Calculating the flux through a certain radius (concentric charged spheres)

5 replies · 2K views · last reply
falyusuf
Messages
35
Reaction score
3
Homework Statement
Attached below.
Relevant Equations
Attached below.
Question
Printed textbook problem: three concentric spherical shells at r = 1, 2 and 3 m with charge densities 2, -4 and 5 µC/m²; part (a) asks for flux at r = 1.5 m and 2.5 m, part (b) asks for D at r = 0.5, 2.5 and 3.5 m.


My attempt for the 1st part, when r = 1.5 m
Handwritten-style derivation of Gauss's law: flux integral of D over closed surface equals Q enc equals volume integral of rho v dv, then a triple integral with 2 times 10^-6 and limits 1 to 1.5 for r, 0 to pi for theta, 0 to 2 pi for phi, giving 1.9897 times 10^-5 C, then D = 7.037 times 10^-7 C/m^2.


Could someone confirm my answer?
 
Hi,

Do you know what a shell is ?
You seem to integrate something from 1 to 1.5 m. What is that ?
Did you notice the dimension of the given charge distributions ? Does that match your ##\rho_v## ?
I also have trouble understanding what your symbols mean. ##\phi = Q## ?

##\ ##
 
BvU said:
You seem to integrate something from 1 to 1.5 m. What is that ?
Handwritten-style derivation of Gauss's law: flux phi equals the closed integral of D dot dS, equal to Q enc, equal to the volume integral of rho_s ds, then evaluated as 2 times 10^-6 r^2 times the integrals over Phi from 0 to 2pi and theta from 0 to pi of sin theta, with r = 1, giving 2.5133 times 10^-5 C and D = 2 times 10^-6 C/m^2.

BvU said:
also have trouble understanding what your symbols mean. ϕ=Q ?
Gauss law equation: Gauss Law heading above psi exiting equals the closed surface integral over S of D dot dS, equal to Q enc.
 
Sparse with words we are, eh ?
So what is flux in your context ? Units ?
You are asked to calculate the flux through ##r = 1.5## m as a starter in part (a).
falyusuf said:
My attempt for the 1st part, when r = 1.5 m
In post #3 the volume integral you wrote in post #1 is replaced by a surface integral. Good ! And you write $$\phi = \oint \overline D\, \overline{dS} = Q_{enc} =\int \rho_s ds$$ where I must suppose ##D = \varepsilon_0 E## ?

In my book the electric flux in such a nice spherically symmetric case is ##\Phi = EA## with E the electric field strength in Newton/Coulomb and A the area in m2 . In other words, I get $$\Phi = \oint {\overline {D}\over \varepsilon_0}\; \overline{dS} = {Q_{enc}\over \varepsilon_0}$$ and the units are Nm2/C.

We are still in part (a) first question. I agree that ##Q_{enc} = \rho_s \, 4\pi \,r^2## with ##r = 1 m##.
second and third (a) questions remain unanswered ?
---

Moving on to part (b) first question:

Your exercise composer makes life difficult by re-using symbol ##r## in r = 1.5 m where ##D## is asked for. We no longer need the ##\varepsilon_0##.
You are smart enough to replace ##r## by ##R## (without explaining:mad:) but then you take ##R= 1 ## m (given) ?

##\ ##
 
BvU said:
Sparse with words we are, eh ?
So what is flux in your context ? Units ?
You are asked to calculate the flux through ##r = 1.5## m as a starter in part (a).

In post #3 the volume integral you wrote in post #1 is replaced by a surface integral. Good ! And you write $$\phi = \oint \overline D\, \overline{dS} = Q_{enc} =\int \rho_s ds$$ where I must suppose ##D = \varepsilon_0 E## ?

In my book the electric flux in such a nice spherically symmetric case is ##\Phi = EA## with E the electric field strength in Newton/Coulomb and A the area in m2 . In other words, I get $$\Phi = \oint {\overline {D}\over \varepsilon_0}\; \overline{dS} = {Q_{enc}\over \varepsilon_0}$$ and the units are Nm2/C.

We are still in part (a) first question. I agree that ##Q_{enc} = \rho_s \, 4\pi \,r^2## with ##r = 1 m##.
second and third (a) questions remain unanswered ?
---

Moving on to part (b) first question:

Your exercise composer makes life difficult by re-using symbol ##r## in r = 1.5 m where ##D## is asked for. We no longer need the ##\varepsilon_0##.
You are smart enough to replace ##r## by ##R## (without explaining:mad:) but then you take ##R= 1 ## m (given) ?

##\ ##
I was so confused in using many r's, so I use different symbols, and tried to solve it again. Here's my attempt with my explanation:
Handwritten-style derivation of electric flux through a spherical surface: flux equals the integral of rho_s ds, Qenc = 2.5133 * 10^-5 C at r = 1.5 m, D = 8.89 * 10^-8 C/m^2.
And regarding the following formula:
Handwritten-style typeset equation under the heading Gauss Law: psi exiting equals the closed surface integral over S of D-bar dot dS-bar, equal to Q enc.

This is given in the textbook.
 
If the flux it is the total inside charge you have to calculate D at r=2.5 [or r=0.5] and not at r=1.5