Question about data & Monte Carlo statistical uncertainties

In summary, the conversation discusses whether it is logical to separate the statistical uncertainties of data and Monte Carlo simulations. It is suggested that when the Monte Carlo has infinite statistics, the uncertainty is reduced, while the data has a finite uncertainty. However, when considering a fixed observation and varying the Monte Carlo within its uncertainty, there may be a possibility of double counting. It is noted that these are two distinct sources of uncertainty that affect the estimation of physical parameters in different ways."
  • #1
ChrisVer
Gold Member
3,378
464
Hi
I was wondering the following/feeling uneasy about it:
Does it make sense to separate the statistical uncertainties of data and Monte Carlo?
For example assume infinite statistics in your MC (uncertainty-->0) while your data is finite : so they come with some "uncertainty" (if that makes sense for an observation).

Then, exchange the two cases, aka consider the observation a fixed number (which sounds reasonable to me) and vary the MC within its uncertainty.

Doesn't the combination of those two steps result in double counting? (I have a feeling that that is happening).
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
They are two different uncertainty sources, and both influence separately (and differently!) how well you can estimate the physical parameter you are looking for.
 
  • #3
Monte Carlo uncertainty is a reflection of the computational model precision. Physical uncertainty reflects physics not mathematics.
 

1. What is the purpose of using Monte Carlo simulations in data analysis?

Monte Carlo simulations are used in data analysis to help estimate the uncertainty in a measurement or calculation. This is particularly useful when the underlying model is complex and analytical methods cannot provide a precise solution. By generating a large number of random samples, Monte Carlo simulations can help determine the range of possible outcomes and the likelihood of each outcome, providing a more accurate assessment of the uncertainty in the data.

2. How do Monte Carlo simulations account for statistical uncertainties?

Monte Carlo simulations use random sampling to account for statistical uncertainties. By repeatedly sampling from a known probability distribution, the simulation can generate a large number of potential outcomes and calculate the corresponding uncertainties. The more samples taken, the more accurate the estimate of the uncertainty will be.

3. Are there any limitations to using Monte Carlo simulations for statistical uncertainties?

Monte Carlo simulations can be computationally intensive and time-consuming, especially when dealing with complex models and large datasets. Additionally, the accuracy of the results depends on the quality and representativeness of the input data and the assumptions made in the simulation. Therefore, it is important to carefully design and validate the simulation to ensure reliable results.

4. How do you choose the appropriate probability distribution for a Monte Carlo simulation?

The choice of probability distribution depends on the nature of the data and the underlying model being simulated. For example, if the data follows a normal distribution, then a Gaussian distribution should be used in the simulation. It is important to carefully consider the characteristics of the data and consult with experts in the field to determine the most appropriate probability distribution for the simulation.

5. Can Monte Carlo simulations be used for all types of data and models?

Monte Carlo simulations can be applied to a wide range of data and models, but their effectiveness may vary depending on the complexity of the model and the quality of the data. Some models may require specialized techniques or modifications to the traditional Monte Carlo method in order to accurately account for uncertainties. It is important to carefully evaluate the suitability of the simulation for the specific data and model being analyzed.

Similar threads

I Monte Carlo for uncertainty estimation
    • Set Theory, Logic, Probability, Statistics
Replies
2
Views
1K
I Why Monte Carlo Simulations? What do they tell us?
    • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
9
Views
2K
A Monte Carlo to compute uncertainties, why report the mean and SD?
    • Set Theory, Logic, Probability, Statistics
Replies
2
Views
794
A Least-squares calculation with a pinch of weights and monte-carlo
    • Calculus
Replies
2
Views
936
I What is the correct definition of measurement uncertainty?
    • Set Theory, Logic, Probability, Statistics
Replies
21
Views
2K
A Monte Carlo Wang-Landau_antiferromagnetic perovskite
    • Atomic and Condensed Matter
Replies
3
Views
873
I ATLAS and CMS see signs of Higgs->muons decay
    • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
17
Views
5K
Statistical uncertainties Monte Carlo
    • Mechanics
Replies
2
Views
1K
I Confused about error propagation
    • Set Theory, Logic, Probability, Statistics
Replies
22
Views
1K
Determine the number of required Monte Carlo iterations
    • General Engineering
Replies
1
Views
2K

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top