Why isn't Geophysics a division of the APS?

Thread starter AryaKimiaghalam
Start date Feb 28, 2022
Tags

Division Geophysics

In summary, the American Physical Society (APS) is the world's largest organization of physicists, promoting and supporting physics research, education, and outreach. Geophysics, a branch of physics focusing on the Earth's physical properties, is not currently a division of the APS due to its relatively new and interdisciplinary nature. While there is no official statement from the APS, it is possible that Geophysics could eventually become a division in the future. Other organizations that specifically focus on Geophysics include the American Geophysical Union and the European Geosciences Union, with many Geophysicists being members of both the APS and these organizations.

Feb 28, 2022

AryaKimiaghalam

Curious to know why...

Physics news on Phys.org

Feb 28, 2022

Frabjous

Gold Member

Not enough members who want an independent unit; i.e., they are happy with AGU, GSA and/or the APS Unit they are currently in. Don‘t quote me on the number, but I believe a Topical Group only requires roughly 400 members.

Last edited: Feb 28, 2022

1. Why isn't Geophysics considered a division of the APS?

Geophysics is not considered a division of the American Physical Society (APS) because it is a highly interdisciplinary field that encompasses aspects of both physics and geology. As such, it does not fit neatly into the traditional divisions of the APS, which are based on specific areas of physics.

2. Can geophysics be considered a subfield of physics?

While geophysics does involve the study of physical phenomena, it is not typically considered a subfield of physics. This is because geophysics also incorporates principles and methods from other disciplines, such as geology, mathematics, and engineering.

3. Is geophysics recognized as a separate discipline by other scientific organizations?

Yes, geophysics is recognized as a separate discipline by many other scientific organizations, including the American Geophysical Union (AGU) and the European Geosciences Union (EGU). These organizations have their own divisions and sections dedicated to geophysics.

4. Are there any efforts to include geophysics as a division of the APS?

There have been discussions and proposals to include geophysics as a division of the APS, but so far, none have been successful. The APS does have a Topical Group on Geophysics, which serves as a forum for geophysicists within the society.

5. Will geophysics ever be recognized as a division of the APS?

It is difficult to predict if geophysics will ever be recognized as a division of the APS. While there is a growing recognition of the importance of interdisciplinary research, the traditional divisions of the APS have remained largely unchanged. However, as the field of geophysics continues to advance and gain recognition, it is possible that it may eventually become a division of the APS.