Computing the second fundamental form - can you spot the error?

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
docnet
Messages
796
Reaction score
487
Homework Statement
Compute the second fundamental form of the surface.
Relevant Equations
Standard differential geometry formulas for the second fundamental form with Christoffel symbols.
Hi all. We are computing the second fundamental form corresponding to a surface.

The correct answer should give the coefficients 2, 0, and -2 for IIuu, IIuv, IIvv

We have only been able to compute IIz, and not IIx, IIy where we have functions instead of 2, 0 and -2.

We are 99% certain that everything up to the da component in part (e.) is correct. It is just in the last computations where an apparent errors are. Can you see where the error is in part g?
Handwritten notes titled Ennepe's surface with a sketch of a surface; parametrisation x = u(1 - u^2/3 + v^2), y = v(1 - v^2/3 + u^2), z = u^2 - v^2, and boxed differentials dx = (1 + v^2 - u^2)du + 2uv dv, dy = 2uv du + (1 - v^2 + u^2)dv, dz = 2u du - 2v dv.


Handwritten derivation on ruled paper: dx², dy², dz² expanded in du and dv, summed into a metric with du² and dv² coefficients, boxed and simplified to (1+u²+v²)²(du²+dv²).

Handwritten notes: metric tensor G with diagonal entries (1-u^2+v^2)^2+4u^2v^2+4u^2 and its inverse, then sqrt(det g) as the square root of the product of diagonal entries, and an integral of [(1-u^2+v^2)^2+4u^2v^2+4u^2] du dv over -2 to 2.

Handwritten calculus working: an antiderivative in v evaluated from -2 to 2, then the result 11728/45 units squared, stated as the area of the image of the square -2 ≤ u ≤ 2, -2 ≤ v ≤ 2.


Handwritten Christoffel symbol calculations, labelled 5, with four rows of fractions: each gives a Christoffel symbol as one-half of g inverse times a partial derivative of a metric component, with numerators in u and v and denominators 2((1-u^2+v^2)^2+4u^2v^2+4u^2), simplifying to 2u, 2v, -2u and -2v over (1+u^2+v^2).

Handwritten working computing Christoffel-based second fundamental form components II_uu, II_uv, II_vv for x, y and z, with results such as -4u/(1+u^2+v^2), 0, and 2 - 4(u^2-v^2)/(1+u^2+v^2).


In part g, the II's corresponding to x and y should be the same as z. It seems like something is missing, perhaps. The second fundamental form were calculated using the following formula.
Formula for the second fundamental form in local coordinates: II with indices ij and superscript alpha equals the second partial derivative of y^alpha with respect to x^i and x^j, minus Gamma with indices ij and superscript p times the first partial derivative of y^alpha with respect to x^p.


Thank you!
 
Last edited:
I am replying to this thread so it no longer shows up on the "unanswered threads" list