A pulse of frequencies that start in phase - pulse period?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the behavior of multiple carrier frequencies starting in phase and their periodic alignment over time. Participants explore the relationship between the frequency spacing of 25 kHz and the time period at which all frequencies come back into phase, specifically focusing on a range from 100 MHz to 100.25 MHz. The conversation includes mathematical reasoning and conceptual clarifications regarding phase alignment and periodicity.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant describes a setup of 10 carrier frequencies starting at 100 MHz with 25 kHz spacing, noting they come back in phase every 40 microseconds.
  • Another participant argues that regardless of the number of frequencies, as long as the spacing remains 25 kHz, the frequencies will align every 40 microseconds.
  • Some participants discuss the mathematical relationship between the frequencies and their periods, suggesting that the phase alignment can be derived from the differences in frequency.
  • One participant introduces the concept of the Greatest Common Divisor (GCD) of the frequency sequence as a relevant factor in understanding the periodicity.
  • Another participant provides a detailed mathematical explanation involving sine wave functions and phase differences, illustrating how the frequencies align over time.
  • There is a question raised about how different frequencies can come back in phase despite having different periods, indicating a struggle to visualize the concept.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express varying degrees of understanding regarding the phase alignment of the frequencies. While some agree on the periodicity of 40 microseconds, others question the visualization of how different frequencies can align. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the clarity of this concept.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention the mathematical relationships and assumptions underlying the phase alignment, but there are unresolved aspects regarding the visualization of how multiple frequencies interact and align over time.

Natalie Johnson
Messages
38
Reaction score
0
Hi,

I start at 100 MHz have 10 carrier frequencies all starting in phase at t=0 and the carrier frequencies have 25 kHz spacing. So my frequency range is 100-100.25 MHz, with 10 single frequencies equally spaced in this range.

They come in phase every 4x10-5 seconds. The equation Frequency = 1 / Time_period works for this... with frequency being the frequency of the carrier spacing

The time period between all carriers coming back in phase (after going out of phase at t=0 or at any time after they realign) is directly related to the spacing of the carrier frequencies using this equation. I am struggling to see how this is related but it works. Perhaps I am looking for an elegant explanation of this

Please can someone advise?

Thanks
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
The 100MHz doesn't matter.
If you have only one 25KHz signal, it will be at 0 phase once every cycle. That is once every 40usec, the period.
With two, you still have both of them matching up at phase=0 every 40usec. The 1st one going through 1 cycle each period, the second going through 2 such cycles.
That pattern continues up to ten.
 
Natalie Johnson said:
Hi,

I start at 100 MHz have 10 carrier frequencies all starting in phase at t=0 and the carrier frequencies have 25 kHz spacing. So my frequency range is 100-100.25 MHz, with 10 single frequencies equally spaced in this range.

They come in phase every 4x10-5 seconds. The equation Frequency = 1 / Time_period works for this... with frequency being the frequency of the carrier spacing

The time period between all carriers coming back in phase (after going out of phase at t=0 or at any time after they realign) is directly related to the spacing of the carrier frequencies using this equation. I am struggling to see how this is related but it works. Perhaps I am looking for an elegant explanation of this

Please can someone advise?

Thanks
In effect you have a 25kHz source and you are just looking at one wavelength of it.
This principle applies in other fields. It is possible to find the length of a cable by looking at the repetitive ripple of a VSWR sweep for instance.
It is also possible to ascertain the frequency of a microwave receiver by receiving harmonics of a low frequency carrier and finding the spacing between adjacent low frequency pips.From memory, F = F1^2 / (F1-F2).
 
It's 10 single frequencies, equally spaced every 25khz from a starting frequency of 100MHz to a finish frequency 100.250. Even though all the single frequencies have different time periods, my script shows they all come back in phase every 40 micro seconds.

Also it doesn't matter how many frequencies I add (with increasing the bandwidth past 100.250 to accomaddate more single frequencies), as long as the spacing is 25khz ... it's always repeating every 40 ms...

.Scott said:
The 100MHz doesn't matter.
If you have only one 25KHz signal, it will be at 0 phase once every cycle. That is once every 40usec, the period.
With two, you still have both of them matching up at phase=0 every 40usec. The 1st one going through 1 cycle each period, the second going through 2 such cycles.
That pattern continues up to ten.

If each of these frequencies placed in th 250khz bandwidth are different frequencies, they all have different periods so how would they all come back in phase in the manner you suggest? It's clearly happening but I'm finding it difficult visualising.
tech99 said:
In effect you have a 25kHz source and you are just looking at one wavelength of it.
This principle applies in other fields. It is possible to find the length of a cable by looking at the repetitive ripple of a VSWR sweep for instance.
It is also possible to ascertain the frequency of a microwave receiver by receiving harmonics of a low frequency carrier and finding the spacing between adjacent low frequency pips.From memory, F = F1^2 / (F1-F2).

How is it a 25khz source if it's a new frequency spaced between, it's the spacing not a repeating single frequency?
 
Last edited:
Natalie Johnson said:
If each of these frequencies placed in the 250khz bandwidth are different frequencies, they all have different periods so how would they all come back in phase in the manner you suggest? It's clearly happening but I'm finding it difficult visualising.
I'll take another shot at it.

Let's say we have two sine wave functions, one ##A(t)## at frequency ##a## cycles per second, the other ##B(t)## at frequency ##b## cycles per second. And we will assume that they start in phase at time ##t_0##.
Those functions would be:
##A(t) = sin(2\pi a(t-t_0))##
##B(t) = sin(2\pi b(t-t_0))##

But we are interested in phase. So here are the formulas for phase:
##phase(A(t)) = 2\pi a(t-t_0)##
##phase(B(t)) = 2\pi b(t-t_0)##

And we are specifically interested in when these phases match:
##P_{diff} = phase(A(t)) - phaseB(t)) =## a multiple of ##2\pi##
##P_{diff} = ( 2\pi a(t-t_0) ) - ( 2\pi b(t-t_0) ) =## a multiple of ##2\pi##
##P_{diff} /(2\pi)= ( a(t-t_0) ) - ( b(t-t_0) ) =## is an integer
##P_{diff} /(2\pi)= ( (a-b)(t-t_0) ) =## is an integer
This will happen when
##( (a-b)(t-t_0) ) = 0, 1, 2, 3, ... ##
##t-t_0 = 0/(a-b), 1/(a-b), 2/(a-b), 3/(a-b), ... ##

So what happens is that at ##t=t_0##, ##P_{diff}## is also zero.
As t increases, the phase difference ##P_{diff}## also increases. The first time they will be in phase is when the phase difference is ##2\pi## (##360^{\circ}##).
That will only happen when ##t-t_0 = 1/(a-b)##. That's the first time they match up. The seconds time will be another ##1/(a-b)## seconds, and so on.

In your case, the frequency difference ##(a-b)## is 25KHz, so the period when they repeat will be 1/25KHz = 40usec. So:
at ##t_0+0##usec, the phase difference expressed in full cycles (##2\pi##) would be ##0(a-b) = 0\times25KHz = 0## cycles (##0^{\circ}##).
at ##t_0+5##usec: ##5usec(a-b) = 5usec\times25KHz = 0.125## cycles (##45^{\circ}##).
at ##t_0+10##usec: ##10usec(a-b) = 10usec\times25KHz = 0.25## cycles (##90^{\circ}##).
at ##t_0+20##usec: ##20usec(a-b) = 20usec\times25KHz = 0.5## cycles (##180^{\circ}##).
at ##t_0+40##usec: ##40usec(a-b) = 40usec\times25KHz = 0.5## cycles (##360^{\circ}##).

That should show you why this works with only two. Now look at the case with 10.
The difference between the 1st and 2nd is 25KHz, so they will resync every 40usec.
The difference between the 1st and 3rd is 50KHz, so they will resync every 20usec.
The difference between the 1st and 4th is 75KHz, so they will resync every 40usec/3.
...
The difference between the 1st and 10th is 225KHz, so they will resync every 40usec/9.

So some of the pairs will sync more often that once every 40usec. But they will all be in phase when the first two signals are in phase.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Natalie Johnson

Similar threads

  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
4K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
5K
Replies
17
Views
6K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
6K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K