Recent content by Dale
-
Undergrad Does mass have intrinsic properties apart from inertia?
For the purpose of your question however, it doesn't really matter. Either way gravity is something beyond inertia, either a force or a spacetime curvature. -
Undergrad Does mass have intrinsic properties apart from inertia?
You could say something similar in General relativity, but your question was specifically about Newtonian physics. In standard Newtonian physics free fall motion in a gravitational field is not straight line motion. So it is not inertia. Even in GR where free fall motion is straight-line... -
Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?
I already said: Not the metric. It is indeed easy to go from one to the other, but the line element is a scalar. -
Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?
Sure, but ##ds^2## is not a coordinate basis covector itself. As you can see from the formula you posted, it is a scalar. -
Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?
Sorry, I forgot this was the math forum. I was referring to general relativity. ##ds^2## is the line element or spacetime interval and ##d\tau## is the proper time. -
Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?
True, assuming that ##x## is a coordinate. Something like ##d\tau^2## or ##ds^2## wouldn't be a coordinate basis covector. -
Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?
Well, if someone chooses to use Leibniz approach then they are justifiably subject to all of the standard criticisms of that approach. -
Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?
Interesting. In the US it is almost exclusively the “epsilon delta” approach. I don’t think I have ever seen one that teaches Leibniz’s approach. It is not rigorous -
Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?
Use Robinson's hyperreals instead: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperreal_number#From_Leibniz_to_Robinson Regardless of Leibniz's infinitesimals, Robinson's are mathematically rigorous and well accepted. They just haven't been adopted as part of standard instruction, so they are not as well... -
Graduate Why rotation apparently seems to be absolute?
And I answered that too: Brans Dicke gravity. It is just weird to ask a question, receive answers, and then suggest both that you haven’t received answers and that it is because we consider the question non-physical. Nobody said you were being argumentative. Nor that you were prolonging the...- Dale
- Post #103
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
Graduate Why rotation apparently seems to be absolute?
And that question has been answered. Did you not see the answers above? Especially my answer about “the shortest distance between two points is a straight line”. I don’t understand. Since we already answered, doesn’t that already indicate that we think they are in physics?- Dale
- Post #101
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
Graduate Why rotation apparently seems to be absolute?
Yes. This is largely a debate about what “Machian” means. Mach never actually proposed a theory and his statement is very vague. So people can and do “move the goalposts” to prolong the debate. One thing is clear: Brans and Dicke intended their theory to fix what they understood as the...- Dale
- Post #99
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
Graduate Why rotation apparently seems to be absolute?
Yes, standard GR is not Machian. And experimental evidence shows that the universe is non-Machian in the same way that GR is. The main candidate is Brans Dicke gravity. It has a free parameter ##\omega##. When ##\omega \approx 1## the universe is Machian, and when ##\omega = \infty## you get GR...- Dale
- Post #94
- Forum: Special and General Relativity
-
Undergrad Geometrical meaning of ##(dx)^2##. Does ##(dx)^2## represent a point?
When you are discussing things like ##dx## you have to be very clear about what mathematical system you are using. In the real numbers with standard analysis ##dx## is a limit (or a variable that is taken to a limit as it approaches 0). If you do not want to treat it as a limit, then you need to... -
Undergrad Are 2 and 4 “special” numbers?
It is not “the” least magnitude non-special number. It is “a” least magnitude non-special number. There are two: ##n## and ##-n##, so neither is special.- Dale
- Post #24
- Forum: General Math