Calculating the flux through the spherical surfaces at certain radius

13 replies · 3K views · last reply
falyusuf
Messages
35
Reaction score
3
Homework Statement
Point charges 5 uC, -3 uC, 2 uC and 10 uC are located at (-12, 0,5). (0, 3,-4),(2, -6, 3) and (3, 0, 0), respectively. Calculate the flux through the spherical surfaces at:
i) r= 1
ii) r= 10
iii) r=15

* u = 10^-6 *
Relevant Equations
Attached below.
Relevant Equation:
Gauss's law in integral form: a closed surface integral over S of D dot ds equals Q enc, with a circle-with-cross closed-integral symbol and vector arrows on D and ds.

My attempt:
Handwritten-style typeset working for electric flux density D at points: R1 = (0,0,0)-(-12,0,5), R2, R3, R4 vectors, then D = Q/(4 pi R^2) a_R, with D1 to D4 and D_Total computed as sums in r, theta and phi unit vectors.

Handwritten-style worked solution of electric flux through spheres: phi equals closed surface integral of D dot dS equals D times 4 pi r squared r-hat, then values at r = 1, 10 and 15 giving 27309.96547 C, 273099.6547 C and 409649.482 C.

Could someone please confirm my answer?
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten-style typeset derivation of electric flux density D for four point charges: vector differences R1 to R4, then D1 to D4 with numeric coefficients, and the total D_Total summed at the end.
    1637444649520.png
    20.4 KB · Views: 205
You can't magically greate 10 digit accuracy results from 1 digit givens !

What is ##Q_{enc}## for ##r= 1## ?

##\ ##
 
BvU said:
You can't magically greate 10 digit accuracy results from 1 digit givens !

What is ##Q_{enc}## for ##r= 1## ?

##\ ##
Yes the answers I got were not reasonable and tried to figure out my mistakes but I couldn't.

I think it's -3 uC as r in the point (0, 3,-4) is 0, which is less than r=1.
so, the total charge enclosed is -3 uC.
 
I must asssume you have correctly given the problem statement
Calculate the flux through the spherical surfaces at:
i) r= 1
etc. And my interpretation is that such spheres are centered at the origin. So that the enclosed charge is zero for ##r=1##.
And that you are making a fairly simple exercise quite complicated unnecessarily.

Like in the other problem: what are the units for flux in your textbook ?

##\ ##
 
BvU said:
Like in the other problem: what are the units for flux in your textbook ?
It's Coulomb.

Gauss law equation: psi exiting equals the closed surface integral over S of D-bar dot dS-bar, which equals Q enc.
 
BvU said:
And my interpretation is that such spheres are centered at the origin. So that the enclosed charge is zero for r=1.
Sorry, I didn't get it. Could you explain further?
 
falyusuf said:
It's Coulomb.

View attachment 292834
Confusing (for me, at least). SI unit for electric flux is different.

falyusuf said:
Sorry, I didn't get it. Could you explain further?
The exercise asks for the flux through a spherical shell with radius 1 around the origin (then 10, then 15).

I don't understand what you do with your ##\overline{R_1}## etc.

* u = 10^-6 *
There is a ##\mu## under the 'insert symbol' button:
Symbol palette from the forum editor showing Greek letters, math operators and symbols, with the Greek letter mu highlighted in yellow.


But (much better): with a little ##\LaTeX## you can do all kinds of math. ##\mu## becomes ##\mu##

There is a guide button at lower left:

Screenshot of two forum links in blue text, 'LaTeX Guide' and 'BBcode Guide', separated by a vertical bar.


##\ ##
 
BvU said:
I don't understand what you do with your R1― etc.
I assume that R1 is the vector between point 1 and the origin and found it by
Text reading |r − r_k|; where r is the point at the origin (0,0,0) and r_k is (−12,0,5), the point at which the point charge is equal to 5 µC.
 
What would you need that vector for ?

##\ ##
 
BvU said:
What would you need that vector for ?

##\ ##
Get its length and substitute it in this formula:
Gauss's law as a closed surface integral of D dot dS equals Q enc, followed by D equals Q over 4 pi R squared times the unit vector a_R, with R squared highlighted in yellow.
 
Handwritten equations: D-bar equals Q over 4 pi R squared times a-R-hat, and D1-bar equals 5 times 10 to the minus 6 times (12 r-hat minus 5 phi-hat) over 4 pi times (sqrt(12 squared plus 5 squared)) cubed, equals 2173.258 r-hat minus 905.5243 phi-hat C/m squared.

Seems to me ##\overline {a_R}## is a unit vector. Right ?

This formula calculates ##\overline D## at the origin. Not what you want. The exercise asks for a flux (in your case apparently an electric displacement flux).

##\ ##
 
BvU said:
Seems to me aR― is a unit vector. Right ?
BvU said:
Seems to me aR― is a unit vector. Right ?
Yes. I think about it more and find that it'll be easier to get r from the given points using this formula:
Typeset equation r = square root of (x^2 + y^2 + z^2), with the radical covering the sum of three squared terms.

and then simply;
Handwritten calculation of distances from the origin: R1 = sqrt(12^2 + 5^2) = 13, R2 = sqrt(3^2 + 4^2) = 5, R3 = sqrt(2^2 + 6^2 + 3^2) = 7, R4 = sqrt(3^2) = 3; below, cases r = 1, r = 10 and r = 15 with phi values written out.

Right?
 
Makes much more sense to me than post #1 !
And no hassle with 10-digit numbers either :wink:

##\ ##
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: falyusuf
BvU said:
Makes much more sense to me than post #1 !
And no hassle with 10-digit numbers either :wink:

##\ ##
Thank you so much. Appreciate your help
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: BvU