Archimedes principle with a completely submerged ball

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
4 replies · 2K views
dasky
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Greetings,
I have a question about the classic Archimede's principle.
A ball inflated with air will not sink into water. My understanding is that it will be pushed from all directions by the surrounding water trying to fill the space occupied by the ball. So there will be a pressure downwards formed by the water column above the ball, and there will be pressure upwards from the water below the ball, and obviously on the sides.
My question is: if a ball is completely submerged there will be a lot of pressure downwards but no or very little pressure upwards, will the ball remain submerged?
Thanks
Dasky
 
Physics news on Phys.org
dasky said:
My question is: if a ball is completely submerged there will be a lot of pressure downwards but no or very little pressure upwards,
No, your premise is wrong. The pressure is higher at the bottom of the ball (it is deeper and pressure grows linearly with depth).
 
Then what about a different container, like a box, resting on the bottom of a pool? the face in contact with the surface of the pool will have no water pushing upwards, so will it remain down?
 
dasky said:
Greetings,
I have a question about the classic Archimede's principle.
A ball inflated with air will not sink into water. My understanding is that it will be pushed from all directions by the surrounding water trying to fill the space occupied by the ball. So there will be a pressure downwards formed by the water column above the ball, and there will be pressure upwards from the water below the ball, and obviously on the sides.
My question is: if a ball is completely submerged there will be a lot of pressure downwards but no or very little pressure upwards, will the ball remain submerged?
Thanks
Dasky
The pressure under the ball will be greater because it is deeper.
By the way, I have noticed that if such a ball is pushed down under water and then released, the upward acceleration cannot exceed -g. This is because water has to fall by gravity into the space vacated in order to create the upthrust.
 
dasky said:
Then what about a different container, like a box, resting on the bottom of a pool? the face in contact with the surface of the pool will have no water pushing upwards, so will it remain down?

If you can arrange it such that really no water slips in. This is difficult, but a priori possible.