Integrals that keep me up at night!

[Physics Slayer]

Homework Statement:

Need help finding the following indefinite integrals

Relevant Equations:

-

Been struggling with a few integrals, I might post a few more once I progress further in my assignment.

$$1. \int \sqrt{tanx} + \sqrt{cotx} (dx)$$

Attempt1:
for integral 1, I try to apply integration by parts on both $\sqrt{tanx}$ and $\sqrt{cotx}$ separately, I then get
$$\int \underbrace{\sqrt{tanx}}_{\textrm{u}}\underbrace{(dx)}_{\textrm{dv}} + \int \underbrace{\sqrt{cotx}}_{\textrm{u}}\underbrace{(dx)}_{\textrm{dv}}$$

this gives,
$$=\left( x\sqrt{tanx}-\int \underbrace{x}_{\textrm{u}}.\underbrace{\frac{sec^2x}{2\sqrt{tanx}}}_{\textrm{dv}}(dx)\right) + \left(x\sqrt{cotx}-\int \underbrace{x}_{\textrm{u}}.\underbrace{\frac{(-coesc^2x)}{2\sqrt{cotx}}}_{\textrm{dv}}(dx)\right)$$

after applying integration by parts again I sadly get, RHS = LHS

$$=\left(xtanx - \left(x\sqrt{tanx}-\int \sqrt{tanx}(dx)\right)\right) + \left(x\sqrt{cotx}-\left(x\sqrt{cotx}-\int\sqrt{cotx}(dx)\right)\right)$$
$$=\int\sqrt{tanx}(dx)+\int\sqrt{cotx}(dx)$$
this basically lead me back to the beginning:(

Attempt2:
I also tried using a the substitution, $t^2 = tan(x)$ but even this brought me back to where I started,
$$\int \sqrt{tanx}+\frac{1}{\sqrt{tanx}} (dx) = \int\frac{tanx+1}{\sqrt{tanx}}(dx)$$
using the above sub,
$$\int\frac{t^2+1}{t}\frac{2t}{1+t^4}(dt) = 2\int\frac{t^2+1}{t^4+1}dt$$
now $u=t^2$
$$=\int\frac{u+1}{u^2+1}\frac{du}{\sqrt{u}}=\int\frac{\sqrt{u}}{u^2+1}+\frac{1}{\sqrt{u}(u^2+1)}(du)$$
and finally if you use the trig sub, $u = tan\theta$ you end up with,
$$=\int \sqrt{tan\theta}+\sqrt{cot\theta}(d\theta)$$
I usually don't like asking for help while solving integrals, there is a different satisfaction one gets when they finally get the "aha" moment and then solve the problem, but these are literally getting in the way of my life, I don't want entire solutions, a hint or a reassurance that I am thinking in the right direction will do :)

I need help in these two as well, but I'll show my working for them once I get this pesky one out of the way.

$$2. \int \frac{1}{x^{1/2} + x^{1/3}} (dx)$$
$$3. \int \frac{cos(2x) - sin(2\phi)}{cos(x) - sin(\phi)} (dx)$$

 

[PeroK]

Attempt2:
I also tried using a the substitution, $t^2 = tan(x)$ but even this brought me back to where I started,
$$\int\frac{t^2+1}{t}\frac{2t}{1+t^4}(dt) = 2\int\frac{t^2+1}{t^4+1}dt$$

This looks like progress.

and finally if you use the trig sub, $u = tan\theta$

That takes you back to square one - you've undone your first substitution.

 

[PeroK]

Instead:$$\int\frac{t^2+1}{t^4+1}dt = \int\frac{t^2}{t^4+1}dt + \int\frac{1}{t^4+1}dt $$

 

[PeroK]

Instead:$$\int\frac{t^2+1}{t^4+1}dt = \int\frac{t^2}{t^4+1}dt + \int\frac{1}{t^4+1}dt $$

On second thoughts, perhaps that's not such a good idea.

 

[Physics Slayer]

On second thoughts, perhaps that's not such a good idea.

I thought about this, but the only think I could think of was the substitution $u=t^2$ so I could get rid of $t^4$ in the denominators, but the integral was still challenging to solve.

 

[PeroK]

I thought about this, but the only think I could think of was the substitution $u=t^2$ so I could get rid of $t^4$ in the denominators, but the integral was still challenging to solve.

$$t^4 +1 = (t^2 + \sqrt 2 t +1)(t^2 - \sqrt 2 t +1)$$

 

[Physics Slayer]

$$t^4 +1 = (t^2 + \sqrt 2 t +1)(t^2 - \sqrt 2 t +1)$$

$$2\int\frac{t^2+1}{t^4+1}(dt) = \int\frac{2t^2+2}{(t^2+\sqrt{2}t+1)(t^2-\sqrt{2}t+1)}(dt)$$
$$\int\frac{(t^2+\sqrt{t}+1)+(t^2-\sqrt{2}t+1)}{(t^2+\sqrt{2}t+1)(t^2-\sqrt{2}t+1)}(dt)=\int\frac{1}{t^2+\sqrt{2}t+1}+\frac{1}{t^2-2\sqrt{t}+1}(dt)$$
$$\int \frac{1}{(t + \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}})^2 + (\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}})^2} + \frac{1}{(t - \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}})^2 + (\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}})^2} (dt)$$
we can use,
$$\int\frac{1}{x^2+a^2}dx = \frac{1}{a}tan^{-1}\left(\frac{x}{a}\right)$$
finally my ans is,
$$\sqrt{2}\left[tan^{-1}(\sqrt{2tanx}+1) + tan^{-1}(\sqrt{2tanx}-1)\right] +C$$

how were you able to factor $(t^4+1)$ into $(t^2 -\sqrt{2}t + 1)(t^2 + \sqrt{2}t + 1)$ ?
It's obviously correct(I only know because I multiplied the two and verified) but what method did you use?

 

[PeroK]

how were you able to factor $(t^4+1)$ into $(t^2 -\sqrt{2}t + 1)(t^2 + \sqrt{2}t + 1)$ ?
It's obviously correct(I only know because I multiplied the two and verified) but what method did you use?

I've seen that sort of thing before. I was actually looking at complex numbers first:
$$t^4 + 1 = (t^2 + i)(t^2 - i)$$but then I remembered that you can factorise a quartic into two quadratics.

 

[PeroK]

I've seen that sort of thing before. I was actually looking at complex numbers first:
$$t^4 + 1 = (t^2 + i)(t^2 - i)$$but then I remembered that you can factorise a quartic into two quadratics.

You can keep going with the complex numbers:
$$t^4 + 1 = (t + \frac{1}{\sqrt 2} +\frac{i}{\sqrt 2})(t + \frac{1}{\sqrt 2} - \frac{i}{\sqrt 2})(t - \frac{1}{\sqrt 2} +\frac{i}{\sqrt 2})(t - \frac{1}{\sqrt 2} - \frac{i}{\sqrt 2})$$$$ = (t^2 +\sqrt 2 t +1)(t^2 - \sqrt 2 t +1)$$Or, simply look for$$t^4 +1 = (t^2 + at +1)(t^2 + bt + 1)$$

 

[Physics Slayer]

I've seen that sort of thing before. I was actually looking at complex numbers first:
$$t^4 + 1 = (t^2 + i)(t^2 - i)$$but then I remembered that you can factorise a quartic into two quadratics.

we haven't yet studied complex numbers, so I doubt this was the method they expected us to use. Either way, thanks for your help Perok.

If anybody is able to find a soln. without factorising a quartic, do let me know

 

[PeroK]

If anybody is able to find a soln. without factorising a quartic, do let me know

It's definitely the way to go. Factorise then partial fractions.

 

[Steve4Physics]

If anybody is able to find a soln. without factorising a quartic, do let me know

If you can cope with the language, see:

 

[Physics Slayer]

If you can cope with the language, see:

I'm Indian so I don't mind the heavy accent,
I usually don't search up integrals because they directly slap you with the answer, and I don't like that.
thanks for the video tho :)

 

[Steve4Physics]

I'm Indian so I don't mind the heavy accent,
I usually don't search up integrals because they directly slap you with the answer, and I don't like that.
thanks for the video tho :)

Being a bit pedantic, can I add that both the integral in Post #1 and the integral at the start of the video are incorrect (brackets)!

The integral should, of course, be:$$\int (\sqrt{tanx} + \sqrt{cotx} )dx$$

 

[Physics Slayer]

Being a bit pedantic, can I add that both the integral in Post #1 and the integral at the start of the video are incorrect (brackets)!

The integral should, of course, be:$$\int (\sqrt{tanx} + \sqrt{cotx} )dx$$

As far as I am aware, the notation for a indefinite integral is,
$$\int f(x)dx$$
In #1, $f(x) = \sqrt{tanx}+\sqrt{cotx}$ so I don't really see what's wrong

 

[Steve4Physics]

As far as I am aware, the notation for a indefinite integral is,
$$\int f(x)dx$$

Agreed.

In #1, $f(x) = \sqrt{tanx}+\sqrt{cotx}$ so I don't really see what's wrong

Maybe it's just the convention I was taught. But I would argue that if
$f(x) = \sqrt{tanx}+\sqrt{cotx}$
then in general
$f(x). a$ should be be written as
$(\sqrt{tanx}+\sqrt{cotx}).a$ and not as
$\sqrt{tanx}+\sqrt{cotx}.a$
because $\sqrt{tanx}$ would not get be multiplied by $a$. (For example 1+2*3 = 7, not 9.)

This should apply whatever'$a$' is, even if it is the infinitessimal quantity $dx$.

 

[Physics Slayer]

$$2. \int\frac{1}{x^{1/2}+x^{1/3}} dx $$
I tried both the substitutions, $u^2=x$ and $u^3=x$ and both lead to integrals I am unable to solve,

$u^2=x$
$$\int\frac{2u}{u+u^{2/3}}(du) = 2\int\frac{1}{1+u^{-1/3}}(du)=2\int\frac{u^{1/3}}{u^{1/3}+1}(du)$$
now I use the substitution $u=t^3$
$$2\int\frac{t}{t+1}(3t^2)(dt) = 6\int\frac{t^3}{t+1}(dt) $$
I am unable to solve this final integral. I tried applying Integration by parts consecutively 3 times to get rid of the $t^3$, but that didn't work either.

using the other substitution($u^3=x$) I end up with,
$$3\int\frac{u^2}{u^{3/2}+u} (du) = 3\int\frac{u}{\sqrt{u}+1}(du)$$
which is again a integral I can't solve.

 

[SammyS]

I need help in these two as well, but I'll show my working for them once I get this pesky one out of the way.

$$2. \int \frac{1}{x^{1/2} + x^{1/3}} (dx)$$
$$3. \int \frac{cos(2x) - sin(2\phi)}{cos(x) - sin(\phi)} (dx)$$

Please post these each in an individual thread when you are ready to tackle either one.

 

[PeroK]

Why not $x = u^6$?

 

[Physics Slayer]

Why not $x = u^6$?

actually in my attempt, I first use the substitution $x=u^2$ and then the substitution $u=t^3$ which is equivalent to a single substitution $x=t^3$

But I was since then able to solve the integral, I just had to reduce the final improper fraction into a proper fraction, it was smooth sailing from there, again thanks for you help.

$$6\int\frac{t^3}{t+1}(dt) = 6\int\frac{(t+1)(t^2-t+1)-1}{t+1}(dt)=6\int\left((t^2-t+1)-\frac{1}{t+1}\right)(dt)$$
$$=6\left(\frac{t^3}{3}-\frac{t^2}{2}+t-ln|t+1|\right)=2x^{1/2}-3x^{1/3}+6x^{1/6}-6ln|x^{1/6}+1|+C$$

Please post these each in an individual thread when you are ready to tackle either one.

I thought multiple posts each with a single integral problem, would appear kind of spammy, I will most definitely encounter much harder integrals as I go ahead, I don't want to flood the forum with threads on integrals, but if that's what's supposed to be done, then I shall.

 

[SammyS]

actually in my attempt, I first use the substitution $x=u^2$ and then the substitution $u=t^3$ which is equivalent to a single substitution $x=t^3$

But I was since then able to solve the integral, I just had to reduce the final improper fraction into a proper fraction, it was smooth sailing from there, again thanks for you help.

$$6\int\frac{t^3}{t+1}(dt) = 6\int\frac{(t+1)(t^2-t+1)-1}{t+1}(dt)=6\int\left((t^2-t+1)-\frac{1}{t+1}\right)(dt)$$
$$=6\left(\frac{t^3}{3}-\frac{t^2}{2}+t-ln|t+1|\right)=2x^{1/2}-3x^{1/3}+6x^{1/6}-6ln|x^{1/6}+1|+C$$


I thought multiple posts on just one integral would appear kind of spammy, I will most definitely encounter much harder integrals as I go ahead, I don't want to flood the forum with threads on integrals, but if that's what's supposed to be done, then I shall.

It looks to me that those two integrals I referred to are entirely different from the first one.

 

[Physics Slayer]

It looks to me that those two integrals I referred to are entirely different from the first one.

yes they are indeed entirely different, they are three different problems(integrals), what I was trying to say was Three threads(+) each discussing only one integral might be a little spammy, hence I thought it would be better to discuss most of them here, but if that's not allowed then I shall start a new thread.

 

[SammyS]

Or, simply look for$$t^4 +1 = (t^2 + at +1)(t^2 +bt + 1)$$

@Physics Slayer :
Back to problem #1.

The above quote is from Post #9 by PeroK (with a minor but important Typo fixed).

Expand the right hand side and equate corresponding coefficients.

$t^4+1 = (t^2 + at +1)(t^2 +bt + 1)$

$t^4+1=t^4+(a+b)t^3+(2+ab)t^2+(a+b)t+1$

The cubic terms (also the linear terms) give you that $\ 0 = a+b\ .\$ Thus $b=-a$ .

The quadratic terms give you that $0=2+ab\ .\$ Together with the previous you get $a^2=2.$

Thus $a=\pm\sqrt{2 \,}$ .