Basic Forces Question from 9th grader - Hard to put in words

  • #1
29
0

Homework Statement


I have here a problem asking me to find the tension force on the lower end of a rod with mass of 0.6 kg. The rod connects two blocks, the first / upper one has a mass of 5.0 kg while other/lower one has a mass of 4.0 kg. There is an upward force of 150 N applied on the whole system.

Homework Equations


Given:
F = 150 N
Mass of whole system : 9.6 kg (mass of upper block+mass of rod + mass of lower)
a = 150 N/9.6 kg
a= 15.625 m/s^2

The Attempt at a Solution


Knowing that the system has acceleration:
Fnet= ma
Fnet = Tb (tension force on point b/ lower end of rod) - (Weight of rod + Weight of lower block)
Tb - (Wrod + Wlowrblck) = ma
HERE IS MY QUESTION (only capitalised for emphasis)
Tb - (5.88 N + 39.2 N) = ma
Tb - 45.08 N = m (15.625 m/s^2)
At this juncture I was having 2nd thoughts on what mass to use but since this problem is in multiple choice, I had to try out some things:
Tb - 45.08 = (4.6 kg)(15.625 m/s^2) -------> the mass I used is the sum of the masses of rod and lower block
Tb = 116.96 N -------> This answer was too large and was not part of the choices.
I had an alternative:
Tb - 45.08 = (0.6 kg)(15.625 m/s^2) ---------> this time I plugged in only the mass of the rod
Tb = 54.455 or approximately 54 N -------> This answer of mine was part of the choices so decided to stick with it.
If my 2nd solution is correct, why should I only consider the mass of the rod and not include the mass of the lower block?
Thank You very much
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Answers and Replies

  • #2
20,772
4,501
Welcome to Physics Forums.

It's very hard to picture this. Can you provide a diagram?

I assume the force is applied to the bottom of the stack? Have you drawn a free body diagram on the lower block and shown the forces acting on it?

Chet
 
  • #3
gleem
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
1,748
1,098
I would expect that since there is a reference to tension, vis-a vis compression, which to me implies a stretching of the connecting rod that the force is applied to the upper mass.
 
  • #4
20,772
4,501
OK. So, again, have you drawn a free body diagram on the lower mass and shown the forces acting on it? Based on this free body diagram, what is the force balance on the lower mass?

Chet
 
  • #5
29
0
Mod note: Copied diagram from Word doc and added it as an attachment.
Here is the diagram of the problem. Thank you for replying.
FBD.png
 

Attachments

Last edited by a moderator:
  • #6
145
12
the answer is 62.5 N my friend
Who's gonna calculate gravity as an external force(as the 150 N force acts upwards,gravity acts on the whole system downwards)
still make the question a bit clear,would you?
 
  • #7
145
12
My friend,it's obvious gravity's there
Please redo your question and i'll tell you something called the centre of mass method to solve such problems(:))
 
  • #8
Ray Vickson
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Dearly Missed
10,706
1,728
My friend,it's obvious gravity's there
Please redo your question and i'll tell you something called the centre of mass method to solve such problems(:))
It is not at all obvious that gravity is present; it was not mentioned in the original problem. The whole thing could be here on earth in the presence of gravity, or it could be in outer space where there is no significant gravitational force on such a small object.

Certainly the OP should clarify this issue!
 
  • #9
20,772
4,501
Assuming, as UchichaClan13 suggests, that gravity is present.

You already determined that the mass of the combined assembly is 9.6 kg. Using the equation w = mg, what is the weight of the combined assembly?
From your free body diagram, there are two external forces acting on the assembly: 150 N and the weight (gravitational force) mg. What is the net force? What is the acceleration?

Next, you are going to have to do a free body diagram on just the lower block so that you can determine the force of the rod acting on this block. From Newton's 3rd law, how would this force compare with the tension force that the lower block applies to the rod?

Chet
 
  • #10
SammyS
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
11,349
1,023
upload_2016-1-27_18-19-1.png
 
  • #11
145
12
space where there is no significant gravitational force on such a small object.
that's true but my friend,surely the question would have been elaborated further by the OP wouldn't it???
It's normally assumed that when we say that the 150 n force pulls the system upwards ,there's gravity acting downwards!
 
  • #12
Ray Vickson
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Dearly Missed
10,706
1,728
that's true but my friend,surely the question would have been elaborated further by the OP wouldn't it???
It's normally assumed that when we say that the 150 n force pulls the system upwards ,there's gravity acting downwards!
Normally, yes, but who knows if that is the case here? I refuse to assume; I would rather have the OP state clearly all the conditions of the problem. I know, I know... if one speaks of upward and downward that typically refers to the direction of gravity, but again, I am unwilling to make an assumption. Much better, I think, would be to force the OP to deal with the issue!
 
  • #13
jbriggs444
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
9,474
4,165
Normally, yes, but who knows if that is the case here? I refuse to assume; I would rather have the OP state clearly all the conditions of the problem. I know, I know... if one speaks of upward and downward that typically refers to the direction of gravity, but again, I am unwilling to make an assumption. Much better, I think, would be to force the OP to deal with the issue!
Suppose that you add gravity to the free body diagram based on some unknown local gravitational field strength. Does that field strength change the final answer?
 
  • #14
20,772
4,501
Suppose that you add gravity to the free body diagram based on some unknown local gravitational field strength. Does that field strength change the final answer?
$$150-9.6g=9.6a\tag{overall force balance}$$
where a is the acceleration of the assembly. So,
$$a=\frac{150}{9.6}-g$$
$$T-4g=4a\tag{force balance on lower mass}$$
where T is the tension exerted by the rod on the lower mass, and the tension exerted by the lower mass on the rod.
So,
$$g+a=\frac{T}{4}=\frac{150}{9.6}$$
So, $$T=62.5 N$$

Yikes, you're right. The answer to the problem does not depend on whether gravity is included or not.
 
  • #15
145
12
So,
T=62.5NT=62.5N​
T=62.5 N

Yikes, you're right. The answer to the problem does not depend on whether gravity is included or not.
See told you
gravity assumption would yield the correct answer
:)
 

Related Threads on Basic Forces Question from 9th grader - Hard to put in words

Replies
9
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
0
Views
906
Replies
3
Views
9K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
18
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
1K
Top