Recent content by Killtech

well, education is slow while integration could be much faster. why learn so much knowledge and how to solve very complicated differential equations and integrals over decades, when we would have the option to expand our natural wiring to additional hardware where this comes pre-trained? would...

this is an example for a misunderstanding an AI wouldn't do. a discussion is broader then a single question and exploring any topic beyond the established requires a good understanding of the current knowledge of all things related to it. barely any human has all the related knowledge and its...

i must admit that for me LLMs have revolutionized learning and exploring certain subjects beyond established knowledge. i find that LLM are for more proficient at exactly understanding my questions and how i approach them than people ever could. removing the factor of constant misunderstandings...

Sorry, i cannot see how with the interpretation you propose makes Newtons theory at all usable. Consider a clock ##r_1## on earths surface and another one ##r_2## in orbit, and a last one ##r_3## passing earth with relativistic speed, all of them measuring the time it takes earth spin one full...

As far as i read Newton's theory it mainly uses coordinate time and hence makes only predictions on that. If we have an minimal interpretation how to interpret coordinates, we don't need another representation of time, because everything is already perfectly specified by coordinates. Hence...

Which i did. Use the Ctrl+F function to highlight the word "original" in your browser if you wish to check. Same goes to when i refer to Newton explicitly as a person. I have not brought up the concept of proper time in terms of Newtons theory. I was pretty clear on highlighting that his...

Sorry, but i can make no sense of what you claim here. Newtowns theory predates any atomic clock by a very long time, hence there is no way it can make any statements about them. Newton's Philosophiae Naturalis Principia Mathematica explicitly introduces the concept of time as absolute...

Oh, i see the word "match" is misleading here. What i meant was merely that in order to make a comparison of two models one must first identify something that is supposed to represent the same thing. Naively i would assume one would try to identify each point in spacetime in one theory to their...

Well, honestly sorry but i have no idea why you think i have claimed that? It's a bit insulting tbh. Newton's gravity is intentions lacking entirely a field equation so there is no way to translate that. These models are obviously structurally incompatible. All i wanted to point out is that on...

Out of curiosity then, how is Newtons model of gravity actually compared against GT? Because, here the details of interpretation are not clear to me. One could either say Newtons description is a pure coordinate view and hance should be matched with GR's model of the solar system by the right...

Yes, but you have to be more careful, because the arc length is not measured absolutely, but rather always represented by a unit. The arc length in units of ##r_a## needs no correction when measured by ##r_a##, but requires one when measured by ##r_b##. The situation is reversed when the arc...

We are talking past each other. I don't dispute anything you wrote here, or rather fully agree with it. Of course we must ensure all length measurement is consistent and of course we can build the knowledge to make it so, even if we were to use rod types that don't agree with each other, we will...

So that was not the part i was referring to as impossible. Peter suggested But: If you accept neither one as a valid measure of length, what kind of further experimentation would Peter be doing then? I don't see him being able to make any quantitative observations, let alone derive any...

What you suggest here is however logically not entirely possible: experiments require measurements which need a measuring system like SI is. In this simple case SI is nothing else but a choice of which rod to take, so we go in circles. What experiments can detect however are hysteresis like...

Wow, thanks for the detailed read :D There was just this part that i am compelled to thinking more about. i take the "rigid rod" is a reference to the orinasal meter rod in Paris as an exemplary of the general abstract concept of a length measure. This involvement of geometry and it's...