Calculus II - Trigonometric Substitutions

  • Thread starter GreenPrint
  • Start date
  • #1
1,196
0

Homework Statement



Evaluate

integral dx/sqrt(x^2-49)

Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



SEE POST #4 BELOW WITH ATTACHMENT TO VIEW MY SOLUTION EASIER TO READ

i was trying to use a csc(theta) substitution and I don't see how my logic and math below is flawed but apparently I'm getting a different answer, note that I wanted to try and evaluate this integral this way and not other ways and don't see how evaluating it this way is wrong as long as my intermediate steps are mathematically correct

integral dx/sqrt(x^2-49)
sense csc(theta)= hypotenuse/adjacent
let hypotenuse = x
and adjacent = 7
use the fact that hypotenuse= adjacent^2 + opposite^2
then opposite = sqrt(x^2-49)
then csc(theta)=x/7
then x = 7csc(theta)
use the fact that d/dx csc(theta) = -cot(theta)csc(theta)
dx/dtheta = -7cot(theta)csc(theta)
dx=-7cot(theta)csc(theta)dtheta
substitute dx and x back into the integral
integral[ (-7cot(theta)csc(theta)dtheta)/sqrt((7csc(theta))^2-49) ]
took out the constants and squared the term
-7*integral[ (cot(theta)csc(theta)dtheta)/sqrt(49csc(theta)^2-49) ]
factored out 49
-7*integral[ (cot(theta)csc(theta)dtheta)/sqrt(49(csc(theta)^2-1)) ]
use fact that cot(theta)^2=csc(theta)^2-1
-7*integral[ (cot(theta)csc(theta)dtheta)/sqrt(49cot(theta)^2) ]
evaluated the square root
-7*integral[ (cot(theta)csc(theta)dtheta)/(7cot(theta)) ]
"canceled" cot(theta)/cot(theta)=1 and took out constant and got 7/7=1
- integral csc(theta)dtheta
used the fact that integral csc(theta)dtheta = -ln(cot(theta)+csc(theta))
-*-ln(cot(theta)+csc(theta)) + c
it became positive
ln(cot(theta)+csc(theta)) + c
already established that csc(theta)= x/7
ln(cot(theta)+x/7) + c
use fact that cot(theta)=adjacent/opposite = 7/sqrt(x^2-49)
ln( 7/sqrt(x^2-49) + x/7 ) + c

so this gives me the wrong answer the correct one is
ln(sqrt(x^2-49)/7 + x/7 ) + c
but i really don't see how what i did is wrong...

SEE POST #4 BELOW WITH ATTACHMENT TO VIEW MY SOLUTION EASIER TO READ
 

Attachments

Last edited:

Answers and Replies

  • #2
768
4
Okay, this may not be it, but it's hard enough to follow trig substitutions, let alone follow it typed out instead of natural images, but....
Why are you making a CDC substation?
Thank you iPad..... I had to leave that autocorrect.
Why are you using a csc substitution? Shouldn't it be a sec sub? X should equal 7sec(@).
Hey, maybe using @ for theta will catch on.
 
  • #3
1,196
0
i don't know i wanted to try using a csc subsitution
i'll make a good image
 
  • #4
1,196
0
here
i guess just see my reasoning above if you don't understand what i did
SEE ATTACHMENT IN THIS POST TO SEE A EASIER TO READ SOLUTION
note that in the last expression i switched around co secant and cotangent as far as there order in there previous expression but everything is correct with the last expression I believe
 

Attachments

Last edited:
  • #5
768
4
Gotta be a rebel, huh? Alright I'll look at it again. Let me get out an actual piece of paper here...

That was so much easier to follow! *still looking
 
  • #6
1,196
0
Alright thank you ^_^ I hope you can read my chicken scratch in attachment #4 lolz, let me know if you can't
 
  • #7
768
4
X=7csc@
X/7=csc@
Csc@=1/sin@ so
Sin@=7/x
Sin@=opp/hyp
So 7 is the opposite , your triangle pic is backwards.
 
  • #8
768
4
Kinda had to figure it was something like that, since your answer was just kinda upside down.

I hate trig subs. Avoid 'em like the plague.
 
  • #9
1,196
0
*smashes head into desk*
lol thanks

it's been to long sense i have done basic trig stuff
and ya like i guess it's custom to use secant substitution in this case but i wanted to see if it really matter if i used co secant and I'm glad to see that it doesn't
 
  • #10
768
4
Hey, I learned you can use the *off brand* too. So it was worth my time. Thank you.
 

Related Threads on Calculus II - Trigonometric Substitutions

Replies
1
Views
952
Replies
2
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
15
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
776
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
942
Top