The discussion explores the effects of intense gravity, particularly in black holes, on atomic motion and kinetic energy. Participants consider whether gravity can halt atomic jiggling and what happens to the kinetic energy in such extreme conditions.
Participants generally agree that there is significant uncertainty regarding the effects of intense gravity on atomic motion and the behavior of energy, with multiple competing views presented without a consensus.
The discussion highlights limitations in current understanding of atomic behavior in extreme gravitational fields and the lack of empirical evidence from black holes, which complicates definitive claims.
makes a lot of sense, but arent there any theories about it ?Crazymechanic said:The thing is we don't know.Surely the atomic structure if there even is one anymore is way way different than in ordinary conditions.
Actually I could say pretty much anything , like that Julius Caesar lives in one of them because you cannot prove me wrong as you cannot look into one , nor is anyone of those ever achieved here on Earth and studied up close.
The thing is we have theories , and good guesses nothing more on this one.
If you ask me personally , I think there has to be motion , energy cannot just disappear in thin air it has to go somewhere and do something , anything beyond that is poetry.
P.S. Surely the stuff before the event horizon and the radiation that the BH spills as it evaporates is in motion , what is in between I don't know.