got teleported in to mine, and that’s why, it seems now, Aristotle gave so much importance (and almost considered it as a divine power) to the speech as an expression.

The other thing which gave me a joyous shock was how Laplace was able to see, completely on his own (though the integral of transformation was already in use), that the integral could be so well employed in solving differential equations. That’s simply ELEGANT!

[Post edited by the Mentors]

Last edited by a moderator: Dec 5, 2022

1. What is the main topic of Prof. Mattuck's Lecture 20?

The main topic of Prof. Mattuck's Lecture 20 is the concept of a divine power of speech and its connection to Laplace's elegance.

2. What is a divine power of speech?

A divine power of speech refers to the belief that certain individuals possess a special ability to communicate or persuade through their words, often attributed to a divine or supernatural source.

3. Who is Laplace and what is his connection to this topic?

Pierre-Simon Laplace was a French mathematician and astronomer who is best known for his contributions to probability theory and celestial mechanics. He is connected to this topic because of his famous quote, "The weight of evidence for an extraordinary claim must be proportioned to its strangeness," which is often used to support the idea of a divine power of speech.

4. How does Laplace's elegance relate to this topic?

Laplace's elegance refers to his belief that the laws of nature are simple and elegant, and therefore, the most likely explanation is often the simplest one. This idea is often used to argue against the existence of a divine power of speech, as it is seen as a more complex and extraordinary claim.

5. What are some examples of a divine power of speech?

Some examples of a divine power of speech include religious figures who are believed to have the ability to perform miracles through their words, such as Jesus Christ and the Buddha. Other examples include influential leaders and orators throughout history, such as Martin Luther King Jr. and Winston Churchill.