Can I change topology of the physical system smoothly?

Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers on the smooth change of a physical system represented by a potential field ##A## associated with a ##U(1)## bundle on a space ##M##, typically a torus. The Chern number ##c##, defined as ##c = \frac{i}{{2\pi }}\int_T F## where ##F = dA##, is an invariant of the bundle and remains unchanged under smooth transformations of the connection. Participants assert that while the gauge field can change smoothly, the Chern number itself cannot change, as it is an intrinsic property of the bundle, not the connection.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of gauge theory, specifically ##U(1)## bundles.
  • Familiarity with Chern numbers and their significance in topology.
  • Knowledge of differential forms and their applications in physics.
  • Basic concepts of Hamiltonian mechanics and eigenstates in quantum mechanics.
NEXT STEPS
  • Study the properties of Chern numbers in topology and their implications in physics.
  • Explore gauge transformations and their effects on physical systems.
  • Learn about Berry's connection and its role in quantum mechanics.
  • Investigate the relationship between smooth changes in Hamiltonians and their eigenstates.
USEFUL FOR

Physicists, mathematicians, and students interested in gauge theory, topology, and quantum mechanics, particularly those exploring the implications of Chern numbers in physical systems.

lichen1983312
Messages
85
Reaction score
2
I am encountering this kind of problem in physics. The problem is like this:
Some quantity ##A## is identified as a potential field of a ##U(1)## bundle on a space ##M## (usually a torus), because it transforms like this ##{A_j}(p) = {A_i}(p) + id\Lambda (p)## in the intersection between patches ##{U_i} \cap {U_j}##. So there should be a ##U(1)## bundle corresponding to this potential field and a Chern number is defined to characterize this bundle (or the physical system)
##c = \frac{i}{{2\pi }}\int_T F ##
Where ##F## is the field strength ##F = dA##.

One may change the physical system smoothly so that the potential field also changes smoothly. Let's say the system is changing with ##t##, and the potential field becomes a smooth function ##A(t)##, while the transform rule ##{A_j}(p) = {A_i}(p) + id\Lambda (p)## is still valid.

So the question is, is this smooth change of system possible to change the Chern number ##c## ?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
lichen1983312 said:
I am encountering this kind of problem in physics. The problem is like this:
Some quantity ##A## is identified as a potential field of a ##U(1)## bundle on a space ##M## (usually a torus), because it transforms like this ##{A_j}(p) = {A_i}(p) + id\Lambda (p)## in the intersection between patches ##{U_i} \cap {U_j}##. So there should be a ##U(1)## bundle corresponding to this potential field and a Chern number is defined to characterize this bundle (or the physical system)
##c = \frac{i}{{2\pi }}\int_T F ##
Where ##F## is the field strength ##F = dA##.

One may change the physical system smoothly so that the potential field also changes smoothly. Let's say the system is changing with ##t##, and the potential field becomes a smooth function ##A(t)##, while the transform rule ##{A_j}(p) = {A_i}(p) + id\Lambda (p)## is still valid.

So the question is, is this smooth change of system possible to change the Chern number ##c## ?

I think you are changing the connection (gauge field) not the bundle. The Chern number is an invariant of the bundle. It is the same for any connection. Although the Chern form will be different its integral over the surface will be the same.
 
lavinia said:
I think you are changing the connection (gauge field) not the bundle. The Chern number is an invariant of the bundle. It is the same for any connection. Although the Chern form will be different its integral over the surface will be the same.
Is this possible? let's say there are two principal bundles ##{P_1}## and ##{P_2}## over ##M##, and ##{A_1}## and ##{A_2}## are corresponding gauge fields. Is it possible to smoothly change ##{A_1}## into ##{A_2}##?
 
Maybe the question is not so clear, I will use an example.
BZ.jpg

A physical system is represented by k-dependent Hamiltonian operators ##\hat H(k)##, where ##k## is a point in the torus. Each linear operator ##\hat H(k)## has a set of discrete eigen-functions such that ##\hat H(k)\left| {{u_n}(k,r)} \right\rangle = {E_n}(k)\left| {{u_n}(k,r)} \right\rangle ##, where ##{E_n}(k)## are energy eigen-values and are real. ##\left| {{u_n}(k,r)} \right\rangle ## is a smooth function over ##k## and the Cartesian coordinates ##r##. ##\left| {{u_n}(k,r)} \right\rangle ## is required to be normalized such that ##\left\langle {{u_m}(k,r)} \right.\left| {{u_n}(k,r)} \right\rangle = {\delta _{m,n}}## where ##\left\langle {{u_m}(k,r)} \right.\left| {{u_n}(k,r)} \right\rangle ## are defined as ##\left\langle {{u_m}(k,r)} \right.\left| {{u_n}(k,r)} \right\rangle = \int {dr} \,u_m^ * (k,r){u_n}(k,r)##.

However there is a phase ambiguity of ##\left| {{u_n}(k,r)} \right\rangle ##, since
##\hat H(k){e^{i\Lambda (k)}}\left| {{u_n}(k,r)} \right\rangle = {e^{i\Lambda (k)}}\hat H(k)\left| {{u_n}(k,r)} \right\rangle = {E_n}(k){e^{i\Lambda (k)}}\left| {{u_n}(k,r)} \right\rangle ##
So ##\left| {u{'_n}(k,r)} \right\rangle = {e^{i\Lambda (k)}}\left| {{u_n}(k,r)} \right\rangle ## is also smooth over ##k## and ##r##, if ##{\Lambda (k)}## is smooth.
For simplicity, assume there is only one energy eigen state. Now define a special connection, called the Berry's connection as
##A = \left\langle {u(k,r)} \right|{d_p}\left| {u(k,r)} \right\rangle = \left\langle {u(k,r)} \right|\frac{\partial }{{\partial {k^\mu }}}\left| {u(k,r)} \right\rangle d{k^\mu }##
(##\left\langle {u(k,r)} \right|\frac{\partial }{{\partial {k^\mu }}}\left| {u(k,r)} \right\rangle ## is pure imaginary)
so if let ##\left| {u(k,r)} \right\rangle \to \left| {u'(k,r)} \right\rangle ##
##A \to A' = A + id\Lambda ##

In the case of the graph used here, we may define smooth potential fields ##{A^A}## and ##{A^B}## on patches A and B. on the boundary set the transition function as ##{t^{AB}} = {e^{i\Lambda (k)}}## , using ##F = dA##, the Chern number is
##c = \frac{i}{{2\pi }}\int_T F ##

Now if I let the Hamiltonian ##\hat H(k)## depend on a parameter ##t## in a smooth way, the energy eigen-state ##\left| {{u_n}(k,r,t)} \right\rangle ##as well as the Berry's connection ##A(t)## change with ##t## smoothly.

is it possible at certain ##t##, the Chern number change its value ?
 

Attachments

  • BZ.jpg
    BZ.jpg
    43.6 KB · Views: 656

Similar threads

  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 28 ·
Replies
28
Views
7K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
5K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
7K
Replies
5
Views
619
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 0 ·
Replies
0
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K