Can someone tell me how many forces of friction are in here?

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving two blocks (2kg and 7kg) connected by a pulley, with a force F applied to move them at a constant velocity. Participants explore the forces of friction acting between the blocks and the normal forces involved, as well as the implications of Newton's laws in this context.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the number of frictional forces present between the blocks and question the calculations of normal forces and frictional forces. There is exploration of the implications of Newton's third law regarding action and reaction forces. Some participants express uncertainty about the correct application of gravitational force in their calculations.

Discussion Status

The discussion is active, with participants providing insights and questioning each other's reasoning. Some have offered guidance on the relationships between forces, while others are still clarifying their understanding of the problem setup and the forces involved.

Contextual Notes

There are indications of confusion regarding the application of gravitational force and the treatment of tension in the system. Participants are also navigating the constraints of the problem as a homework assignment, which may limit the information they can use or assumptions they can make.

Blockade
Messages
68
Reaction score
0
Ch085.gif


Let's assume that the force of friction is only present between the two blocks and that the pulley is massless. On top of that, force F pulling the two blocks at a constant velocity; as a result, the acceleration = 0m/s2.
May someone tell me how many forces of friction are going on between the "2kg" and "7kg" blocks? I guessed two since the top block is moving left and the bottom box is moving right. Am I right?

And is it true that the force of gravity that applies on the "7kg" block is actually (2kg+7kg)*g = 9kg*g?

Also may you please check if my sum of all forces are corrrect?:
ΣFtop blockx: -T1 + μ*2kg*g = [2kg*0] -> T1 = μ*2kg*g
ΣFtop blocky: Ntop = 2kg*g

ΣFbottom blockx: T2 - μ*9kg*g - T1 + F = [9kg*0] -> T2 = μ*9kg*g + 1 - F
ΣFbottom blocky: Ntop = 9kg*g

note: sorry but I don't know if I should still multiply kg * gravity or just leave it as kg.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Action and reaction are equal and opposite. If the normal force experienced by the 2kg block from the 7kg block is 2kg * g then what is the normal force the 7kg block experiences from the 2kg block?
 
haruspex said:
Action and reaction are equal and opposite. If the normal force experienced by the 2kg block from the 7kg block is 2kg * g then what is the normal force the 7kg block experiences from the 2kg block?

Hello again :). The normal force the 7kg block experiences from the 2kg block is 2kg * g because of Newton's 3rd law as you mentioned above.
 
Blockade said:
Hello again :). The normal force the 7kg block experiences from the 2kg block is 2kg * g because of Newton's 3rd law as you mentioned above.
Right, so what is the frictional force on the 7kg block?
 
So... therefore, "ΣFbottom block y" Nbot should be subtracted to Ntop as it is below where Nbot = 2kg*g ?
ΣFtop blockx: -T1 + μ*2kg*g = [2kg*0] -> T1 = μ*2kg*g
ΣFtop blocky: Ntop = 2kg*g

ΣFbottom blockx: T2 - μ*9kg*g - T1 + F = [9kg*0] -> T2 = μ*9kg*g + 1 - F
ΣFbottom blocky: Ntop - Nbot = 9kg*g
 
Blockade said:
ΣFbottom blockx: T2 - μ*9kg*g ...
Where does that μ*9kg*g term come from?
 
haruspex said:
Right, so what is the frictional force on the 7kg block?

The force of friction on the 7kg block should feel μ*2kg*g.
 
haruspex said:
Where does that μ*9kg*g term come from?

Well I thought that since the 2kg block is on top of the 7kg block, then the force of gravity for the 7kg block would be (2kg+7kg)*g "the sum of both masses times gravity".
 
Blockade said:
Well I thought that since the 2kg block is on top of the 7kg block, then the force of gravity for the 7kg block would be (2kg+7kg)*g "the sum of both masses times gravity".
Sure, but where will that total weight be felt? You already accepted in post #3 that the normal force at the boundary between the blocks is only 2kg * g.
 
  • #10
haruspex said:
Sure, but where will that total weight be felt? You already accepted in post #3 that the normal force at the boundary between the blocks is only 2kg * g.

I figured the "9kg * g" force would be felt from block 7kg to the ground and back to up at it again through the Nbot force.
 
  • #11
Blockade said:
I figured the "9kg * g" force would be felt from block 7kg to the ground and back to up at it again through the Nbot force.
Sure, but there's no friction there.
 
  • #12
haruspex said:
Sure, but there's no friction there.

Hang on let me double check.
 
  • #13
ΣFbottom blockx: T2 - μ*2kg*g - T1 + F = [2kg*0] -> T2 = μ*2kg*g + 1 - F
ΣFbottom blocky: Ntop - Nbot = 7kg*g

I think I've fixed it.
 
  • #14
Blockade said:
ΣFbottom blockx: T2 - μ*2kg*g - T1 + F = [2kg*0] -> T2 = μ*2kg*g + 1 - F
ΣFbottom blocky: Ntop - Nbot = 7kg*g

I think I've fixed it.
You have T1 and T2. There's only one tension acting on the bottom block (other than F).
 
  • #15
haruspex said:
You have T1 and T2. There's only one tension acting on the bottom block (other than F).

So I don't need T2 since there's already a force F pulling on it?

since T2 = F it will just cancel out?
 
  • #16
Blockade said:
So I don't need T2 since there's already a force F pulling on it?

since T2 = F it will just cancel out?
It can't cancel. Either take F as acting directly on the block, or take T2 as acting on the block and set T2=F. It comes to the same thing.
 
  • #17
haruspex said:
It can't cancel. Either take F as acting directly on the block, or take T2 as acting on the block and set T2=F. It comes to the same thing.

Alright. I just thought that force F was acting on the rope since it's pulling it but thank you, if the bottom equation looks correct. You've been a great help.ΣFbottom blockx: μ*2kg*g - T1 + F = [2kg*0] -> F = μ*2kg*g + 1 + T1
ΣFbottom blocky: Ntop - Nbot = 7kg*g
 
  • #18
Blockade said:
Alright. I just thought that force F was acting on the rope since it's pulling it but thank you, if the bottom equation looks correct. You've been a great help.ΣFbottom blockx: μ*2kg*g - T1 + F = [2kg*0] -> F = μ*2kg*g + 1 + T1
ΣFbottom blocky: Ntop - Nbot = 7kg*g
Yes, that's right.
If you want to think of F as a force someone is applying to a rope, the tension in the rope is F. The block feels the tension F, but it knows nothing about the person pulling on the other end. When constructing the FBD for a body, it's important to think in terms of the forces that act directly on the body, and not get mixed up with more distant origins of the forces.
 

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
61
Views
4K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
3K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
14K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
4K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
7K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K