Recent content by avec_holl

  1. A

    Uniqueness of Even and Odd Function Decomposition

    Swell! I agree that my earlier proofs weren't worded very well and that probably created some confusion. I'm sorry about that. So, as it stands, is my logic reasonable? I also realize that there are better solutions but I wanted to make sure I got everything cleared up with my logic before I...
  2. A

    Uniqueness of Even and Odd Function Decomposition

    Couple thoughts that might be a bit coherent. We know that: f(a) = C + D and f(-a) = C - D for some real numbers C and D. I define the function E such that is always has the property that E(a) = C and E(-a) = C; hence E is even. I define the function O such that O(a) = D and O(-a) = -D...
  3. A

    Uniqueness of Even and Odd Function Decomposition

    The proof should address the first question. To address your second criticism, I'll revise the proof . . . Suppose that f is a function whose domain is the set of real numbers, then f(a) and f(-a) both exist. Given any two real numbers f(a) and f(-a) there exist two real numbers C and D...
  4. A

    Uniqueness of Even and Odd Function Decomposition

    I'm still struggling with this. Given any two real numbers f(a) and f(-a) there exists two real numbers c and [/itex]d[/itex] such that f(a) = c + d and f(-a) = c - d. The number c has the property that if E(a) = c then E(-a) = c and the number d has the property that O(a) = d and O(-a) = -d...
  5. A

    Uniqueness of Even and Odd Function Decomposition

    Normally, I probably would use the case by case method but I'd already proved the lemma I used to derive the contradiction. So, using the lemma that I provided, do you think that (b) is a valid proof? Also, have you read through (a)? I recognize that the point of contention is where I...
  6. A

    Uniqueness of Even and Odd Function Decomposition

    I stated in the quoted bit that O cannot be the zero function which means that f cannot be even. The point of this lemma is: In (b) we have that the sum of an odd function and an even function is odd. The lemma proves that this can only be true if E is the zero function - if it isn't, we...
  7. A

    Uniqueness of Even and Odd Function Decomposition

    Alright, I'm a bit confused at the moment so I'll post my original argument with all my thoughts included . . . (a) Suppose that f is some function whose domain is the set of real numbers. This implies that both f(a) and f(-a) exist. Since, given any two real numbers c and d there exist two...
  8. A

    Uniqueness of Even and Odd Function Decomposition

    Here's what I thought: Given any two numbers c and d, there exist two numbers a and b such that a + b = c and a - b = d. However, I guess this doesn't apply (maybe it's a consequence of this theorem?). Maybe this is incorrect in general. I guess I'll work on this a bit longer then! Could...
  9. A

    News The US has the best health care in the world?

    How does this pertain to the current health care reform bill? The current bill would allow Joe, Sarah, Bob, Emily, Frank and Amy to keep private health care if they desired and does not cut funding from medicaid or medicare.
  10. A

    Uniqueness of Even and Odd Function Decomposition

    Homework Statement 13. (a) Prove that any function f with domain \mathbb{R} can be written f = O + E where E is even and O is odd. (b) Prove that this way of writing f is unique. Homework Equations N/A The Attempt at a Solution (a) Suppose that f is some function with domain...
  11. A

    Proof of the Remainder Theorem: Is this proof of the Remainder Theorem valid?

    Thanks for your reply! Sorry about the misnomer, my textbook refers to this result as the Remainder Theorem but I guess it isn't.
  12. A

    Proof of the Remainder Theorem: Is this proof of the Remainder Theorem valid?

    Homework Statement Prove that for any polynomial function f and number a, there exists a polynomial function g and number b such that: f(x) = (x-a)g(x) + b Homework Equations N/A The Attempt at a Solution Proof: Let P(n) be the statement that for some natural number n, f(x) =...
  13. A

    Recommendations for Rigorous Multivariable/Vector Calculus Books

    I just looked into Vector Calculus, Linear Algebra, and Differential Forms and it looks like an excellent textbook - very well reviewed. Thanks for the suggestion!
  14. A

    Recommendations for Rigorous Multivariable/Vector Calculus Books

    Does anyone have some suggestions for a good multi-variable/vector calculus book? I have a fairly reasonable math background - managed to self-teach myself calculus through Micahael Spivak's text Calculus pretty successfully - and I'm looking for something that's fairly rigorous. One of my...
  15. A

    Understanding Even Numbers in Set S Divisible by 5

    Homework Statement Let S be a set of Natural numbers with the property that every even number in S is divisible by 5. Which of the following must be true. a. 2 is not in S b. 5 is not in S c. S contains all multiples of 10 d. Every even number in S is divisible by 10 e. S contains no...
Back
Top