Calculating Force of Jumping Motorcycle

  • Context: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Thread starter SPIAction
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Motorcycle
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around calculating the force associated with a falling mass, specifically in the context of a motorcycle jumping and landing on a ramp. Participants explore the implications of mass, gravitational force, and the effects of momentum during impact, while considering various factors such as speed, angle, and ramp design.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant asks how to calculate the maximum reading on a scale when a 10-pound brick is dropped from a height, seeking to understand the force of impact.
  • Another participant states that the downward force on falling objects is constant and is calculated as mass times gravitational acceleration, suggesting that the trajectory does not affect this force.
  • Some participants emphasize that the question should focus on "impact load" rather than just force, noting that the change in momentum is critical when the motorcycle lands.
  • There is a discussion about the role of suspension in affecting the deceleration time and thus the impact load on the ramp.
  • One participant proposes a simplified scenario involving a bowling ball rolling down a ramp and questions how to calculate the force upon landing, while others caution against oversimplifying the problem.
  • Another participant provides a mathematical approach to calculating maximum force based on mass, velocity, and deceleration time, presenting different scenarios with varying deceleration times leading to different force outcomes.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the need to consider both force and momentum in the context of impact, but there is no consensus on the best approach to calculate the impact force or the specific factors that should be prioritized in the calculations. Multiple competing views remain regarding the importance of various parameters such as ramp design and deceleration time.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that the calculations depend on several assumptions, including the time it takes for the motorcycle to decelerate upon landing, which can vary significantly based on the suspension system and other factors. The discussion highlights the complexity of accurately determining impact forces in real-world scenarios.

SPIAction
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Hey guys,

New to the forum but full of so many questions, of which I assume will be a cakewalk for many of you. I'm no physics expert as you will soon discover.

Looking foward to your input and assistance.

The first question is how do I calculate the force associated with a falling mass? For example, if you take a 10 pound brick and drop it 10 feet on a scale, what would be the maximum reading that I would see on the scale? Wind resistance and such aside.

The next question is similar but a little more complicated.

If I know the angle and height of a jump, the speed of an appoaching motorcycle, and the total weight of the bike with rider, how would I calculate the amount of force that the bike/rider has as it returns to earth? In other words, I assume that the falling mass will hit with a force greater than the total weight of bike and rider, with respects to the curve that it takes as it flys through the air.

Let's say I'm just trying to calculate how strong the landing ramp needs to be. Something like that. Putting the matter of the suspension and such aside.

Hope that makes sense.

Thoughts?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The downward force on falling objects is always constant (if you put air resistance aside). The downward force would always be the mass of the object times the gravitational acceleration of the Earth (roughly 9.8 m/s2). The curve with which the bike travels doesn't make any difference.
 
This question is asked over & over again in many different guises. The question is not "how much force."

Nerd is right, as far as he/she goes: mass times gravitational acceleration equals the force. But that just tells you the weight of the object (in your case, mcycle + rider). It doesn't tell you anything about the momentum (which depends on both mass and speed). And when you hit the ramp, it is the change in momentum that you are concerned with.

What you want to know is the "impact load" on your landing-ramp. That question is probably better asked in the engineering section of the forum. The answer you're going to get there is, "well that depends..." Because, well, it depends on how long it takes for you and your bike to decelerate from your landing speed to the final speed. This time is a few fractions of a second, and the shorter it is, the more impact load your ramp has to withstand. The time it takes depends a lot on the suspension - since a long springy suspension will stretch out the time and make for a softer landing. That's why you bike has springs to begin with. Eventually you will find that the only way to really know is to do some experiments. There may also be some empirical correlations (that's a fancy name for basing your estimate on other people's experiments, or thumb rules).

Good luck.
 
Nerd said:
The downward force on falling objects is always constant (if you put air resistance aside). The downward force would always be the mass of the object times the gravitational acceleration of the Earth (roughly 9.8 m/s2). The curve with which the bike travels doesn't make any difference.

Ah...good stuff and thanks for the info.

So...just to make sure that I have this correct, for as elementary as it may seem, if we have a ball that is 10 kilograms in weight (the mass) and we drop it any distance (assuming is can reach its maximum velocity) the force of the impact is 98 kgf?
 
gmax137 said:
This question is asked over & over again in many different guises. The question is not "how much force."

Nerd is right, as far as he/she goes: mass times gravitational acceleration equals the force. But that just tells you the weight of the object (in your case, mcycle + rider). It doesn't tell you anything about the momentum (which depends on both mass and speed). And when you hit the ramp, it is the change in momentum that you are concerned with.

What you want to know is the "impact load" on your landing-ramp. That question is probably better asked in the engineering section of the forum. The answer you're going to get there is, "well that depends..." Because, well, it depends on how long it takes for you and your bike to decelerate from your landing speed to the final speed. This time is a few fractions of a second, and the shorter it is, the more impact load your ramp has to withstand. The time it takes depends a lot on the suspension - since a long springy suspension will stretch out the time and make for a softer landing. That's why you bike has springs to begin with. Eventually you will find that the only way to really know is to do some experiments. There may also be some empirical correlations (that's a fancy name for basing your estimate on other people's experiments, or thumb rules).

Good luck.


Thanks!

So what if we simplify this by saying that we are rolling a bowling ball at a given speed, at a ramp that is 2 feet long and one feet high?

Can we calculate how much force the ball will hit the ground (landing) with?

And then what happen if the ramp is curved instead of being flat?
 
SPIAction said:
Ah...good stuff and thanks for the info.

So...just to make sure that I have this correct, for as elementary as it may seem, if we have a ball that is 10 kilograms in weight (the mass) and we drop it any distance (assuming is can reach its maximum velocity) the force of the impact is 98 kgf?
The unit for force is Newton (N). But the 98N is just the weight on the ball (which is always there, whether it's bouncing, flying or rolling, etc). If a ball is lying still on a surface, the weight gets canceled out by the force that the surface exerts on the object. But if it bounces, the force exerted by the surface is bigger than the weight (the force is the reason it is accelerated upwards again), or equal to the weight if we assume it doesn't bounce and there is no suspension etc (so this statement doesn't make a lot of sense in the first place).
SPIAction said:
Thanks!

So what if we simplify this by saying that we are rolling a bowling ball at a given speed, at a ramp that is 2 feet long and one feet high?

Can we calculate how much force the ball will hit the ground (landing) with?

And then what happen if the ramp is curved instead of being flat?

It makes no sense to simplify it down any further and to work with forces here.
gmax137 said:
The question is not "how much force."

I'd recommend to read gmax's post again. That's pretty much all there is to it. You might want to read up on momentum and Newton's laws of motion.
 
The motorcycle + rider mass and weight is m and mg respectively. If the motorcycle + driver's downward velocity times mass is mv, and it hits a horizontal ramp, then the impulse (force times time) is integral [F*dt]= mv. Using 200 kg and 2 meters/sec for m and v, and dt = 0.1 seconds, then Fmax = about 4000 Newtons, or about 2 g's.
 
Bob S said:
Using 200 kg and 2 meters/sec for m and v, and dt = 0.1 seconds, then Fmax = about 4000 Newtons, or about 2 g's.

OK, and using 200 kg and 2 meters/sec for m and v, and dt = 0.2 seconds, then Fmax = about 2000 Newtons; using the same and 0.05 seconds you get 8000 N, etc.

That's why I said above "it depends." Unless you quantify the time to decelerate to zero, you don't have a number you can use to design your ramp.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 86 ·
3
Replies
86
Views
15K
  • · Replies 44 ·
2
Replies
44
Views
8K
  • · Replies 46 ·
2
Replies
46
Views
9K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 49 ·
2
Replies
49
Views
5K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
9K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
6K