B Can EM Radiations Exist without a Source?

AI Thread Summary
Electromagnetic radiation, including light, is generally understood to require a source, such as charges or energy changes, to exist. While theoretical concepts like vacuum solutions suggest that electromagnetic fields can exist without sources, these have not been observed in practice. The Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation and phenomena like Hawking radiation are often cited, but they still trace back to initial sources, such as the Big Bang. Discussions also highlight that while vacuum fluctuations might imply the creation of particles, these are not considered "real" in the traditional sense. Ultimately, all known electromagnetic activities are linked to sources, though some theoretical scenarios allow for the possibility of sourceless existence.
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #52
Bob is a good man. Bon Homme Jaffe.
 
  • Haha
Likes phinds
  • #53
sophiecentaur said:
I have to question the reasoning behind many of these sorts of threads. They seem to be chasing something 'extra' before getting familiar with what's already been established. Sherlock Holmes got it right about first examining and rejecting all possibilities before considering something apparently impossible.
I think the process of examining and rejecting all possibilities is just a bit messier for some than others especially if one comes with a mind entangled in some mental wool that needs untangling first.
 
  • #54
bob012345 said:
I think the process of examining and rejecting all possibilities is just a bit messier for some than others especially if one comes with a mind entangled in some mental wool that needs untangling first.
I have just made a comment elsewhere about the Q and A approach to self teaching. It's very easy to waste a lot of effort up blind alleys with Q and A. I very much doubt that you can untangle that mental wool on your own and put appropriate weighting to the hundreds of facts that are available.
You need to get used to taking stuff on board in the order that it's usually presented on formal courses - that method has been tried and tested.
 
Back
Top