- #1

- 391

- 6

I'm having a bit of trouble with two analysis questions, they are:

1) a_n -> a iff every subsequence of {a_n} converges to a

2) a_n->a iff {a_n} is bounded, and a is its only cluster point.

For the first, I was thinking of doing something along the lines of saying that a subsequence of a_n would be a_(f(n)); that is, f being a function that maps the natural numbers onto itself, and has the properly that whenever n>= m, f(n) >= f(m) (nondecreasing) and from there, saying that |a_n - a| < eps given some eps(ilon), for all n> N (Where N is a natural number)... and then arguing that, since f(n) spits out a natural number, then for some f(n) >= N, a_f(n) thus has the limit...

For the second (and probably the first too, but I can't see it?), I'm supposed to make use of the theorem:

i) x is a cluster point of {x_n} <---> for all eps>0, N natural number, there exists an n > N such that |x_n - x| < eps, x real number

ii) x is a cluster point of {x_n} iff there exists a converging subsequence {x_(n_k)} of {x_n} that converges to x.

I'm unsure as to how to approach the second one.. but my idea is..

First, work my way from a_n->a to a_n is bounded, and a is a cluster point, and work backward from there.

However, I'm unsure as to how cluster points and limits are related...

I'd really appreciate it if someone can point out where I could begin, and possibly clarify some things I'm confused about... if possible. :D

Thanks for

1) a_n -> a iff every subsequence of {a_n} converges to a

2) a_n->a iff {a_n} is bounded, and a is its only cluster point.

For the first, I was thinking of doing something along the lines of saying that a subsequence of a_n would be a_(f(n)); that is, f being a function that maps the natural numbers onto itself, and has the properly that whenever n>= m, f(n) >= f(m) (nondecreasing) and from there, saying that |a_n - a| < eps given some eps(ilon), for all n> N (Where N is a natural number)... and then arguing that, since f(n) spits out a natural number, then for some f(n) >= N, a_f(n) thus has the limit...

For the second (and probably the first too, but I can't see it?), I'm supposed to make use of the theorem:

i) x is a cluster point of {x_n} <---> for all eps>0, N natural number, there exists an n > N such that |x_n - x| < eps, x real number

ii) x is a cluster point of {x_n} iff there exists a converging subsequence {x_(n_k)} of {x_n} that converges to x.

I'm unsure as to how to approach the second one.. but my idea is..

First, work my way from a_n->a to a_n is bounded, and a is a cluster point, and work backward from there.

However, I'm unsure as to how cluster points and limits are related...

I'd really appreciate it if someone can point out where I could begin, and possibly clarify some things I'm confused about... if possible. :D

Thanks for

**any**replies!
Last edited: