Discussion Overview
The discussion centers on the allowed and forbidden transition dipole moments between different molecular electronic states in diatomic molecules, specifically addressing both homonuclear and heteronuclear cases. Participants explore the underlying principles, selection rules, and the impact of symmetry on these transitions.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Exploratory
Main Points Raised
- Some participants propose that the basic rule for transition dipole moments involves the expression ||2 > 0, where transitions depend on the symmetry properties of rovibronic wavefunctions.
- It is noted that allowed transitions occur between states of the same spin family, such as singlet to singlet or triplet to triplet, but not singlet to triplet.
- One participant highlights that the rules for allowed and forbidden transitions assume that molecules adhere to established nomenclature, which may not reflect the reality of molecular states due to perturbations.
- Another participant clarifies that there are no allowed or forbidden dipole moments, but rather allowed or forbidden dipole transitions, with a transition being forbidden if the transition dipole moment vanishes.
- A participant raises a specific question regarding heteronuclear diatomic molecules, inquiring about the selection rules and the possibility of transitions between doublet Sigma+ and doublet Delta electronic states, noting their own calculations suggest such transitions exist.
- It is mentioned that heteronuclear diatomic molecules belong to the symmetry group ##C_{\infty v##, and that dipole moment operators can be analyzed using character tables for this group to determine the nature of transitions.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express differing views on the specifics of allowed and forbidden transitions, particularly in the context of heteronuclear diatomic molecules. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the selection rules for these molecules and the implications of perturbations on transition dipole moments.
Contextual Notes
Limitations include the dependence on symmetry properties and the potential for perturbations to affect the actual states of molecules, which may not conform strictly to the established selection rules.