Why does breathing out have more effect on surroundings?

  • Thread starter Sharkingboy8
  • Start date
In summary: When you suck in air through a barely opened mouth, you feel a strong stream of air hitting your tongue that could put out a candle. So the issue not our limited suction strength.In summary, the candle in front of me provides an interesting question about the difference between blowing and suction. Both actions have a small impact on their surroundings, but blowing has a greater impact.
  • #1
Sharkingboy8
2
0
Theres a candle in front of me while I've been working. It got me thinking; why does it take so little to blow the candle out, but if i inhale near the candle almost nothing happens. I guess more generally than this, why does suction have such a small impact on its surroundings compared to blowing?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Sharkingboy8 said:
I guess more generally than this, why does suction have such a small impact on its surroundings compared to blowing?
At most you can create a vacuum in your mouth when inhaling (and I doubt that very much). Thus: max inhale pressure differential: 105Pa. When blowing, you can create a much higher pressure differential.

It is the same with suction pumps and pressure pumps: You can only suck water up to ≈10m (vacuum in the pump, 105Pa outside), but there is only a mechanical and practical limit to the height a pressure pump can push water.
 
  • #3
When air is blown from a higher pressure source, the flow is directional (assuming that a dispersal type nozzle is not used). When air is drawn into a lower pressure zone, the flow is not directional, but instead is drawn inwardws from all directions, so the net flow in any specific direction is much less.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes CWatters, davenn and marcus
  • #4
I also think that, for biological reasons, breathing out is a stronger reaction than breathing in. From what I remember, expelling carbon dioxide is more critical than taking in oxygen.
 
  • #5
rcgldr said:
When air is blown from a higher pressure source, the flow is directional. When air is drawn into a lower pressure zone, the flow is not directional, but instead is drawn inwardws from all directions, so the net flow in any specific direction is much less.

That's a good explanation! To repeat/paraphrase: Blowing out creates momentum in the volume of air expelled, the directionality and coherence increases its effect. Breathing in only creates coherent directionality in the air going down your windpipe. I'll check out some of the other posts by Rcgldr. Also it was a good question by Sharker---hadn't ever occurred to me to ask.
 
  • #6
lychette said:
I also think that, for biological reasons, breathing out is a stronger reaction than breathing in. From what I remember, expelling carbon dioxide is more critical than taking in oxygen.

naaaa, disagree, am sitting here reading this thread and my inhaling and exhaling are very even in strengthD
 
  • #7
have to agree with davenn, surely you breathe the same amount in as out, and you pretty much control the force. But the momentum explanation makes sense, thanks.
 
  • #8
there is a simple test using a U tube manometer filled with water (standard school demo) Blow into one end of the manometer...note the height difference(pressure)
Suck on the manometer, note the height difference (pressure)...let me know which is greater !
(the manometer needs to be about 2m tall)
 
  • #9
marcus said:
That's a good explanation! To repeat/paraphrase: Blowing out creates momentum in the volume of air expelled, the directionality and coherence increases its effect. Breathing in only creates coherent directionality in the air going down your windpipe. I'll check out some of the other posts by Rcgldr. Also it was a good question by Sharker---hadn't ever occurred to me to ask.

Breathing in creates just as much momentum, but outside of one's body cavities it is diffused over a larger volume so the velocity of the air is generally less.
 
  • #10
the fundanental thing is that you can 'blow harder than you can suck'... this is so easy to check with a pressure gauge...
 
  • #11
lychette said:
the fundanental thing is that you can 'blow harder than you can suck'... this is so easy to check with a pressure gauge...

You might be able to blow out harder than you can suck in, but that's not why you can blow out a candle but you can't 'suck' out a candle. The reason is that the outgoing air has momentum, just as explain in posts 3, 5, and 9.
 
  • #12
lychette said:
the fundanental thing is that you can 'blow harder than you can suck'...
As others said, even you blow at the same rate as you suck in, the blowing will still be more effective in putting out the flame.

Put it another way: When you suck in air through a barely opened mouth, you feel a strong stream of air hitting your tongue that could put out a candle. So the issue not our limited suction strength.
 
  • #13
I think that it is agreed that you can blow harder than you can suck...in pressure terms
 
  • #14
lychette said:
I think that it is agreed that you can blow harder than you can suck...in pressure terms

No one said otherwise. It just doesn't have much to do with why you can blow out a candle but can't put one out by inhaling.

One other thing to think about for those in the thread, is that when you blow out a candle you're pursing your lips together and forcing the air through a small orifice, which greatly increases the velocity of the air compared to inhaling. Trying to blow out a candle by exhaling through a wide open mouth isn't nearly as effective.
 
  • Like
Likes davenn

Related to Why does breathing out have more effect on surroundings?

1. Why is breathing out important for our health?

Breathing out is important for our health because it helps remove carbon dioxide from our body. Carbon dioxide is a waste product produced by our cells during metabolism. If it builds up in our body, it can lead to fatigue, dizziness, and other health issues. Breathing out removes this waste gas and helps maintain proper levels of oxygen and carbon dioxide in our body.

2. Does breathing out affect the environment?

Yes, breathing out affects the environment as it releases carbon dioxide into the air. Carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas that contributes to climate change. However, the amount of carbon dioxide released by an individual's breathing is very small and is not a significant contributor to climate change. Other human activities, such as burning fossil fuels, have a much larger impact on the environment.

3. Why do we feel warm air when breathing out?

When we breathe out, the air we exhale is warmer than the surrounding air. This is because our body temperature is around 37 degrees Celsius, and the air we inhale is usually cooler than that. As the warm air from our body mixes with the cooler air in the environment, it creates the sensation of warm air when we exhale.

4. How does breathing out affect the pH of our body?

Breathing out helps regulate the pH of our body. When we exhale, we release carbon dioxide, which combines with water in our body to form carbonic acid. This acid is a weak acid that helps maintain the pH balance in our body. If we do not breathe out enough carbon dioxide, the pH of our body can become too acidic, leading to health problems.

5. Can breathing out affect the temperature of our surroundings?

Breathing out does not have a significant effect on the temperature of our surroundings. The amount of heat released when we exhale is very small compared to other sources of heat in our environment. However, if a large number of people are in a confined space and breathing out, it can contribute to a slight increase in temperature in that area.

Similar threads

  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
9
Views
2K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
1
Views
994
  • DIY Projects
2
Replies
35
Views
5K
  • Chemistry
2
Replies
39
Views
3K
  • General Engineering
Replies
14
Views
727
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
6K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
930
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
8
Views
4K
Back
Top