Recent content by huangdaiyu

  1. huangdaiyu

    Graduate Steady state confined flow field: Is it cyclic?

    Thank you. That is very interesting. I will look into that. Going back to the example of Rayleigh convection, is there a way to predict convection cells without having to solve the equations of motion? That was what I was hoping for in guessing that the steady flow solutions for a confined...
  2. huangdaiyu

    Graduate Steady state confined flow field: Is it cyclic?

    Wow that is an interesting counterexample. Is it from a textbook by chance? I would like to look it up to visualize and understand it better.
  3. huangdaiyu

    Graduate Steady state confined flow field: Is it cyclic?

    Correct, I did not think about turbulent flow. And yes those are my assumptions. Whatever is necessary to make the velocity, pressure, and density fields independent of time.
  4. huangdaiyu

    Graduate Steady state confined flow field: Is it cyclic?

    No, I suppose it would not be. So that is a third option I did not consider. What if we restrict to non-chaotic flow regime? Is my assumption true then? Can it be "proved" (like in physics textbooks, not necessarily very rigourous)? All I can give so far is informal arguments. Such as, a...
  5. huangdaiyu

    Graduate Steady state confined flow field: Is it cyclic?

    For a fluid that is confined to a finite region with no sources and sinks, are the only options for the flow field a) static, and b) cyclic? The example I have in mind is Rayleigh convection in a shallow dish heated from below, where convection cells are formed beyond a certain temperature...