Basic physics question (frequency/energy relation)

In summary, the higher the frequency, the higher the energy. However, when a medium is involved, the lower frequencies have more energy to perturb it. This might be why the lower frequencies are the ones that make it through.
  • #1
SoPM
6
1
I almost feel embarrassed to ask this. I've always understood it to be that the higher the frequency, the higher the energy (at least from what I've been taught). However, something has always bugged me: why then, when a medium is involved, are the lower frequencies the ones that make it through? Wouldn't this mean that the lower frequencies have more energy to perturb that medium?

Examples of what I mean,
Sound: If someone is blasting music in their car, or you walk outside past a night club, you hear the bass (lower frequency).

Light: At sunrise/sunset, the sun looks yellow/gold because it has to travel through more atmosphere, deflecting the higher frequencies and only the lower frequencies (orange, yellow) reach you eyes.

Perhaps this has to do with resonant frequencies but I'm not sure. Could someone explain the relationship between frequency and energy that explains this?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Consider water waves. It's easy to build a breakwater that will protect a harbor against the highly energetic waves that a storm drives in - these smash excitingly and energetically against the breakwater, throwing spouts of white water many meters into the sky with every peak in amplitiude. But compare with the low-energy, low frequency (twelve hours!), long wavelength (halfway around the earth!) wave represented by the tides... these drift gently in, passing the breakwater as quietly as they pass any other random piece of topography along the coast, and over a period of hours they move the water level in the harbor by their full amplitude.

Intuitively, what's going on here is that the lower-frequency wave is changing the height of the water more slowly so that the water level has time to adjust and the next increase in height will build on the previous one. The higher-frequency storm wave piles water up against the breakwater, but before the water has time to flow on into the harbor the next trough has come along.
 
  • Like
Likes Geofleur
  • #3
First, your statement that "the lower frequencies are the the ones that makes it through" is a generalization without support.
Metals are opaque to visible but transparent in UV and some bands in x-rays. Just one example that contradict this statement.
Transmission coefficient of EM waves is a complicated function of wavelengths and you cannot make any general statements, valid for any material and spectral range.
Air scatters more blues than red due to the size of the scattering centers rather than the energy of the radiation. It is valid when the model of Rayleigh scattering is applicable.
You can have a medium that scatters more lower frequencies than higher frequencies.

And second, the statement that higher frequency waves have more energy than lower frequency waves makes sense for quantised waves, like the EM waves. It just means that a quanta has more energy at higher frequencies.
In the case of sound waves described by a continuous model, what would this mean? A tsunami wave with amplitude of tens of meters will have less energy than an ultrasound beam used for medical imaging? The energy of the wave itself depends on both amplitude and frequency.
 
  • #4
If you refer to the equation
E =hf,
that relates the energy of photons to their frequency. It doesn't relate to the amplitude of a wave, which (squared) relates to the Power density. The number of photons for a given power will relate to individual photon energy.
Linking this to the behaviour of mechanical (water) waves is a big step. Is all that not more related to matching of the different wavelengths to the structures involved and propagation losses of surface water waves?
 

1. What is the relationship between frequency and energy in basic physics?

The relationship between frequency and energy is given by the formula E = hf, where E is energy, h is Planck's constant, and f is frequency. This means that as the frequency increases, the energy also increases.

2. How is the frequency of a wave related to its energy?

The frequency of a wave is directly proportional to its energy. This means that as the frequency increases, the energy also increases. This relationship is known as the energy-frequency relation.

3. Does the energy of a wave always increase with frequency?

Yes, the energy of a wave always increases with frequency. This is because the energy of a wave is directly proportional to its frequency, as shown by the formula E = hf.

4. Is there a minimum frequency for a wave to have energy?

Yes, there is a minimum frequency for a wave to have energy. This is known as the threshold frequency and is determined by the material or medium through which the wave is traveling.

5. How does the energy of a wave change when its frequency is doubled?

If the frequency of a wave is doubled, its energy will also double. This is because the energy of a wave is directly proportional to its frequency, as shown by the formula E = hf.

Similar threads

Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
78
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
160
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
20
Views
1K
  • Science and Math Textbooks
Replies
3
Views
784
Replies
16
Views
2K
Replies
29
Views
2K
Back
Top