A Newton's law question which is too hard for me

21 replies · 4K views · last reply
tze liu
Messages
57
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Question 1.
A triangular prism of mass M is placed one side on a frictionless horizontal plane as shown in Fig. 1. The other two sides are inclined with respect to the plane at angles a1 and
a2 respectively. Two blocks of masses m1 and m2, connected by an inextensible thread, can slide without friction on the surface of the prism. The mass of the pulley, which supports the thread, is negligible.

  • Express the acceleration a of the blocks relative to the prism in terms of the acceleration a0 of the prism.
  • Find the acceleration a0 of the prism in terms of quantities given and the acceleration g due to gravity.
  • At what ratio m1/m2 the prism will be in equilibrium?

Homework Equations


ma=F

The Attempt at a Solution


see the picture below

i got totally wrong as it is too hard
can everyone give me hint to do this question
How did i do this question in a more clear and systematic way?
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten free-body diagrams and force equations on paper for a triangular prism with two blocks on inclined faces connected by a thread over a pulley; includes equations such as N1 = m1 g cos a1 and T - m1 g sin a1 = m1 a.
    16900277_1856761944604830_2142562444_n.jpg
    16.3 KB · Views: 545
  • Fig. 1: a triangular wedge on a horizontal floor with a pulley at its apex, two blocks labelled m1 and m2 on its inclined faces joined by a thread over the pulley, with angles α1 and α2 marked at the base.
    Scientists-and-Belief-3.gif
    30.2 KB · Views: 665
I think you assumed that the blocks are not accellerating in the directions perpendicular to the inclined surfaces of the prism, which of cause not true.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: tze liu
andrevdh said:
I think you assumed that the blocks are not accellerating in the directions perpendicular to the inclined surfaces of the prism, which of cause not true.
But how to do this question thank
 
The blocks on the inclines are sharing the horizontal acceleration of the prism since they are moving with it.
 
andrevdh said:
The blocks on the inclines are sharing the horizontal acceleration of the prism since they are moving with it.
andrevdh said:
The blocks on the inclines are sharing the horizontal acceleration of the prism since they are moving with it.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten blue-ink derivation on lined paper: a = (m2 g sin θ2 - m1 g sin θ1)/(m1 + m2), then a0 = (m1 g cos θ1 sin θ1 - m2 g sin θ2 cos θ2)/M, then g = a0 M/(m1 cos θ1 sin θ1 - m2 sin θ2 cos θ2), with g substituted into the first equation.
    IMG_20170221_134150.jpg
    45.4 KB · Views: 575
  • Handwritten notes on lined paper: a block m1 on an incline at angle α1 and block m2 on an incline at angle α2 joined by a string over a pulley, with the equations T - m1 g sin α1 = m1 a1 and m2 g sin α2 - T = m2 a2, and ground-frame equations N1 cos α1 + N2 cos α2 + Mg = R and N1 sin α1 - N2 sin α2 = M a0.
    IMG_20170221_134145.jpg
    47.8 KB · Views: 525
andrevdh said:
The blocks on the inclines are sharing the horizontal acceleration of the prism since they are moving with it.
andrevdh said:
The blocks on the inclines are sharing the horizontal acceleration of the prism since they are moving with it.
seems i forget to use consider the inertial force in this case??
 
Last edited:
The accelerations of the blocks along the incline are the same, say a , since they are connected with a string.

Hand-drawn physics diagram of a hatched wedge on a horizontal surface, with block m1 on its left incline and block m2 on its right incline, each labelled with an acceleration a along the slope, and an arrow above labelled a0 pointing right.


They are also accelerating horizontally, ao , so I am not convinced it is business like usual :sorry:

Hand-drawn free-body sketch of two blocks on a wedge-shaped incline, with arrows labeled a, a0 and a_R1, a_R2 showing accelerations; the block on the left has arrows labeled a and a0 and a_R1, the block on the right has arrows labeled a0, a and a_R2.


only along the inclines we have a
 
Last edited:
tze liu said:

Homework Statement



Question 1.
A triangular prism of mass M is placed one side on a frictionless horizontal plane as shown in Fig. 1. The other two sides are inclined with respect to the plane at angles a1 and
a2 respectively. Two blocks of masses m1 and m2, connected by an inextensible thread, can slide without friction on the surface of the prism. The mass of the pulley, which supports the thread, is negligible.

  • Express the acceleration a of the blocks relative to the prism in terms of the acceleration a0 of the prism.
  • Find the acceleration a0 of the prism in terms of quantities given and the acceleration g due to gravity.
  • At what ratio m1/m2 the prism will be in equilibrium?

Homework Equations


ma=F

The Attempt at a Solution


see the picture below

i got totally wrong as it is too hard
can everyone give me hint to do this question
How did i do this question in a more clear and systematic way?

Have you taken the Lagrangian form of Mechanics yet? If so, the problem is a relatively straightforward application of the Lagrangian, with "generalized coordinates" ##x## = horizontal location of the peak of the prism, and ##u##= length of the pulley-##m_1## string. The length of the pulley-##m_2## string is ##T-u##, where ##T## = total length of the string (fixed). If ##H## is the "height" of the prism, the (x,y) coordinates of mass ##m_1## are ##x_1 = x - u \cos(\alpha_1)## and ##y_1 = H - u \sin(\alpha_1)##. The (x,y) coordinates of mass ##m_2## are ##x_2 = x + (T-u) \cos(\alpha_2)## and ##y_2 = H - (T-u) \sin(\alpha_2)##. From that we can get the velocity vectors ##(\dot{x},0)## of the prism and ##(\dot{x}_1, \dot{y}_2), (\dot{x}_2, \dot{y}_2)## of masses ##m_1, n_2##, and can thus work out their kinetic energies, expressing everything in terms of ##x, u, \dot{x}, \dot{u}##.. We can also get the potential energies of masses ##m_1,m_2##. (The prism has potential energy as well, but it remains constant because the prism moves horizontally.)
 
So you could analyze the forces in the horizontal direction.
 
andrevdh said:
So you could analyze the forces in the horizontal direction.
Did I do something wrong in these several steps thank
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten physics working on lined paper headed question 1, with sketched inclined-plane diagrams of blocks m1 and m2 labelled with normal forces, tension T, weights mg and accelerations a, a0 and a_total, followed by equations including T - m1g sinθ1 = m1a1x, N1 - m1g cosθ1 = m1a1y, and N1 sinθ1 - N2 sinθ2 = M a0.
    IMG_20170223_001536.jpg
    37.2 KB · Views: 564
  • Handwritten derivation in blue ink on lined paper: a sketch of two blocks m1 and m2 on inclined planes connected over a pulley, followed by equations for (T - m1 g sin α)^2/m1^2 + (N1 - m1 g cos α)^2/m1^2 = a1 total^2, expanded and rewritten with a0 and a terms.
    IMG_20170223_001545.jpg
    54.5 KB · Views: 552
Can u use high school method to do it how about my work done here?
Ray Vickson said:
Have you taken the Lagrangian form of Mechanics yet? If so, the problem is a relatively straightforward application of the Lagrangian, with "generalized coordinates" ##x## = horizontal location of the peak of the prism, and ##u##= length of the pulley-##m_1## string. The length of the pulley-##m_2## string is ##T-u##, where ##T## = total length of the string (fixed). If ##H## is the "height" of the prism, the (x,y) coordinates of mass ##m_1## are ##x_1 = x - u \cos(\alpha_1)## and ##y_1 = H - u \sin(\alpha_1)##. The (x,y) coordinates of mass ##m_2## are ##x_2 = x + (T-u) \cos(\alpha_2)## and ##y_2 = H - (T-u) \sin(\alpha_2)##. From that we can get the velocity vectors ##(\dot{x},0)## of the prism and ##(\dot{x}_1, \dot{y}_2), (\dot{x}_2, \dot{y}_2)## of masses ##m_1, n_2##, and can thus work out their kinetic energies, expressing everything in terms of ##x, u, \dot{x}, \dot{u}##.. We can also get the potential energies of masses ##m_1,m_2##. (The prism has potential energy as well, but it remains constant because the prism moves horizontally.)
 
The a1x and the a2x are the same for starters, but I am not convinced this way of approaching it will work (or is the easiest), although I might be wrong.
What i would rather suggest is analyzing the forces along the inclines, as you did, and use just a symbol a for the acceleration along the inclines for both masses, that is your x-direction equations.

The other sets of equations is for all three objects in the horizontal direction, with an acceleration ao in all three equations.
This approach I guess would be more promising, also it directly uses the symbols suggested in the original question.
 
andrevdh said:
The a1x and the a2x are the same for starters, but I am not convinced this way of approaching it will work (or is the easiest), although I might be wrong.
What i would rather suggest is analyzing the forces along the inclines, as you did, and use just a symbol a for the acceleration along the inclines for both masses, that is your x-direction equations.

The other sets of equations is for all three objects in the horizontal direction, with an acceleration ao in all three equations.
This approach I guess would be more promising, also it directly uses the symbols suggested in the original question.
andrevdh said:
The a1x and the a2x are the same for starters, but I am not convinced this way of approaching it will work (or is the easiest), although I might be wrong.
What i would rather suggest is analyzing the forces along the inclines, as you did, and use just a symbol a for the acceleration along the inclines for both masses, that is your x-direction equations.

The other sets of equations is for all three objects in the horizontal direction, with an acceleration ao in all three equations.
This approach I guess would be more promising, also it directly uses the symbols suggested in the original question.
then what will you do next!?

thank you
 
The original question wants you to find a relationship between a and ao, that is maybe a/ao = ... in terms of the masses and the angles and what not :smile:

so then you would use the five equations to answer the questions - that is find the simplest relationship.
 
andrevdh said:
The original question wants you to find a relationship between a and ao, that is maybe a/ao = ... in terms of the masses and the angles and what not :smile:

so then you would use the five equations to answer the questions - that is find the simplest relationship.
i cannot solve it

no idea

as i expand such equations ,it seems that it make it too complicated
 
Consider which forces are causing the prism to move, and which forces are causing the blocks to move. Remember the blocks move with the resultant acceleration of a and a0.
 
tze liu said:
i cannot solve it

no idea

as i expand such equations ,it seems that it make it too complicated
Please do not post handwritten working as images. Not only are they usually quite hard to read, and frequently sideways or upside down, it also makes it hard to comment on individual steps. Images are for diagrams and textbook extracts.
Suppose the left hand block is accelerating down the slope at rate a relative to the prism. What is the horizontal component of that? If the prism is accelerating to the right at rate a0, what is the net horizontal acceleration of the block?
What net horizontal force must be acting on the block?
Do the same for the right-hand block. What force balance equation does that allow you to write?
 
The acceleration of both blocks along the incline is a, say 1 up and 2 down. So develop such equations just like before, just with the acceleration indicated as a for both.

Then for each block you also resolve the forces horizontally. The acceleration of the blocks is ao, let's say horizontally to the right, that is while the blocks are sliding they are moving together with the prism, all accelerating to the right with acceleration ao. This will give you 2 more equations.

Finally one more equation for the prism, since it is also accelerating horizontally to the right at ao.

That gives you 5 equations in total.
 
Your x-equations are correct, say for 2

m2 g sin(α2) - T = m2a

but the block is also accelerating horizontally ao

so add up the horizontal components of the forces on the block and they should produce the ao acceleration

Free-body diagram of a block on an incline at angle α2, with arrows for tension T up the slope, normal force N2 perpendicular to the slope, weight W2 straight down, and accelerations a along the slope and a0 horizontal.
 
Last edited:
haruspex said:
Please do not post handwritten working as images. Not only are they usually quite hard to read, and frequently sideways or upside down, it also makes it hard to comment on individual steps. Images are for diagrams and textbook extracts.
Suppose the left hand block is accelerating down the slope at rate a relative to the prism. What is the horizontal component of that? If the prism is accelerating to the right at rate a0, what is the net horizontal acceleration of the block?
What net horizontal force must be acting on the block?
Do the same for the right-hand block. What force balance equation does that allow you to write?
Sorry

i don't know how to post the working more clearly
 
tze liu said:
Sorry

i don't know how to post the working more clearly
You can post the diagrams as images as long as you make them large, clear, annotated, and the right way up. There are drawing packages you can get for your computer that will create e.g. .jpg which you can upload. See the image in post #19.
For the algebra, just type it in! Be careful to use parentheses correctly. You can either use the tool icons just above the typing area for superscript (X2), subscript (X2) and special symbols (∑), or learn to use LaTeX. There's a LaTeX help button at the bottom left of the typing area.
 
just try and set up the equation for the horizontal components of the forces on the blocks