Can Aliens Perceive Time as a Dimension?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the perception of time as a dimension, contrasting human experience with hypothetical alien perspectives. It highlights that while humans can perceive space and the present moment, our understanding of time is limited to memory and imagination. The conversation references literary inspirations, such as Kurt Vonnegut's depiction of aliens perceiving time as a physical dimension, visualizing humans as a continuous entity. The analogy of "Flatland" illustrates how beings in lower dimensions cannot conceive of higher dimensions, suggesting that if we could perceive time differently, it might appear as a series of overlapping moments. The discussion also touches on the implications of existing without a time dimension, allowing for communication across different temporal states, which is described as a primitive or altered state of consciousness.
hatfair
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Uneducated writer here looking for a discussion on the perception of other dimensions, including time:

If the fabric of our universe is space/time, I understand that as humans, we can only really perceive space, that is I can see space all around me. However, I can only perceive this actual moment (the now) in time. I can remember the past, or imagine the future, but now is the only time I can perceive.

If time is a dimension, and I was an alien able to perceive that dimension, what kind of perception would it be, do you think?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
It will be whatever you want it to be in your story. As they say, paper is patient.

There are no reliable answers to questions about "what is the scientific answer to non-scientific questions" or "what does science tell us about things outside of its realm".
 
I believe Kurt Vonnegut might provide some inspiration. Aliens who could see time as a physical dimension saw humans as long caterpillars, with a baby at the tail end and an old man at the head.

Alternately, look to degenerate dimensions for analogies. Are you familiar with Flatland? 2 dimensional creatures who live on a plane. They cannot perceive - or even conceive of - a 3rd dimension. A cube to them is an infinitely thin slice in the shape of a square (or hexagon, depending on how the square is sliced).

Imagine what would happen if they saw a cube's infinite number of slices all flattened into their plane? They'd see multiple polygons all overlapping.
 
Last edited:
I remember a book from my youth, William Sleator's The Boy Who Reversed Himself, which got into some higher spatial dimensions.
 
Your question reminds me of Einsteins thought process where he imagines traveling with a light beam.
Did him a lot of good.
Imagine living without a time dimension, able to communicate with your ancestors and decendants.
Sounds "primative" tribe under the influence of mind altering drugs.
 
A map of a four-dimensional planet is three dimensional, so such can exist in our Universe. I made one and posted a video to the Internet. This is all based on William Kingdon Clifford's math from the 19th century. It works like this. A 4D planet has two perpendicular planes of rotation. The intersection of such a plane with the surface of the planet is a great circle. We can define latitude as the arctan( distance from one plane/distance from the other plane). The set of all points...

Similar threads

Replies
7
Views
3K
Replies
48
Views
3K
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
1K
Replies
20
Views
978
Back
Top