Was Richard Feynman's explanation of the twin paradox wrong?

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter gen x
  • Start date
60 replies · 8K views · last reply
Nugatory said:
But every step forward is an extension, not a replacement, and you have zero chance of understanding new developments without a solid foundation in what we have now.
In Helliwell's SR book, he says "every new theory swallows the previous one whole"! Newton is inside SR, which is inside GR, which will be inside a Quantum theory of gravity.
 
renormalize said:
Explain how learning from YouTube videos instead of textbooks assures that you "...don't...learn physics that will be different for 100 years." Please be specific in your answer.
I am not learning, I just listen from time to time about this theories. Learning mean do physics=do calculation.
As I already said, I don't wont learn something that will be completely different for 100+ years, when we figure out what gravity and quantum world really is ..
 
gen x said:
I am not learning, I just listen from time to time about this theories. Learning mean do physics=do calculation.
As I already said, I don't wont learn something that will be completely different for 100+ years, when we figure out what gravity and quantum world really is ..
It will not be different in a hundered years. What you learn now will be just the same then. There will be more things to learn, but the theories that you learn now will still be there. A hundred years ago people learned general relativity, today they also do that, in a hundred years they will still do it.
 
martinbn said:
It will not be different in a hundered years. What you learn now will be just the same then. There will be more things to learn, but the theories that you learn now will still be there. A hundred years ago people learned general relativity, today they also do that, in a hundred years they will still do it.
I wrote 100+ years
 
For myself, I find Newtonian dynamics interesting even though it's 300+ years old and "superseded" by GR.
And the same for Maxwell's electrodynamics.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Matterwave and javisot
martinbn said:
Replace 100 with 100+ in my post!
One day will be look at current physics just like now we look at Aristotelian physics.
 
gen x said:
One day will be look at current physics just like now we look at Aristotelian physics.
What Aristotelian physics?

What about Archimedes? The law of lever, the buoyancy principle, and everything else he did is still taught and is still relevent today.
 
gen x said:
One day will be look at current physics just like now we look at Aristotelian physics.
Perhaps. But the work of Dunning and Kruger will remain as relevant as ever.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Likes   Reactions: PhDeezNutz, Frimus, Matterwave and 5 others
PeterDonis said:
I'm glad it got reduced to 4. (One thing I never found out was whether anyone had made a T-shirt with the tensor formulation, which would have reduced it to two.) Maxwell's original 20 would never have fit on a T-shirt. :wink:
That depends on the size of the T-shirt and the beer-belly it was covering. I could do it. :-p
 
Hornbein said:
Progress. The geometric algebra people got it down to one. But I thought that was silly because in order to do anything useful you have to unpack it.
That is true, but I like that the geometric algebra shows that it all comes from one concept/methodology, based on very basic considerations. That is intellectually pleasing to me.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Sagittarius A-Star and robphy
gen x said:
I wrote 100+ years
Are you planning to be around 100+ years from now?
 
martinbn said:
Why do you watch you tube videos instead of studying physics textbooks?
Because sometimes the textbook can be wrong... :-p I'm not saying that they are always wrong, but when people don't find them explanatory enough, they seek extra information somewhere else... It's the textbook fault... Do not blame the individual for trying to fully understand the matter in question. The problem is (like PeroK said) most of the time YouTube is clickbait...
 
Yanni said:
Because sometimes the textbook can be wrong... :-p I'm not saying that they are always wrong, but when people don't find them explanatory enough, they seek extra information somewhere else... It's the textbook fault... Do not blame the individual for trying to fully understand the matter in question. The problem is (like PeroK said) most of the time YouTube is clickbait...
So then why doesn't the individual seek out explanations from multiple, credible textbooks to find ones that aren't "wrong" and gain understanding by studying those, rather than risking being misled by unvetted "clickbait"?
 
renormalize said:
So then why doesn't the individual seek out explanations from multiple, credible textbooks to find ones that aren't "wrong" and gain understanding by studying those, rather than risking being misled by unvetted "clickbait"?
:smile: that's why he asked the question (I believe...), so he could "sieve" the reliable answers...
 
Yanni said:
:smile: that's why he asked the question (I believe...), so he could "sieve" the reliable answers...
You give the OP too much credit. They never mentioned that they would evaluate any of the helpfully suggested references. The OP is likely a troll.
 
renormalize said:
You give the OP too much credit. They never mentioned that they would evaluate any of the helpfully suggested references.
Ha-ha! When a drunk man is right he deserve credit.
 
Paul Colby said:
The two twins follow two different paths. One twins path proper length is shorter. As setup, the shorter path twin must accelerate to get on this shorter length path. The shorter path length isn’t shorter because it takes acceleration for the twin to change to it. It’s shorter because it’s shorter.
This hits the nail on the head. The fact that one path is shorter is the fundamental point. Acceleration causes the effect by causing the shorter path to be followed.
 
gen x said:
I am not learning, I just listen from time to time about this theories. Learning mean do physics=do calculation.
As I already said, I don't wont learn something that will be completely different for 100+ years, when we figure out what gravity and quantum world really is ..
The learning of current theories is what leads to more comprehensive theories later.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Dale and FactChecker
PhDeezNutz said:
The learning of current theories is what leads to more comprehensive theories later.
Good point. Although if "learning" means being able to do the calculations, then I will never "learn" GR or QM in any form. I will remain intellectually satisfied with a general, vague understanding of the concepts.
 
It seems you are a fan of Tim. He is quite clear in his exposition. He is also very "opinionated" (although I guess to him, he is simply right).
 
Matterwave said:
It seems you are a fan of Tim. He is quite clear in his exposition. He is also very "opinionated" (although I guess to him, he is simply right).
No I am not, I just surprised how brutal he is about physics.
Same as Penrose. They don't use polite term "incomplete" , they use term "wrong" all the time..
 
PeterDonis said:
For those who, like me, find videos a very poor way of communicating these kinds of topics, Linda Fugate has a PDF on her website covering the same material:

https://lindafugate.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/twinfeynman.pdf
Do you agree with conclusion in pdf?
For me as layman, Tim explanation is better. Explanation with acceleration can lead a person who is not an expert in topic to the wrong conclusion
 
Last edited:
gen x said:
Do you agree with conclusion in pdf?
The conclusion being:

[Feynman] never actually told us acceleration caused the traveling twin to age slower. ... So I don’t think Feynman was wrong, I just think he confused the heck out of a generation of young physicists. These things happen when we take shortcuts in trying to explain physics to the public or to undergraduate students. ...
 
gen x said:
Do you agree with conclusion in pdf?
It depends on what you think "the conclusion" is.

To the extent she is saying that Feynman was not wrong, I agree with her--because Feynman was talking about a specific scenario, in which the acceleration of Alice, the traveling twin, is the key difference between them.

To the extent she is saying that Feynman did cause trouble, by confusing the heck out of a generation of young physicists by taking shortcuts, I think she's failing to realize that her own presentation also takes shortcuts. Attributing things to a "gravitational field" is just as much of a shortcut as attributing them to "acceleration"--because both of those explanations only work in particular special scenarios.

The Insights article I referenced in post #11 of this thread takes basically the same position that Maudlin takes, at least as far as the actual physics is concerned (as opposed to his claims that Feynman was "wrong", which I don't agree with--see above): that the most general explanation of "twin paradox" scenarios, the one that always applies in every scenario, is the different path length along the two twins' worldlines through spacetime. Things like "acceleration" and "gravitational field" are just heuristics for particular scenarios where the difference in path lengths can be attributed to those things.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: martinbn, Dale, FactChecker and 1 other person
PeterDonis said:
because Feynman was talking about a specific scenario, in which the acceleration of Alice, the traveling twin, is the key difference between them.
Exactly. IMO, when a person has a simple misconception, you must dispel that first. Otherwise, you can give him the true solution till you are blue in the face and he will still think his simple misconception is more convincing.
Feynman pointed out the error in their simple logic. Perhaps his "explanation" of the Twin's Paradox was not even intended to fully give the real solution.
 
Last edited: