Why does AC have less copper loss than DC

In summary: AC was more efficient because it avoided this.Hi there everyone, I'm doing some study on electronics and the section on the advantages of A/C over DC mentioned that AC has less copper loss (I^2 x R), But to me this seems contradictory to the skin effect. Could someone please tell me why AC has less copper loss.The reason AC has less copper loss is that it uses higher voltages to power transmission, which results in lower current.
  • #1
Buggsy GC
48
1
Hi there everyone, I'm doing some study on electronics and the section on the advantages of A/C over DC mentioned that AC has less copper loss (I^2 x R), But to me this seems contradictory to the skin effect. Could someone please tell me why AC has less copper loss.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
For the same voltage and for the same power transmitted over a copper line, DC has less power loss. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-voltage_direct_current

However the reason that AC power transmission has dominated is that the equipment to transform between high voltage (in order to transmit the power for fewer losses) and low voltage (power for domestic use) is cheaper and less complicated. AC generators were also cheaper and more efficient.
 
  • #3
Buggsy GC said:
Hi there everyone, I'm doing some study on electronics and the section on the advantages of A/C over DC mentioned that AC has less copper loss (I^2 x R), But to me this seems contradictory to the skin effect. Could someone please tell me why AC has less copper loss.

I suspect this is confused. Most likely it's due to the answer that Delta gave eg...

AC power transmission is done at higher voltage. Higher voltage implies lower current for same power. Lower current means lower I2R losses in the copper wire.
 
  • #4
Buggsy GC said:
Hi there everyone, I'm doing some study on electronics and the section on the advantages of A/C over DC mentioned that AC has less copper loss (I^2 x R), But to me this seems contradictory to the skin effect. Could someone please tell me why AC has less copper loss.
This is probably in reference to the development of the area-wide power distribution system, in an era when the choice was basically between DC all-the-way or AC all-the-way. Transformers enabled the efficient transmission of AC at high tension followed by a step-down to consumer voltages, whereas there was no equivalent available for efficiently stepping down DC at the power levels involved.

Transmitting low tension DC throughout a power network involves cripplingly-high I2⋅R losses.
 

What is copper loss?

Copper loss is the energy lost in the form of heat when an electric current flows through a conductor, such as a copper wire.

Why does AC have less copper loss than DC?

AC (alternating current) has less copper loss than DC (direct current) because the direction of the current in AC power systems alternates, resulting in a back-and-forth movement of the electrons. This movement reduces the buildup of heat in the conductor, thereby reducing copper loss.

How does the frequency of the current affect copper loss?

The higher the frequency of the current, the higher the copper loss. This is because with a higher frequency, the electrons are moving back and forth at a faster rate, causing more collisions with the atoms in the conductor and resulting in more heat generated and therefore more copper loss.

Is the type of conductor material also a factor in copper loss?

Yes, the type of conductor material can also affect copper loss. Copper is a good conductor of electricity and has a lower resistance compared to other materials, which results in lower copper loss. Other materials such as aluminum have a higher resistance and therefore higher copper loss.

Can the length and thickness of the conductor affect copper loss?

Yes, the length and thickness of the conductor can also affect copper loss. Longer and thinner conductors have a higher resistance, which results in higher copper loss. This is why power transmission lines use thicker and shorter conductors to reduce copper loss.

Similar threads

  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
69
Views
7K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
9K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
25
Views
4K
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
5
Views
4K
Back
Top