Bob's Relativistic Velocity Addition: 0.9c for Alice & Charlie

In summary, Bob is floating in deep space with two powerful cannons that shoot his friends Alice and Charlie in opposite directions at 0.9c. Bob can only look at one friend at a time, making him feel secure that no one is traveling faster than the speed of light. However, Alice and Charlie would see themselves receding from each other at 1.8c due to the relativistic velocity addition formula. Bob wonders if he can shoot his friends out at 0.9c relative to each other without them seeing it this way, and the answer is yes according to the velocity-addition formula.
  • #1
DiracPool
1,243
516
My name is Bob. I'm floating in deep space and I have these two powerful cannons that shoot my friends Alice and Charlie in opposite directions to me, one to the left and one to the right. I shoot each out at 0.9c. As I look to the left, I see that Alice is flying away from me at 0.9c. Then I turn to the right and see Charlie is also flying away from me at 0.9c. So I'm feeling pretty secure because I'm thinking, well, since I can only look at one at a time, nobody here is traveling faster than c. But then I think, well, Alice and Charlie are probably looking at each other here, and they must see themselves receding from each other at 1.8c. But then I'm thinking that there's some relativistic velocity addition thing going on between Alice and Charlie that I'm not privy too whereby they see themselves as traveling at less than c relative to each other.

Do I have this correct? Can I shoot out my friends out at 0.9 c relative to each other in opposite directions and see it this way without them seeing it this way?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
DiracPool said:
Can I shoot out my friends out at 0.9 c relative to each other in opposite directions and see it this way without them seeing it this way?
Yes.
 
  • #3
  • #4
Friends who shoot friends aren't good friends.
Anyway, just use that equation, and they'll never be superluminal.
 
  • #5
It doesn't matter if you can see them both at the same time or not; it's easy to modify your scenario so that you see them fly past each other. In fact it has little to do with what you or they literally see.
Apart of that, yes you use the velocity transformation formula to calculate how each would measure the speed of the other if they set up a standard reference system in which they themselves are considered to be in rest.
 

Similar threads

Replies
6
Views
4K
Replies
16
Views
3K
Replies
55
Views
3K
Replies
70
Views
4K
Replies
11
Views
2K
Back
Top