Homework Help: Can anyone confirm this possible error in 'Vector Calculus' by Matthews?

1. Aug 14, 2012

Syrus

1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data

Find the surface integral of u dot n over S where S is the part of the surface z = x + y2 with z<0 and x>-1, u is the vector field u = (2y+x,-1,0) and n has a negative z component.

2. Relevant equations

In the text leading up to the end-of-chapter exercises (where this question arises), n is specified as a unit normal vector.

3. The attempt at a solution

The solution claims that ndS = (1,2y,-1)dxdy. But isn't this ignoring the fact that n should be a unit vector? Obviously, the position vector for the surface in parameter form is r = (x,y,x+y2), and n is obtained by taking the partial derivative of r with respect to y, the partial derivative of r with respect to x, and forming the cross product of the two (in that order). But then, shouldn't this resulting vector be divided by the magnitude of the cross product- which, by my calculations happens to be √(2 + 4y2), which is never 1?

Last edited: Aug 14, 2012
2. Aug 14, 2012

LCKurtz

Your surface is parameterized as $\vec R(x,y) = \langle x, y, x+y^2\rangle$. Read my post #13 in this thread: