Recent content by swle

  1. S

    Do photons obey the 1/r^2 gravity law?

    Thank-you andrien, that is a really interesting link - who is Kevin Brown?
  2. S

    Handwaving to match orders of magnitude

    Thanks very much for the reply, but I have a problem with this line Are you not arguing a flux here? (i.e. Gauss ) What happens to the photons once they have reached a destination? While individual photons will be absorbed, won't the total number available will remain constant? Sorry if...
  3. S

    Handwaving to match orders of magnitude

    You got me! I chose numbers that, although widely available in the public domain, gave the me answer that I wanted. btw, great links - thanks
  4. S

    Do photons obey the 1/r^2 gravity law?

    Do photons obey the 1/r^2 gravity law? This was a question that came up in our recent PhySoc meeting and no-one present seemed to know the answer (lecturers included!) Does anyone have a unequivocal answer (and preferably citing a source)? I have done a quick search through old posts...
  5. S

    Handwaving to match orders of magnitude

    Thanks for reply! It was just a bit of fun - I realize that most objections will centre around what is, or what is not, "rest mass". I took the view that if someone is prepared to quote a figure, then I am prepared to put it into a calculation!
  6. S

    Handwaving to match orders of magnitude

    Brilliant - thanks!
  7. S

    Handwaving to match orders of magnitude

    Thank-you for taking time to reply! Like I said, just a bit of fun! I don't follow that argument - perhaps you cold explain? I don't follow this argument either, perhaps you can explain this one too? The universe may well be fractally distributed, but as far as we know it is isotropic...
  8. S

    How to Evaluate ∫(z²+x²)^(-3/2)dx by Hand?

    Sorry that this is a bit late, but is Z a real number? If not then you could use Cauchy: non-holomorphic points will be at z^2 = - x^2 ( e.g. x =1, z = i).
  9. S

    Handwaving to match orders of magnitude

    Hello This is my first post here. Although I've often read posts in Physics Forums, I've never actually contributed anything - so here goes! I always enjoy a good hand-waving argument on orders of magnitude; when I first started my astrophysics degree, one homework question was "estimate...
Back
Top