Can you help with these sound wave problems?

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around sound wave problems, specifically focusing on the Doppler effect and beat frequencies. Participants are exploring how the frequency of sound changes based on the relative motion of the source and observer, as well as the concept of beat frequencies in tuning forks.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • The original poster attempts to solve problems involving the frequency heard by a bicyclist relative to a moving car and the frequency changes of a train whistle as it approaches and recedes. They express confusion over their calculations and the expected results.
  • Some participants question the assumptions made regarding the signs in the Doppler effect equations and the interpretation of the frequency shifts.
  • There is a mention of beat frequencies and how they relate to the difference in frequencies of two tuning forks, with an example provided to illustrate the concept.

Discussion Status

Participants are actively engaging with the problems, with some providing insights and clarifications on the equations used. There is recognition of the need to adjust the signs in the Doppler effect formula based on the direction of motion, and the discussion is ongoing without a clear resolution yet.

Contextual Notes

Participants are preparing for a test and are working through problems that were not reviewed in class. There is a focus on understanding the underlying principles of sound waves and their behavior in different scenarios.

lavafrog
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Help With Sound Wave Problems!

Hi...I'm studying for a test on soundwaves tomorrow, and I have questions on a few problems my teacher never reviewed. I'd appreciate it if someone could even answer one of them. Thanks!

1) At rest, a car's horn sounds the note A (440Hz). The horn is sounded while the car is moving down the street. A bicyclist moving in the same direction with one third the car's speed hears a frequency of 415. How fast is the car moving? Is the bicyclist ahead of or behind the car? T=20C. (Based on the fact that the biker hears a lower frequency than the actual frequency, I've determined that he's behind the car.)

I've found the velocity of sound in these conditions to be 343m/s. Then I used this equation: (f'=frequency heard, f=actual frequency, v=velocity of sound in air, vo=velocity of observer, vs=velocity of the source, or car, +/- is used because it's - on top and + on bottom when the source is going away from you, and + on top and - on bottom when it's coming towards you.)

f'=f(v+/-vo/v+/-vs)

415Hz=440Hz(343m/s-(1/3)vs/343m/s+vs) (Sorry I can't write it out any neater than that, but I don't know how to use the right symbols.)

When I solve the equation for vs, I get 15.35m/s, but the answer is supposed to be 31m/s! Why am I off by a factor of two?

2) The frequency of a steam train whistle as it approaches you is 522Hz. After it passes you, it's 486Hz. How fast was the train moving? (assume constant velocity.)

522-486=36, 36/2=18.
486+18=504Hz. when right in front of you.

522Hz=504Hz(340m/s+0m/s/340m/s-Xm/s) When I solved for x, I got 13m/s. Is this the right answer?


One more I can't even start working on:

Two tuning forks are held near each other and a beat frequency of 6Hz is percieved. if one fork has a f=512Hz, what frequencies are possible for the other?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
lavafrog said:
Hi...I'm studying for a test on soundwaves tomorrow, and I have questions on a few problems my teacher never reviewed. I'd appreciate it if someone could even answer one of them. Thanks!

1) At rest, a car's horn sounds the note A (440Hz). The horn is sounded while the car is moving down the street. A bicyclist moving in the same direction with one third the car's speed hears a frequency of 415. How fast is the car moving? Is the bicyclist ahead of or behind the car? T=20C. (Based on the fact that the biker hears a lower frequency than the actual frequency, I've determined that he's behind the car.)

I've found the velocity of sound in these conditions to be 343m/s. Then I used this equation: (f'=frequency heard, f=actual frequency, v=velocity of sound in air, vo=velocity of observer, vs=velocity of the source, or car, +/- is used because it's - on top and + on bottom when the source is going away from you, and + on top and - on bottom when it's coming towards you.)

f'=f(v+/-vo/v+/-vs)

415Hz=440Hz(343m/s-(1/3)vs/343m/s+vs) (Sorry I can't write it out any neater than that, but I don't know how to use the right symbols.)

When I solve the equation for vs, I get 15.35m/s, but the answer is supposed to be 31m/s! Why am I off by a factor of two?

2) The frequency of a steam train whistle as it approaches you is 522Hz. After it passes you, it's 486Hz. How fast was the train moving? (assume constant velocity.)

522-486=36, 36/2=18.
486+18=504Hz. when right in front of you.

522Hz=504Hz(340m/s+0m/s/340m/s-Xm/s) When I solved for x, I got 13m/s. Is this the right answer?


One more I can't even start working on:

Two tuning forks are held near each other and a beat frequency of 6Hz is percieved. if one fork has a f=512Hz, what frequencies are possible for the other?





To get you started on the last one, consider the following case:

If 1 tuning fork has a frequency of 5 hz and a second one has a tuning frequency of 8 hz, then you would hear a beat frequency of 3 hz. So, the beat frequency is related to the difference of each of the individual frequencies. Likewise if a 5 hz tuning fork and a 2 hz truning fork were placed near each other, you would also hear a beat freuency of 3 hz.
 
lavafrog said:
Hi...I'm studying for a test on soundwaves tomorrow, and I have questions on a few problems my teacher never reviewed. I'd appreciate it if someone could even answer one of them. Thanks!

1) At rest, a car's horn sounds the note A (440Hz). The horn is sounded while the car is moving down the street. A bicyclist moving in the same direction with one third the car's speed hears a frequency of 415. How fast is the car moving? Is the bicyclist ahead of or behind the car? T=20C. (Based on the fact that the biker hears a lower frequency than the actual frequency, I've determined that he's behind the car.)

I've found the velocity of sound in these conditions to be 343m/s. Then I used this equation: (f'=frequency heard, f=actual frequency, v=velocity of sound in air, vo=velocity of observer, vs=velocity of the source, or car, +/- is used because it's - on top and + on bottom when the source is going away from you, and + on top and - on bottom when it's coming towards you.)

f'=f(v+/-vo/v+/-vs)

415Hz=440Hz(343m/s-(1/3)vs/343m/s+vs) (Sorry I can't write it out any neater than that, but I don't know how to use the right symbols.)

When I solve the equation for vs, I get 15.35m/s, but the answer is supposed to be 31m/s! Why am I off by a factor of two?
the bike is behind the car (since tje frequency heard is lower) So your sign in the numerator shoudl be a + not a minus.
 
The bike encounters 415 waves/s, as it moves into the waves;
so the wavelength in the air must be
lambda = (v_sound + v_bike)/415 [wave/s] .
The waves emitted at the car were stretched by the car motion, to be
lambda = (v_sound + v_car)/440 [wave/s]
 
OK, I understand that my biker is moving towards the source, so the top should have a +. But then for the bottom, is it + because my source is moving away from my observer? (I know it's +, I just want to make sure that's the right reason.)

abercrombiems02--Thanks!
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
5K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
20
Views
5K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 33 ·
2
Replies
33
Views
4K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
7K