Capacitance between human body and ground

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the phenomenon of capacitance between the human body and the ground, particularly in relation to the operation of voltage testers. Participants explore how capacitance may allow a voltage tester to activate even when insulated from the ground and question the effectiveness of electrical hazard safety shoes in this context.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant questions whether the activation of a voltage tester while insulated from the ground is due to capacitance between the human body and the ground, likening it to a capacitor's behavior.
  • Another participant suggests that the capacitance is between the human body and various surrounding objects, noting that while the capacitance is small, it can still produce sufficient current to light the tester.
  • A participant observes that the tiny current generated is enough to make the tester glow brightly, similar to when standing on the ground without shoes.
  • Concerns are raised about the effectiveness of insulated safety shoes in preventing current flow, with a participant expressing uncertainty about their performance in conjunction with a voltage tester.
  • Some participants mention that voltage testers typically include high ohm resistors to limit current to safe levels and protect the internal components.
  • One participant reflects on the reliability of voltage testers, sharing personal experiences with their functionality and questioning their trustworthiness.
  • A technical analysis is presented regarding the relationship between current, voltage, and capacitance, suggesting that even small capacitance values can produce noticeable effects under certain conditions.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of views on the role of capacitance in the operation of voltage testers and the effectiveness of safety shoes. There is no consensus on the exact mechanisms at play or the reliability of the testers discussed.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note that the discussion lacks specific details about the testing situations and the types of testers used, which may influence the interpretations of the results. Additionally, the calculations regarding current and capacitance are acknowledged as potentially approximate.

QwertyXP
Messages
66
Reaction score
0
Why does a voltage tester (that looks like a screwdriver) turn on even when you are "heavily" insulated from the ground e.g. sitting on a wooden chair.
Is it the result of capacitance between the human body and the ground? (i.e. the body and the ground act as conductors, whereas the insulated gap between them behaves as a dielectric does in a capacitor.)
If capacitance can cause the tester to glow, how then do insulated/EH (electrical hazard) safety shoes work? I don't have those shoes yet so didnt get the chance to use a tester while wearing them. But I was wondering why capacitance doesn't cause current to flow through the human body when wearing those shoes?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
The capacitance is "human body against everything else" - floor, walls, ceiling, whatever is in the room (and even in free space, a body has a capacitance).
The capacitance is tiny, and therefore the currents are tiny as well. Safety shoes protect you from larger currents.
 
But the tiny current was sufficient to make the tester glow quite brightly - about as bright as you see when you're standing on ground with no shoes!
 
QwertyXP said:
Why does a voltage tester (that looks like a screwdriver) turn on even when you are "heavily" insulated from the ground e.g. sitting on a wooden chair.
Is it the result of capacitance between the human body and the ground? (i.e. the body and the ground act as conductors, whereas the insulated gap between them behaves as a dielectric does in a capacitor.)
If capacitance can cause the tester to glow, how then do insulated/EH (electrical hazard) safety shoes work? I don't have those shoes yet so didnt get the chance to use a tester while wearing them. But I was wondering why capacitance doesn't cause current to flow through the human body when wearing those shoes?

QwertyXP said:
But the tiny current was sufficient to make the tester glow quite brightly - about as bright as you see when you're standing on ground with no shoes!

It's a bit hard to help you answer this question without a lot more information about your test situation. Can you post what tester you were using, and what exactly were the test situations you tried (Where did it not light up, where did it light up, etc.)?
 
Such testers that I've seen include a high ohm resistor that limits the current to less than you can feel. It also protects the neon lamp.
 
I think the one the OP means does not even use metal to metal contact. I used to have one. Lost track of it for a while and now it does not work. Soooooo, it was rather pointless to start with. If I can't trust it to light up then why would I trust a new one?
 
jim hardy said:
Such testers that I've seen include a high ohm resistor that limits the current to less than you can feel. It also protects the neon lamp.

yup likewise Jim and sounds like what the OP is describing
Haven't owned one for years but they are effective :)
With the high resistance in the screwdriver tester body and the high resistance of the person to ground via shoes and sox there's still enough current to light the neon globe

cheers
Dave
 
QwertyXP said:
But the tiny current was sufficient to make the tester glow quite brightly - about as bright as you see when you're standing on ground with no shoes!
You can get some visible light with 1mW. At 100 V, that corresponds to 10µA. Below 1mA, it is hard to feel a current, so we have a safety factor of two orders of magnitude.

To get 10µA over 10ms (50 Hz, similar value for 60 Hz) with 100V, you just need 100nC or a capacitance of ~1nC. Give or take a factor of two as I did not do this calculation properly, this is a small capacitance value.
To get the same as DC current, you need a corresponding resistor of 10MOhm. Regular shoes, the floor, and various other objects have a higher resistance, so DC current is probably negligible.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
7K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
83K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
10
Views
5K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • · Replies 71 ·
3
Replies
71
Views
17K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
1K