Break between grad& undergrad phx for master's in philosophy?

[quasar_4]

Another question:

A lot of people have discussed the idea of a year off between undergrad and grad. school. My question is, would it be looked upon negatively if during my 1-2 years off I did something not directly physics? I'm considering doing a Master's in the Philosophy of Physics, which wouldn't at all quite be physics, but would be really interesting (I think). I love picking up my old books and reviewing, so I'm pretty sure I could keep my technical skills sharp until time for physics PhD, but just wondered what all of YOU think.

 

[Sir_Arthur]

I don't know what impact it would have on you admissions-wise (though I assume it would be small), but I think it would be a brilliant idea life-wise. Expanding your mind in a non-technical way is probably really good for you, and if you would take the masters at the same institution you wish to acquire your Phd from, it would probably help admissions.

 

[Vanadium 50]

I disagree. It shows a lack of focus. I also don't believe that you'll "keep your skills sharp". You don't do that by reviewing what you already know. You do that by learning new things.

 

[ice109]

I disagree. It shows a lack of focus. I also don't believe that you'll "keep your skills sharp". You don't do that by reviewing what you already know. You do that by learning new things.

you know i hate that most people on admission's committees will agree with you. i don't understand - i/we/proverbial you shouldn't have any other interests aside from physics/math/1 thing?

and if you're going to rebutt by saying well you can pursue those on the side i say what if my interest in this/these other things is so great that i want to study it intensely. it's a no brainer then to go to a place of higher learning where they study that isn't it.

 

[Vanadium 50]

A PhD is a specialized degree - it requires specialization. There are people who are tempermentally unsuited for this kind of specialization, and they tend to do poorly in a PhD program. It's in the department's best interest not to accept them.

 

[cristo]

I agree with V. Sure you can have interests elsewhere, but if you want to take a masters degree in these other subjects, then you are not focused enough to undertake a Phd program.

 

[kodiakghost]

I will agree and disagree. If you are a genius, that helps. Make a 99% on your physics subject GRE and I don't think pursuing a masters in philosophy will hurt.