Pau Hernandez
- 13
- 3
Hello,
I am confused about the Lorentz Force. For a point charge it is: $$\vec{F} = q \cdot ( \vec{E} + \vec{v} \times \vec{B} )$$
Now from what I understand the E and the B field are external fields. So we are not talking about the fields created by the charge itself.
Now where it gets confusing. If we extend this concept to continuous charge distributions, then: $$d\vec{F} = dq \cdot ( \vec{E} + \vec{v} \times \vec{B} ) = \rho \cdot dV \cdot ( \vec{E} + \vec{v} \times \vec{B} ) = \rho \cdot dV \cdot \vec{E} + \vec{J} \times \vec{B} \cdot dV )$$ For the force density f, it follows $$\vec{f} = \rho \cdot \vec{E} + \vec{J} \times \vec{B}$$ Now here, again the E and the B field are external fields. Suppose I have a charged body. To get the net force I integrate the force density over the whole volume of the body. So lets pick one volume element as an example. In this case I would have to consider the contribution to the E and B field that stem from other volume elements (because there are charges) but actually ignore the E and B field that are produced in the volume element that I am currently 'looking' at?
Where it gets even more confusing is by considering a current carrying wire loop. The force law states: $$\vec{F} = I \cdot \int { d\vec{l} \times \vec{B} }$$ Do I have to consider the B-field that is 'produced' by other wire elements dl?
Last but not least. If we take Lorentz Force law and do some algebra, we end up with Maxwell's stress tensor. Same question here. What are the E and the B fields that have to be considered in Maxwell's stress tensor?
I am confused about the Lorentz Force. For a point charge it is: $$\vec{F} = q \cdot ( \vec{E} + \vec{v} \times \vec{B} )$$
Now from what I understand the E and the B field are external fields. So we are not talking about the fields created by the charge itself.
Now where it gets confusing. If we extend this concept to continuous charge distributions, then: $$d\vec{F} = dq \cdot ( \vec{E} + \vec{v} \times \vec{B} ) = \rho \cdot dV \cdot ( \vec{E} + \vec{v} \times \vec{B} ) = \rho \cdot dV \cdot \vec{E} + \vec{J} \times \vec{B} \cdot dV )$$ For the force density f, it follows $$\vec{f} = \rho \cdot \vec{E} + \vec{J} \times \vec{B}$$ Now here, again the E and the B field are external fields. Suppose I have a charged body. To get the net force I integrate the force density over the whole volume of the body. So lets pick one volume element as an example. In this case I would have to consider the contribution to the E and B field that stem from other volume elements (because there are charges) but actually ignore the E and B field that are produced in the volume element that I am currently 'looking' at?
Where it gets even more confusing is by considering a current carrying wire loop. The force law states: $$\vec{F} = I \cdot \int { d\vec{l} \times \vec{B} }$$ Do I have to consider the B-field that is 'produced' by other wire elements dl?
Last but not least. If we take Lorentz Force law and do some algebra, we end up with Maxwell's stress tensor. Same question here. What are the E and the B fields that have to be considered in Maxwell's stress tensor?
Last edited: