Which component of light is a photon?

In summary, light is an electromagnetic radiation with two wave components that are perpendicular. Between these two perpendicular waves, where is the photon in this system.There is no separate photon and wave component.
  • #1
LSMOG
62
0
Light is an electromagnetic radiation with two wave components that are perpendicular. Between these two perpendicular waves, where is the photon in this system.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #3
Okay thanks. It behaves like! What is its real nature.
 
  • #4
LSMOG said:
Between these two perpendicular waves, where is the photon in this system.
When I strike a block of stone with a heavy steel hammer, there are sparks. Between the hammer and the stone, where is the spark in this system?
LSMOG said:
Okay thanks. It behaves like! What is its real nature.
"Real nature" is not a meaningful concept in science. If a theory explains and accurately predicts the behavior of a system, we go with that theory until and unless we find something better.

The best theory we have for explaining and predicting the behavior of light is classical electrodynamics, discovered by Maxwell in 1861. The explanation is that light is the electromagnetic waves predicted by Maxwell's equations, and it pretty much always works.

However, Maxwell's equations do not completely describe the way that electromagnetic fields exchange energy and momentum with charged particles. It turns out that these interactions always transfer energy and momentum in discrete steps, and we call these steps "photons". That doesn't mean that photons are a "component" of light, or that light is "made up" of photons, or that the photon is even there except when the light is interacting with matter.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes vanhees71 and jedishrfu
  • #5
Nugatory said:
That doesn't mean that photons are a "component" of light, or that light is "made up" of photons, or that the photon is even there except when the light is interacting with matter.

What does that mean, that the photon is just a probability wave until it interacts with something?
 
  • #6
GhostLoveScore said:
What does that mean, that the photon is just a probability wave until it interacts with something?
Not a 'probability wave', just fluctuations (waves) in an electromagnetic field.
'Interacting with something' generally means that the something has absorbed some energy of the wave.
This results in some electrons gaining energy, however electrons can only transition to a more excited state in discrete steps, (quanta).
The number of such steps occurring is countable by an appropriate measuring device, so from that perspective light is behaving more like a bunch of particles than a continuous wave.
 
Last edited:
  • #7
rootone said:
Not a 'probability wave', just fluctuations (waves) in an electromagnetic field.
'Interacting with something' generally means that the something has absorbed some energy of the wave.
This results in some electrons gaining energy, however electrons can only transition to a more excited state in discrete steps, (quanta).
The number of such steps occurring is countable by an appropriate measuring device, so from that perspective light is behaving more like a bunch of particles than a continuous wave.
And to extend this just a bit for the OP, what's also true is that not just any "photon" can excite just any electron. That ability depends on the frequency of the wave that causes the excitation so details of the "photon nature" side of a beam of light is a directly affected by the frequency of the light wave.

Photons are not "particles" in the classical view of particles, they are instead more accurately referred to as "quantum particles" or better still, "quantum objects".
 
  • #8
GhostLoveScore said:
What does that mean, that the photon is just a probability wave until it interacts with something?

The same as when you throw a dice. You know a side will come come up with a probability of 1/6 but nothing happens until you throw the dice.

QM is a theory about observations that appear here in a common sense classical world. We can predict probabilities of those observations but nothing happens until an observation actually occurs.

With light we can predict the probabilities of observing a photon, and that is done with the wave-function (also called a probability wave) but nothing happens until it is actually observed.

Note: What I said above isn't quite true because photons don't really have a wave-function in a usual sense. But liberties with the truth about photons is often taken in beginner texts.

Thanks
Bill
 
  • Like
Likes GhostLoveScore and vanhees71

Related to Which component of light is a photon?

1. What is a photon?

A photon is a fundamental particle of light that carries energy and has no mass. It is the smallest unit of light and is often described as a "packet" of energy.

2. How is a photon different from other components of light?

A photon is different from other components of light, such as electric and magnetic fields, because it is quantized and behaves both as a particle and a wave. It also has specific properties, including energy, frequency, and polarization.

3. How is a photon created?

A photon is created when an atom or molecule undergoes a transition from a higher energy state to a lower energy state. This can happen through a variety of processes, such as emission, absorption, or scattering.

4. Can photons be destroyed?

Photons cannot be destroyed, as they are fundamental particles and do not have a physical structure that can be broken down. However, they can be absorbed by materials or converted into other forms of energy.

5. How do we detect photons?

We can detect photons using various instruments, such as photodetectors, cameras, or telescopes. These devices are designed to measure the energy and properties of photons, such as their frequency, intensity, and direction of travel.

Similar threads

Replies
20
Views
1K
Replies
28
Views
659
Replies
6
Views
823
Replies
3
Views
790
Replies
13
Views
1K
  • Quantum Physics
2
Replies
64
Views
3K
Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
857
Back
Top